The 2018 Filmspotting Golden Brick should go to:

27 Comments

  • Ben Chung - 8 years ago

    First off, I want to commend Filmspotting for selecting 3 films by Asian-American directors for Golden Brick contention. I don't think this was a deliberate decision, but it hardly feels like a coincidence that some of the most bold and inventive cinematic visions of the year came from a group that has long been marginalized by the film industry. As an Asian-American lover of film having to endure endless praise for the by-the-books banality of Crazy Rich Asians, it was a delight to see that Asian-Americans were having a quieter but much more exciting moment in the world of independent film.

    That said, I found the omnipresent narration of Shirkers to be a bit exhausting and over-explanatory, and The Rider was a gorgeous film that left me a bit cold. I think the right choice for the Golden Brick, and my favorite film of the year is Minding the Gap. It was the most thought-provoking and emotional cinematic experience I had this year thanks to Bing Liu's fearlessly empathetic storytelling and remarkably instinctual direction. No fictional climax could match the gut punch that comes as the documentary's narrative threads culminate in a triptych of soul-baring revelations that left me in an absolute puddle of tears.

    Bing Liu's camera is a true empathy machine, always focusing in on the most uncomfortable person in any room, inviting the audience to understand what they're feeling and why they're feeling it. There is a version of this movie where Nina's side of the story is never told, where Liu's mother is no more than a co-conspirator to his victimhood, where we never see Keire's face while racist epithets are being relished nearby. In a film that so deeply explores cycles of abuse and their victims, Liu seems to have a preternatural understanding that, even in the most seemingly mundane moment, there might be a victim just at the edge of the frame.

    As a side note, if you read this aloud at the live show, my wife will be very impressed :)

  • Jack C. (Fort Collins, CO) - 8 years ago

    The Rider is an interesting exercise that is compelling in spurts but fails to make a case for its approach for me. The non-professional acting does no favors for an on-the-nose script that takes a true story and makes it feel contrived. I wanted to dig it, but was left scratching my head. Zhao has an eye, no doubt, but Liu made a Hoop Dreams level masterpiece for me. If directing is “making choices”, there isn’t a bad one made in Minding the Gap.

  • Steve Parsons - 8 years ago

    I had to go with THE RIDER, and as I did so I want to put in a plug for the TRUE/FALSE Film Festival in Columbia, Missouri. I saw both THE RIDER and SHIRKERS there last year and, honestly, neither of them was even my favorite of the Fest. The Festival is that good.

  • Alfredo Maldonado JR - 8 years ago

    Hi this Alfredo. First time leaving a comment. I live in Berwyn, IL. I saw The Rider, Minding the Gap and and Shirkers. I was blown away by all three.

    I mean what's more real than the father in The Rider telling his son to be this and that but when it comes down to it, as a father, who wants to see their kid get hurt? That scene where the rider calls out his father on his inconsistencies, is gold! It's such an American movie of an America that I never get to see. I saw it this time and I loved it.

    As an insurance salesman, and I heard what you and Michael said about being a salesman Adam, lol, I get to travel the country. All over the place I run into young people like the protagonists in Minding the Gap and they're beautiful. They're working hard but not getting paid enough, figuring life out but still got a lot to learn and they almost all seem unaware of the seriousness that they're in the middle off, w.r.t. life. I hope the best for them, a place where they're making enough, have it figured out and have plenty of time to skateboard.

    Shirkers was like one of those bad evening news stories where some crazy person walked out with a new born out of some hospital nursery room. And, all that was left is a bad resolution shot of the culprit turning the corner with they're back to us and our protagonists, and getting away. All I can say is what a wild ride ensues. I couldn't guess what this sorry was gonna be about. Also, I couldn't help to wonder what could've been. But at least Shirkers made it back to it's mother, per se, and we can only hope that they live happily ever after.

    I'd say give the golden brick to all three. I mean Adam and Josh, especially Adam, usually make the rules up as they go anyhow, JK. But, right?

    But, if I had to go with one, and I already voted. I went with Minding the Gap because I see America everyday and that's what I see. Single mothers, drama, good people who deserve better and so on. And, I want them to win.

    Thank you guys. Love your show.

  • Drew - 8 years ago

    My vote is for The Rider, which just rounded out my viewings of the nominees. For me, Shirkers never quite reached what it was aiming for and Minding the Gap unfortunately didn't affect me the way it did so many others. The Rider, though, hit me right in the heart and kept me captivated throughout. The bigger story for me personally, however, is simply that I've watched all three of these films. After years as a film buff, my interest in movies waned several years ago as other areas of my life took precedence. I happened upon the Filmspotting podcast a couple of months ago and my love of the cinema has reemerged as I've listened to your discussions and been inspired to get back in the game. So, I write to say thanks for helping reignite the flame of movie-watching for this recovering film junkie!

    Drew
    Franklin, Tennessee

  • Brian - 8 years ago

    Listening from Havertown, PA & first time leaving feedback (been listening for close to two years), so this is exciting!

    I have a feeling it will be a solid third place, but just want to say that SHIRKERS is probably one of my favorites of the year and by far the most overlooked movie of 2018. But all three options were worthwhile and made this a tough decision!

  • Trey in RVA - 8 years ago

    All three films are worthy for consideration however the Golden Brick is as much a prospective award add one that recognises a quality first film. Given that, I think Chloé Zhao's The Rider wins for me. It's arguable that Liu's visual style could lead to amazing things but my concern is that both Shirkers and Minding the Gap are such profoundly personal stories that I am less confident that they can transfer those filmmaking skills to a new story. No disrespect to either other films.

  • Phillip - 8 years ago

    I'd be happy if any of these three won, so congrats on such fine Golden Brick choices this year! I consider awards such as these encouragement to filmmakers, and as Shirkers and Minding the Gap seem so intertwined with the lives of their directors, I don't have a strong sense of what they would potentially want to next bring to the cinematic table. So, while the inventive editing and sound design of Shirkers delighted me and the gorgeously filmed honesty of Minding the Gap brought me to tears, I'm voting for Chloé Zhao's The Rider, because I look forward to seeing what other subjects and stories she may try to fit into her breathtakingly unique docu-narrative approach.

  • Higgins - 8 years ago

    Both films are in my top 10 but The Rider edges Minding the Gap cinematically. I wish they could tie.

  • Keil S. - 8 years ago

    Toss-up between a The Rider and Minding the Gap, but I ultimately gave it to MtG. Enjoyed Shirkers as well, but I feel that was more setup and not enough follow-through. Either way, I’m just surprised that I’ve seen all 3 of these — mostly because I was a very busy first-time father this year. At least whatever wins will be a good movie.

  • Steven - 8 years ago

    Once again (as with The Florida Project), I find myself shaking my head at the critical adulation for awful-to-the-point-of-distraction performances by non-professional actors. My vote: any film other than The Rider.

  • Joshua G - 8 years ago

    THE RIDER is a beautiful piece of meditative filmmaking. SHIRKERS is a fascinating trip through a "too weird to be true" story of memory and nostalgia. But MINDING THE GAP is a film about skateboarding, then class struggles, then masculinity and paternal failure and its lasting effect. Not many films (let alone documentaries) can shift my view toward one of its subjects so drastically within its running time like this one does. Liu's clever editing and his necessary involvement as a subject as well as the filmmaker makes for one of the most engaging experiences I had watching a movie this year.

  • Laura - 8 years ago

    I have to say that I find it annoying that Minding the Gap is only available on Hulu. It did not play in any theater within 400 miles of where I live. We already subscribe to Netflix, HBO, and Amazon as well as DirectTV, plus we live near two theaters that show independent and foreign films.. We are overflowing with good quality content and can only watch a fraction of it. We are not taking on another subscription service!

    I should have abstained, I know, but I loved The Rider so much that I voted for it anyway.

  • Beat Cadruvi - 8 years ago

    I loved "Shirkers", but "The Rider" was my no. 1 movie of the year, so I obviously have to vote for it (haven't seen "Minding The Gap"). It's a little disappointing that Chloé Zhao has already moved onto a superhero movie.

  • Mike H. - 8 years ago

    I absolutely loved THE RIDER and haven't gotten around to seeing Minding the Gap yet, but I didn't hesitate even for a split second throwing my vote in for SHIRKERS. I haven't seen it on many year-end lists, but it is close to topping mine.

    It captures something fundamental about art on the fringes, creatively and geographically. While it's ostensibly about an indie film getting made on a shoestring budget, which is a category of quirky doc we are all familiar with.....in a way it's almost more important that these young girls had a punk zine than it is that they made a movie. There's another message than just the medium. It's like digging through crates of vinyl records and finding some obscure Iranian psych rock record from 1964 that gives you a sudden moment of awe when you consider the scope of culture and community and musical "scenes" happening at any given time, of which you are completely unaware but changed the lives of everyone who experienced them. And by contrast, it points to the absolute bankruptcy and robbery of being limited to this tiny fraction of corporate-approved western creative output.

    You can view this film as another "lost great amateur film" narrative, which it is, but I see it almost more as a companion piece to something like the Coen Brothers' "Inside Llewyn Davis". There are thousands of "Shirkers" out there, in Jakarta and Somalia and Hungary and Peru. Just as there are countless lost classic novels we'll never get to read, and countless incredible musicians who died penniless in the Mississippi Delta or Algeria who we'll never get to hear. Not because of any lack of talent or worth, but purely because of structural limitations and accidents of luck. Or outright theft. And that's why we dig through crates.

  • Evan - 8 years ago

    In watching Shirkers today I caught finally have seen all 3 nominees. While Chloe Zhao’s THE RIDER is perhaps the most impressive filmmaking and Sandi Tan’s SHIRKERS the most interesting plot, it was Bing Liu and his debut MINDING THE GAP that elicited the most emotion. Liu takes a measured look at the delicate subject of domestic violence and then turns the mirror on himself to explore its effects on his life. For that, MINDING THE GAP is one of the most honest pieces of filmmaking this year.

    While it’s too late for Brick consideration, I wanted to shoutout another overlooked film streaming now on Amazon Prime. Christina Choe’s debut feature NANCY is every bit as intricately pieced together as THE RIDER and as evocative as MINDING THE GAP. Since this is a space recognizing overlooked films of the year I thought I would give a shout-out to one of my favorites!

  • Adam - 8 years ago

    When I've voted on the Golden Brick in the past, I just went with the movie I liked the best. I decided to change my approach this time around.
    I did use the definition of the award--overlooked and underseen--as an informative tool, but I also added my own personal distinction to it.
    If I was just voting based on preference, THE RIDER would be my choice. But I also know that Chloe Zhao has been rewarded for her beautiful movie by getting a biopic about Bass Reeves greenlit and she's hopefully going to impact the Marvel Universe with the Eternals like Ryan Coogler did with Black Panther.
    Knowing that Zhao seems to be taken care of for the foreseeable future, MINDING THE GAP got my vote because it seems easier to overlook documentaries in year-end awards. It's also a movie I want to win something since I'm 99 percent sure the Academy will reward the very good but far more accessible WON'T YOU BE MY NEIGHBOR? with the Best Documentary prize. And Bing Liu's work in MINDING THE GAP--in front of and behind the camera--and as a segment director on AMERICA TO ME really deserves more accolades.

  • I see the pain and emotional agony of Filmspotting Madness is starting early. I . . . voted for one of these films because that's how polls are, but each of these films is profoundly worthy. These films are all so inspired visually, but in such completely different ways that it makes a mockery of having to vote for just one. THE RIDER is so richly evocative of the American West and so profoundly compassionate in its gaze, while SHIRKERS is simultaneously clinical and weird, and MINDING THE GAP is so inspired by motion and patience at the same time . . .

    All of these films also clearly demonstrate a high degree of personal bravery that adds so much to the stakes of watching the films. Sandi Tan is almost clinical in her ability to her criticism of her younger self in Shirkers, Bing Liu has the nous and the patience to watch and listen to his friends for years and to make a film that is invested in so so much more than when his project started. And Chloe Zhao centers Brady's search for a core identity other than the one that has informed his entire life in THE RIDER. It's an impossible choice.

    Ultimately, it seems like a shame that a single film has to win the Golden Brick because all three of these films are so completely excellent at everything we want out of a film: they are moving, visually arresting, fascinating, and their stakes could not be any higher. I look forward to whatever it is that all of these filmmakers do in the future. I'm so grateful that Filmspotting championed each of these films and my life is definitively richer for having seen all of them.

  • This was a tough call... because "Minding the Gap," is THE Filmspotting film of the year. Like "Columbus," last year, I think it's safe to say the majority of listeners voting in this poll would have completely missed this gem without the enthusiastic recommendation of the show. Plus, few shots screamed "promising young talent" quite like the gliding takes Bing Liu captured, riding behind his skater friends through the suspiciously empty Rockford streets.

    And yet, I'm voting for the Rider, because it shares a soul with my stubbornly-held number-one film of the year "Leave No Trace." Because it's honest-to-God the first truly great new film I saw this year, and it's hard to let go of things like that. Because Chloé Zhao's promise is so much more mysterious to me – she could go anywhere next and it wouldn't surprise me. And because, in these red-vs-blue times, it made me look at a way of life I'd never have investigated on my own with honesty and kindness.

    But, I'd be happy if any of these three won. Kudos for getting me to watch "Shirkers" by making it a finalist. I wish I was as cool as Sandi Tan was in her teens.

  • Lucas Muratore - 8 years ago

    What makes Minding The Gap so special is not it's cinematography, its dedication to telling a story about abuse, or even the time taken to tell a story spanning so many years; it's director Bing Liu's ability to push personal vanity aside and tell a story so personal to him and his two friends that, if told incorrectly, could ostracize him from the very community that he sought to help.

    A key moment in the film is when he goes to interview his mother and has a second cameraman follow him into. Recognizing the importance of his part in this overall narrative he put's his own relationship with his mother on the line, because he knows it will give him credibility as a storyteller, AND will help his mother realize the abuse that Bing experienced as a child and MOVE PAST IT.

    Like Bing said in his interview hosted by Adam, the thing we have to do to solve this issue of domestic abuse is have uncomfortable conversations. And this practice is something echoed throughout his film, wether it's confronting his mother about his step-dad, asking Nina how to talk about Zack's abuse, or even finally confronting Zack about beating Nina. It not only makes for a great story but it makes Bing a fearless activist, and someone who puts his money where his mouth is, not backing down when things might get uncomfortable.

    I haven't seen a movie all year that showed characters change this much, made me weep this much, or made me want to get up and change the world. That's why this doesn't just deserve the golden brick award - it's the best god damn film of 2018. Come at me.

    -Lucas Muratore
    Tallahassee, FL

  • Jalal - 8 years ago

    My vote would have gone to Madeline’s Madeline. The incredibly unnerving ending added to its powerful portrayal of mental illness. No film has stuck with me this year quite like this.

    Of the options in the poll I voted for Shirkers.

  • Michael Green - 8 years ago

    So far in 2018 I have seen some very good films, but nothing has moved and mesmerized me like Minding the Gap. Bing Liu’s documentary takes you into the lives of three young skateboarders, but gives the viewer more to chew with. Liu questions masculinity, youth, growing up, fatherhood, race, being a child in a broken home, abuse and the meaning of life. Few documentaries have enthralled me like this. Like Salesman we see the inner workings of humans, and like Gates of Heaven Liu questions the meaning of life itself. Masterfully shot, the cinamatography is gorgeous, editing is top notch and the music is perfect and unobtrusive. Perfect and worth 90 minutes.

  • Adam Grossman - 8 years ago

    For me, the Golden Brick award should go to a movie each year which is not just one of the year’s best by a debut director but, simply, one of the best movies of the year, period. In 2018, the right choice is ‘Minding the Gap’.

    As with last year’s ‘Columbus’, I was introduced to ‘Minding the Gap’ through Filmspotting and I am just as grateful as I was with Kogonada’s debut feature.

    Bing Liu’s debut is a transcendent piece of filmmaking - a documentary which, on the surface, seems to be about some skateboarding youths, soon turns in to an incredible statement on the passage of time from childhood to teens to young adulthood… and then it becomes so much more than that.

    At times, it brings to mind Richard Linklater’s ‘Boyhood’ but, knowing this is real life, it made my heart ache for Bing, Keire, Zack and Nina, that much more. At the epilogue, I wept, and hoped their futures are good ones.

  • Adam - 8 years ago

    I thought nothing could beat The Rider until I saw Minding the Gap. By far my favourite film of the year!

  • Jeff Nohl - 8 years ago

    I voted for The Rider because it grabbed me more emotionally than the other films. It really made you feel the loss of potential and the false hope that an impossible situation will change. Shirkers was interesting but in the end my reaction was "I can't believe you didn't go to see what was going on for years when all signs pointed to a problem. What is wrong with you?" I had the least reaction to Minding the Gap since it is not available for viewing where I live. I researched the release date and it only came out limited in Aug. and is now on HULU which I don't subscribe to. I quess I question whether it should be eligible for a Golden Brick given that it wasn't released wide in 2018. Many people cannot see it.

  • Timothy - 8 years ago

    SHIRKERS is a moving, introspective self-study that’s commendable and fresh. MINDING THE GAP is even more moving, even more instrospective - full of sharp turns and breathtaking moments. I would not denigrate any year-end list that includes one or both of those films.

    ... but THE RIDER is something more. A magnificently Truthful, Life-full achievement. I openly wept no less than four times during my first watch, and I am still haunted now more than 7 months and hundreds of films later. Chloe Zhao has a vision and soul for filmmaking unlike anything I have ever seen. I wish the best for Tan and Liu’s careers and will watch them with interest, but for me Zhao has already vaulted to the upper echelon of contemporary artists.

    No film can be for everyone, and in fact universal praise might be a sign that more risks need to be taken. I really, truly do not begrudge or intend to insult anyone who doesn’t see THE RIDER like I do. I firmly support every person’s right to experience and love or not love any work as fits them. But there’s no no-person I love more than cinema. It is the foundation of my emotional, intellectual, and spiritual growth. I see the world by and through cinema. And after nearly 500 new-to-me films in this year, not one has impacted me in the same way as THE RIDER, a new masterpiece of film. I can’t not vote for it.

  • Zach - 8 years ago

    If THE RIDER beats MINDING THE GAP, I will... well, nothing. Continue listening to the show anyway. But I'll be disappointed. I know THE RIDER is Sam's favorite film of the year, but when I think about Golden Bricks and how bold and vanguard-ish they are... Bing Liu's film really deserves the honor. Zhao's movie doesn't have the directorial rigor and zeal that the best GBs have. MINDING THE GAP, however. fuses thrilling, visceral images with the substantial character study of its heartbreaking subjects. For every bit of the first 40 minutes of THE RIDER (after which I had to give up on it), I was looking at film-school level blocking and writing -- terrible exposition, cloying storytelling. But from minute one until the end of Liu's deeply profound skateboard documentary, I was looking at a real talent behind the lens.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment