Should whispering during tribal council be banned?

17 Comments

  • Pat Rogers - 4 years ago

    I wish you wouldn't keep bring back the old players. They had their time. New blood.

  • SR - 4 years ago

    Silence between contestants at tribal council should be a rule. I find the whispering & running around to be very annoying & it takes away from the sanctity of the council.

  • Terry Lewis - 4 years ago

    I still love the show but please get rid of "Edge". It turned out to be bad idea the first time it appeared in a show so I can't understand why it was brought back. No whispering at Tribal. Make your decisions before you get there and let Jeff guide the Tribal process.

  • Rick - 4 years ago

    Tbh I like the whispers at tribal it shows an evolution of a game. If had the old tribal council it would be respective and people would complain. This shows based on upon Jeff's question who goes home. Trying to figure that out is never been cut and dry. If you don't know you to vote for and you think/feel you are out of the loop and on the bottom of your alliance. Sophie's alliance was going to vote out Jeremy he decided to used his power, who do vote for now? Should they have came up with a alternate person, that would be info if they assumed he an idol. The scrambling makes for good TV and offers an insight on a good blindside.

  • Norma - 4 years ago

    Hate the Edge of Distinction. Hate the whispers at tribal. Get back to what made this show so great. The contestants have to work for their million. I have NOT missed a single episode but it is getting so ridiculous that I am only watching from a Wednesday (used to be Thursday) night habit. I even record and watch later, that's how much it matters now. Get back to the basics and the players working at it.

  • Debra Moore - 4 years ago

    I would like to see a survivor with the 1st ones that were voted off and see how that turns out

  • G - 4 years ago

    How about a silent tribal council? That would be a new twist. Or another new twist ... how about if tribal council takes place IMMEDIATELY following immunity challenge?

  • Lynn - 4 years ago

    The whispers and sneaking around during Tribal Council makes the show fun to watch and keeps you at the edge of your seat because you think you know who’s getting voted out and then they change it up

  • JSnyder - 4 years ago

    Next season, let’s see “old school” rules
    You don’t see the players scrambling for food or water or finding protection from bugs and hear, sunburn or miserably cold and wet from the rain and wind like the beginning seasons showed.
    This show is called “Survivor” let’s get back to the basics and make this more true to its fight instead of all this glorified drama.
    I love this show!!
    I hope it doesn’t destroy itself.

  • Darlene Thomas - 4 years ago

    I don’t mind the scrambling they do at tribal. It’s just part of the game. It should be timed as to how much they can whisper. Jeff is good at putting a stop to all of it. This has been my all out favorite show since it’s beginning. Welcome back for Rob and Amber. They still are in love as much as they were when they began the show. I love watching them and how they look out for each other. Would like to see Rob and Amber back in the finals.

  • Sydia's Traveling Hair Salon - 4 years ago

    I watched Survivor since the beginning but lately not a fan. Not a fan of them Whispering at Council. Hope Boston Rob wins or that Indian girl Natalie.

  • Susan - 4 years ago

    I really like seeing all these previous players, and Edge of Extinction.........would love to see Rob back in. However, it is quite chaotic with all the advantages; and I agree, I think whispering during tribal council should not be allowed. Figure it out before you get there and vote. Plus, the Edge can go away. I will always be a Survivor Fan !!!! Haven't missed a season yet !.

  • Michael Howard - 4 years ago

    Thank you for this. Strategy is dead. Or at least killed by so many advantages and side whispers. And Edge has got to go. At this point whoever gets back in will automatically get all the current jury votes. WAY too much going on this season. I’d like to see the new school players play with no idols, no edge and see how good they are then.

  • Donna - 4 years ago

    Definitely cut out the whispering. Tribal council is too long and we could be watching more reward challenges.

  • Karen Hinton - 4 years ago

    All this whispering at tribal is BS. Make your mind up back at camp. Ive watched this show for years, but find myself makeing a snack at tribal and skipping the end of the show. RIDICULOUS! !!

  • Jn - 4 years ago

    Jeff looks out of place sitting there saying nothing while they do that . It cheapen the show and appears that they are hijacking the show.

  • Patrick Balogh - 4 years ago

    I've seen every episode of every season.
    My favorite show is now becoming unwatchable.
    The rediculous whispering and scrambling at Tribal is getting old, real fast.
    I have always looked forward to Tribal. Now I'm dreading it.
    If I have to continue to watch "my show" continue to decay into this unwatchable stupidity, I guess I'll be free on Wednesday nights at 8:00.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment