There is a new pizza place in town Annangelos Pizza Factory . Located in West Seneca/Cheektowaga French and Borden. Family owned and operated, they use nothing but top quality ingredients,offering homemade soups all the food is delicious. The service is excellent and always smiling.
Rachelle - 7 years ago
Williamsville - Muscarella's
Grand Island - Just Pizza
Depew - Grasso's or Picasso's
NT- Lumber City Or Good Guys
Town of Tonawanda - (still searching)
Kenmore (still searching)
City of Tonawanda - Joe's NY Style, TC
Wheelers for specialty pizza
North Buffalo - Daddios
Geoff - 7 years ago
The best pizza in WNY is hands down....LAHACIENDA BRIGHTON!!!! Every time I am back in WNY I make it a priority to stop in and enjoy the pizza. The owner and staff make you feel like you are at home. Great pizza, great people. What more do you need?
Joe - 7 years ago
For me:
Niagara County Best = Molinaro's in Lockport w/ either traditional or semi-sweet sauce
Erie County Best = Grasso's in Depew.
I find Imperial is extremely over rated and WAY over priced.
Nino's is hit and miss depending on the kids working that day.
La Nova, Leonardi's, Franco's, Bocce, and Imperial are all virtually the same...thick paste like sauce, not enough cheese and too much dough. They're like saying Duffs or Anchor bar has the best wings. (not even close)
Nicky - 7 years ago
Gino& Joes and Joe's pizzeria are the best. Gino&Joes main place mall downstairs, and Joes have two locations, one in Grant st by Buffalo State and the other one is in Tonawanda. If you like NY style pizza, if not stick with La-NOva and other nasty stuff.
Pat - 7 years ago
Did someone from Buffalo have any input on this list? Was it some college intern from Long Island? C'mon man! No Imperial? How about Bella? Poorly selected list.
I.P Freely - 7 years ago
Lovejoy Pizza is killing it with 46% of vote!!!!
Frank - 7 years ago
One pie pizza co in Cheektowaga is killing it! Always amazing!!
Cindy - 7 years ago
Imperial South Buffalo. How could they not make this list !!!!
Sean - 7 years ago
Bella Pizza ????
Greg - 7 years ago
Leonardi's, Joey's (Depew), Santora's PP&G
David bastian - 7 years ago
Obviously this was a weak poll.wheres Lovejoy Pizza??
David Kennedy - 7 years ago
Top 3 have to be Pasqualies, Imperial, and maybe Bocce but they used to be great. Who made this top ten list? They definitely not a Buffalonian. Half of this list is crap pizza. Might as well list pizza hut and dominoes.
Cait - 7 years ago
How is Imperial (on Abbot in So Buffalo) Not on this list?
Tony - 7 years ago
Imperial
Marcy - 7 years ago
Bella Pizza!!!!
Diane Luby - 7 years ago
IMPERIAL....Abbott Road ????
Kathy - 7 years ago
Definitely Imperial the best!!
Kelly - 7 years ago
Lovejoy Pizzeria should have made this list!!!! Fantastic pizza options and exceptional service!!!!
Chris - 7 years ago
I can't believe you didn't list Imperial Pizza in the list. They will probably get more votes than most on the list
diana marotto - 7 years ago
They use fresh mushrooms and they are very generous with their toppings. I'm a veggie but my husband isn't. We both get what we want. When our daughter comes in from Chicago, the first thing we order is a Picasso's. She's a veggie also.❤️????
La Nova
Hands down. Tried others but they don't EVEN COME CLOSE. They have all the ingredients. Even anchovies.
After all eating pizza without anchovies, is like Oreo cookies without the creamy filling
Tamera L Lorenzo-Amidon - 7 years ago
Why isn't Mister Pizza on this list?? They are the best and considered by most on the Westside of Buffalo as the best! La Novas is terrible. Quality of food has gone down immensely in recent year. You guys gotta get in together...
I've eaten pizza from just about every pizza joint in Western New York throughout the days.
Yes, perhaps I'm a pizza addict and I've been on the hunt for the #bestpizza in WNY and then I found https://www.wiseguysbuffalo.com/ who's got them all beat. Including LaNovas, and others who for some reason think are the best around. Not the case. #WiseGuys is the best. Matter of fact, there was a very extensive poll just taken by #AllWNYNews and Wise Guys blew the competition out of the water and was voted #BestPizzaInWNY - see for yourself online. Or just go experience the sweet perfection of Wise Guys and you'll be joining the #Mafia in no time at all!!???????? Happy Pizza Day Everyone!!!:-????????????????????
Rob - 7 years ago
BELLA PIZZA all locations is the BEST!!
Scotty - 7 years ago
Bella Pizza. The best in wny.
Alfred wall - 7 years ago
Pizza Oven in lkpt. I still drive from Lancaster to get that.
Wiseguys South Buffalo! Amazing pizza! Give them a try you won't regret it! So good!! 7168268406 https://www.wiseguysbuffalo.com/
Randu - 7 years ago
Pizza factory. Borden French rds Cheektowaga. Awesome pizza wings everything
Cathy - 7 years ago
to my taste Imperial Pizza is the best around I travel from Grand Island to South Buffalo to get it.
Michelle Young - 7 years ago
They have the best pizza when you see it your mouth starts to water
Tom McKim - 7 years ago
Good Guys in North Tonawanda is my Favorite in WNY. I live in Virginia now, but always stop agGood Guys when I get back to NT.
Dominic Mariotti - 7 years ago
Brunners in North Boston has a great selection & is a family type eatery. You can Google their menu.
Adeline Danahy - 7 years ago
Brick Oven Bistro has an excellent assortment of pizzas that are hands down the best in WNY!
Pat - 7 years ago
Olisi's is the finest tasting pizza in W. New York located on Sheridan Dr... Always the dame very good tasting, at a good price. I am not owner. Just think they are best. Bocce I feel has always been over rated
There is a new pizza place in town Annangelos Pizza Factory . Located in West Seneca/Cheektowaga French and Borden. Family owned and operated, they use nothing but top quality ingredients,offering homemade soups all the food is delicious. The service is excellent and always smiling.
Williamsville - Muscarella's
Grand Island - Just Pizza
Depew - Grasso's or Picasso's
NT- Lumber City Or Good Guys
Town of Tonawanda - (still searching)
Kenmore (still searching)
City of Tonawanda - Joe's NY Style, TC
Wheelers for specialty pizza
North Buffalo - Daddios
The best pizza in WNY is hands down....LAHACIENDA BRIGHTON!!!! Every time I am back in WNY I make it a priority to stop in and enjoy the pizza. The owner and staff make you feel like you are at home. Great pizza, great people. What more do you need?
For me:
Niagara County Best = Molinaro's in Lockport w/ either traditional or semi-sweet sauce
Erie County Best = Grasso's in Depew.
I find Imperial is extremely over rated and WAY over priced.
Nino's is hit and miss depending on the kids working that day.
La Nova, Leonardi's, Franco's, Bocce, and Imperial are all virtually the same...thick paste like sauce, not enough cheese and too much dough. They're like saying Duffs or Anchor bar has the best wings. (not even close)
Gino& Joes and Joe's pizzeria are the best. Gino&Joes main place mall downstairs, and Joes have two locations, one in Grant st by Buffalo State and the other one is in Tonawanda. If you like NY style pizza, if not stick with La-NOva and other nasty stuff.
Did someone from Buffalo have any input on this list? Was it some college intern from Long Island? C'mon man! No Imperial? How about Bella? Poorly selected list.
Lovejoy Pizza is killing it with 46% of vote!!!!
One pie pizza co in Cheektowaga is killing it! Always amazing!!
Imperial South Buffalo. How could they not make this list !!!!
Bella Pizza ????
Leonardi's, Joey's (Depew), Santora's PP&G
Obviously this was a weak poll.wheres Lovejoy Pizza??
Top 3 have to be Pasqualies, Imperial, and maybe Bocce but they used to be great. Who made this top ten list? They definitely not a Buffalonian. Half of this list is crap pizza. Might as well list pizza hut and dominoes.
How is Imperial (on Abbot in So Buffalo) Not on this list?
Imperial
Bella Pizza!!!!
IMPERIAL....Abbott Road ????
Definitely Imperial the best!!
Lovejoy Pizzeria should have made this list!!!! Fantastic pizza options and exceptional service!!!!
I can't believe you didn't list Imperial Pizza in the list. They will probably get more votes than most on the list
They use fresh mushrooms and they are very generous with their toppings. I'm a veggie but my husband isn't. We both get what we want. When our daughter comes in from Chicago, the first thing we order is a Picasso's. She's a veggie also.❤️????
La Nova
Hands down. Tried others but they don't EVEN COME CLOSE. They have all the ingredients. Even anchovies.
After all eating pizza without anchovies, is like Oreo cookies without the creamy filling
Why isn't Mister Pizza on this list?? They are the best and considered by most on the Westside of Buffalo as the best! La Novas is terrible. Quality of food has gone down immensely in recent year. You guys gotta get in together...
Love Love Love BELLA PIZZA!
I've eaten pizza from just about every pizza joint in Western New York throughout the days.
Yes, perhaps I'm a pizza addict and I've been on the hunt for the #bestpizza in WNY and then I found https://www.wiseguysbuffalo.com/ who's got them all beat. Including LaNovas, and others who for some reason think are the best around. Not the case. #WiseGuys is the best. Matter of fact, there was a very extensive poll just taken by #AllWNYNews and Wise Guys blew the competition out of the water and was voted #BestPizzaInWNY - see for yourself online. Or just go experience the sweet perfection of Wise Guys and you'll be joining the #Mafia in no time at all!!???????? Happy Pizza Day Everyone!!!:-????????????????????
BELLA PIZZA all locations is the BEST!!
Bella Pizza. The best in wny.
Pizza Oven in lkpt. I still drive from Lancaster to get that.
Imperial Pizza in South Buffalo is the best.
Imperial Pizza in South Buffalo is the best.
Wiseguys South Buffalo! Amazing pizza! Give them a try you won't regret it! So good!! 7168268406 https://www.wiseguysbuffalo.com/
Pizza factory. Borden French rds Cheektowaga. Awesome pizza wings everything
to my taste Imperial Pizza is the best around I travel from Grand Island to South Buffalo to get it.
They have the best pizza when you see it your mouth starts to water
Good Guys in North Tonawanda is my Favorite in WNY. I live in Virginia now, but always stop agGood Guys when I get back to NT.
Brunners in North Boston has a great selection & is a family type eatery. You can Google their menu.
Brick Oven Bistro has an excellent assortment of pizzas that are hands down the best in WNY!
Olisi's is the finest tasting pizza in W. New York located on Sheridan Dr... Always the dame very good tasting, at a good price. I am not owner. Just think they are best. Bocce I feel has always been over rated