Birdman is the clear winner here. The use of sound alone is a remarkable feat. This film is a must contender for 2010s. I am surprised to see it even shortlisted.
Michael Green Dover DE - 5 years ago
My gut just says Birdman, I have seen both only once and decided if I were forced to choose to sit and see either of these again I was more intrigued with the thought of seeing Birdman.
Albert from Pasadena - 5 years ago
Innaritu is no doubt a great filmmaker and the cinematography in both those films are outstanding. I choose The Revenant because it at least tells a coherent story about revenge whereas Birdman has nothing really to say and I hate every character in that film.
Joe Osborn - 5 years ago
I voted for The Revenant because it is less insufferable, but shouldn't there be a 'Neither' option for this poll???
Luís Ferreira, Portugal - 5 years ago
Iñarritu is one of my favourite working directors and I'm a little bit sad that he doesn't get much love on the show. I think both are great movies but for me Birdman is truly one of the best movies of the decade and more than just a gimmick. Saying that, I will vote Birdman although I would put both movies in the shortlist.
Love from Portugal
J - 5 years ago
Both of these movies are bad, but only one of them is insufferable, so I guess I'll go with the bear one
Corey Craft, Birmingham, AL - 5 years ago
Where’s the option for “neither merits inclusion in any best-of list and both deserve to be heaved in the furnace alongside everything else Inarritu has ever made”?
Phil H - 5 years ago
Not sure why it’s even a question if Birdman should be shortlisted! It should be seeded. It’s great and a sweet 16 contender surely.
Phil H - 5 years ago
Not sure why it’s even a question if Birdman should be shortlisted! It should be seeded. It’s great and a sweet 16 contender surely.
Nathan, Victoria - 5 years ago
Neither.
Joseph Orlando - 5 years ago
Birdman, for the win.
Ben Chambers - 5 years ago
Not only is Birdman a great film, I just revisited it this week after extolling its virtues to some co-workers. Haven't heard anyone recommend the Revenant since it came out.
The masterpiece of Birdman vs. the beautiful but meh Oscar grab for Leo? I think the choice is obvious here. Birdman is still a film I constantly think of. Revenant is one I bought to show off my 4k TV and that's it.
Leave a Comment
Create your own.
Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.
Birdman is the clear winner here. The use of sound alone is a remarkable feat. This film is a must contender for 2010s. I am surprised to see it even shortlisted.
My gut just says Birdman, I have seen both only once and decided if I were forced to choose to sit and see either of these again I was more intrigued with the thought of seeing Birdman.
Innaritu is no doubt a great filmmaker and the cinematography in both those films are outstanding. I choose The Revenant because it at least tells a coherent story about revenge whereas Birdman has nothing really to say and I hate every character in that film.
I voted for The Revenant because it is less insufferable, but shouldn't there be a 'Neither' option for this poll???
Iñarritu is one of my favourite working directors and I'm a little bit sad that he doesn't get much love on the show. I think both are great movies but for me Birdman is truly one of the best movies of the decade and more than just a gimmick. Saying that, I will vote Birdman although I would put both movies in the shortlist.
Love from Portugal
Both of these movies are bad, but only one of them is insufferable, so I guess I'll go with the bear one
Where’s the option for “neither merits inclusion in any best-of list and both deserve to be heaved in the furnace alongside everything else Inarritu has ever made”?
Not sure why it’s even a question if Birdman should be shortlisted! It should be seeded. It’s great and a sweet 16 contender surely.
Not sure why it’s even a question if Birdman should be shortlisted! It should be seeded. It’s great and a sweet 16 contender surely.
Neither.
Birdman, for the win.
Not only is Birdman a great film, I just revisited it this week after extolling its virtues to some co-workers. Haven't heard anyone recommend the Revenant since it came out.
Pick the one with staying power.
The masterpiece of Birdman vs. the beautiful but meh Oscar grab for Leo? I think the choice is obvious here. Birdman is still a film I constantly think of. Revenant is one I bought to show off my 4k TV and that's it.