Should Elizabeth Choose Lucas or Nathan on When Calls the Heart?

109 Comments

  • Meg - 3 years ago

    It's obvious Lucas is attracted to Elizabeth and likes her quite a bit. However it's also obvious that Nathan is head over heels, stupid in love with Elizabeth. The way I interpret their time together, Nathan seems to give Elizabeth the time and space to feel what she needs to feel. He's very aware that she is a widow and whose widow she is. Might explain his hesitancy and awkwardness. That being said, the chemistry between the two of them is off the charts! They've both been left breathless and lost in one another's eyes. As for the argument as to Nathan's being a mountie and breaking her heart, come On! It is a show. With writers. Who choose the storyline. Nathan has to be the safest Mountie in all of Canada at this point!????

  • Chris S. - 3 years ago

    I think Nathan is the better choice. He can be a great father-figure to Baby Jack, as he already is to Allie. He challenges Elizabeth and he has a quiet strength about him that is captivating. Him and Elizabeth just seem to have such a beautiful and pure connection. Lucas is a nice guy, don’t get me wrong, but he seems a bit too worldly for Elizabeth. He doesn’t seem quite ready to settle down and raise a family. Nathan is the obvious choice in my opinion. He’s already amazing with Baby Jack and Elizabeth is obviously intrigued by him. I really hope she chooses him because I think their love story has the potential to be even more meaningful and beautiful than Elizabeth and Jack’s.

  • Donna Stall - 3 years ago

    No more mounties!!

  • Andrew Mark - 3 years ago

    Nathan is the one! The one who can break the spell!

  • Valerie - 3 years ago

    Lucas. Though I think the show will put her with Nathan. I don't like how jealous and brooding Nathan is. He's reacted poorly every time Elizabeth has an interaction with Lucas. I don't know why tv shows paint jealousy and brooding as romantic qualities, there's nothing wrong with not having drama in a relationship and knowing where you stand. Lucas has been very upfront and honest with his intentions, I think his character has undergone a lot more growth and he's been proving the sort of man he wants to be.

  • Bethany - 3 years ago

    This poll is bullshit I tried to vote for Jack and it doesn't count my vote ...

  • Nancy - 3 years ago

    I see no chemistry between Elizabeth and Nathan. And why would she ever get involved with another mountie? Nathan is awkward and no match for her. I definitely see chemistry between Lucas and Elizabeth.

  • Karen Thornton - 4 years ago

    Nathan is definitely the right choice. Elizabeth and Nathan have definitely had so much chemistry right from the very first time that they met. The looks they give each other is beautiful and has sparks flying. Can’t wait to watch them together after that loving Embrace at the end of season 7. Bring on season 8 and the Grant Family.

  • Naomi - 4 years ago

    You see Daniel, before I didn't understand what you were trying to say, and I thought you were team Lucas, and hated Nathan. For me, if Elizabeth had to chose, I would personally go for Nathan. But now since you have said she doesn't need anyone...I agree with that even more! I don't really see Elizabeth with anyone of the guys, they both don't seem her type. Elizabeth is such a strong women, and is capable of anything. She can handle anything on her own, and doesn't need to marry again. She also has so much support from Rosemary and Lee, and Bill would be a good "Father figure" when baby Jack grows up.

  • Daniel - 4 years ago

    Dear Naomi!
    Of course I'm from Team Jack. Who doesn't throw the first stone?
    But, dear, think about it a little: if the idea is to stay the same as before, why didn't the producers change only the actors? In that case, the story would be "like" the book.
    The point here is not Lucas or Nathan. The point is how strong and determined a woman like Elizabeth will get on with her life. And honestly, she doesn't need a man to be happy. As in real life, the series should explore the strong, virtuous, powerful and extraordinary side that women have in fighting for their rights and continuing their lives independent of a man to save them.

  • Daniel - 4 years ago

    Kkkkkk
    Hahahaha

  • Naomi - 4 years ago

    It seems Daniel is team Jack. He wish Jack didn't leave the show... Jack is a Mountie, and same with Nathan. So if he wants Jack back, then he has Nathan. He is saying Jack and Nathan are the "same". In his opinion, there is no difference. So im confused why he wants Lucas to win? He never wanted Jack to leave, and when Nathan came along he thinks they are the same people so why are you complaining? There, you have another Jack just for, so in your eyes the show can keep going with "Jack." I'm team Nathan, not because he is like Jack, but because you can simply tell he is in the lead. And he has amazing qualities Lucas lacks. See the obvious, and Nathan will shine right through. Just my opinion, God Bless!

  • Giana - 4 years ago

    I personally think she should choose Nathan. I understand that picking another Mountie would lead to a similar story as when she was with jack, but this story was always about Elizabeth and a Mountie. If Daniel chose to stay, it would still be a story about a girl and a Mountie. I for one hope they keep that storyline up. I also know that it may be too painful for Elizabeth to go through another relationship with a Mountie. However, if she truly had feelings for Nathan then she’d be willing to take a risk. Life is so uncertain and we can die any day. Because of this, Elizabeth is just as likely to die being a school teacher as Nathan is being a Mountie, which is something Mountie Jack stated himself in earlier seasons. Elizabeth can’t live in fear or she isn’t truly living, rather she is just existing. I think that’s an important lesson that I hope the show touches on in season 8. As for Lucas, he is a great character. I just can not for the life of me picture him with Elizabeth. I have watched many hallmark movies and never have I found two people more wrong for each other than Elizabeth and Lucas. I do, however, hope they bring in another female character that will add some spark to Lucas. Lucas deserves an amazing women, but unfortunately, I do not believe it’s Elizabeth. Nathan, however, has proven to me to be a better fit. I believe he and Elizabeth have way more chemistry. The way they look at each other is only proof. Elizabeth would also be an amazing mother to Allie after Allie lost her parents. Nathan has also proven to be a great father figure toward baby jack with the way he interacts with him. In my opinion, Lucas only started to interact with baby Jack after he saw the way Elizabeth looked at Nathan when Nathan was playing with baby Jack. I believe Lucas only began interacting with baby Jack to get closer to Elizabeth which is a HUGE no for me. In the end, I am hardcore team Nathan and I will stop watching the show if she picks Lucas. Sorry if that offended anyone! Just my opinion :)

  • Daniel - 4 years ago

    Just stop and think: what's the difference between Jack and Nathan?
    Both have the same profession, the same qualities, the same way, all the same.
    I'll tell you the difference: one is called Jack and the other is called Nathan. And finally, one has a niece. It ended there. All the same.
    Watch it again and you will see that they are the same (of course they are different actors).
    Once again I ask: if the idea is for her to be with an equal guy, why did she kill the other?
    If it is to look like books, then just turn off the TV and read the book.
    I don't see any point in changing the series' narrative and then getting back to the same way it started.
    I have the impression that we are all idiots for watching something that we already know how it will end. Where's the surprise and the excitement?
    From the comments of colleagues I begin to imagine that the problem here is Elizabeth herself. Every guy in red she sees falls in love. It doesn't matter who it is. For this Nathan hasn't said anything that made sense since he appeared. He thinks he is far superior to others, that is. And in the series, it seems that he already knows that he will be with Elizabeth and that he does not need to do anything to win this love (she is the one who has to work to win him).
    Honestly, she should fight to live independently from any guy. Move on like everyone else in the series did!
    That's my opinion, guys! Sorry if I offended someone ...

  • Daniel - 4 years ago

    É só parar para pensar: qual a diferença entre Jack e Nathan?
    Os dois têm a mesma profissão, as mesmas qualidades, o mesmo jeito, tudo igual.
    Vou dizer a diferença: um se chama Jack e o outro se chama Nathan. E, por fim, um tem uma sobrinha. Acabou aí. Tudo igual.
    Assista de novo e verá que são iguais (claro que são atores diferentes).
    Mais uma vez eu pergunto: se a ideia é ela ficar com um cara igual, por que matou o outro?
    Se é para ficar igual aos livros, então é só desligar a TV e ler o livro.
    Não vejo sentido em mudar a narrativa da série e depois voltar a ficar igual a como começou.
    Tenho a impressão que somos todos idiotas por assistir algo que já sabemos como vai terminar. Cadê a surpresa e a emoção?
    Pelos comentários dos colegas começo a imaginar que o problema aqui é a própria Elizabeth. Todo cara de vermelho que ela vê se apaixona. Não importa quem seja. Pois esse Nathan não falou nada que fizesse sentido desde que apareceu. Ele se acha muito superior aos outros, isso sim. E, na série, parece que ele já sabe que vai ficar com Elizabeth e que não precisa fazer nada para conquistar esse amor (ela é quem tem que trabalhar para conquistar ele).
    Sinceramente, ela deveria lutar para levar a vida independente de qualquer cara. Siga em frente como todos os outros da série fizeram!
    Essa é a minha opinião, galera! Desculpa se ofendi alguém...

  • Tom Kim - 4 years ago

    Im confused with what Daniel said. How is another Mountie the exact same as Jack? It's literally a completely different person, just sharing the same job. Like Jesse and Lee, they have the same job, but totally different people. Also, there always has to be a Mountie in town, even after Jack dies, another Mountie must come, so there will always be a Mountie. It doesn't mean it's another Jack. Or another example, if there was another women teacher come to town, it doesn't mean she is the same as Elizabeth. How is having the same job as someone, make you the same as the other person. It's so weird why someone would think that.

  • Marie Jane - 4 years ago

    I completely understand why people wouldn't want another Mountie for Elizabeth. And I understand why something different than another love story with a Mountie would be interesting. What Daniel said, since Jack had to leave, why not just bring in another actor that played his character...? Well, good idea, that didn't happen, instead they brought two new characters that love Elizabeth. People want to change what has already been made and developed. Elizabeth always goes TO Nathan to have conversations with him, and their love is spontaneous. Unlike with Lucas, HE creates it to be romantic, like the reading, dinner, beautiful library date. It's not there, only he makes it seem like it is. But with Nathan, he doesn't do anything romantic comparing to Lucas. He just simply spends time with Elizabeth, says romantic things, and loves the way she interacts with Ally. Nathan absolutely want's the best for ally, and he can see Elizabeth is exactly what he needs. Nathan is more innocent, Lucas doesn't seem the right fit for a beautiful, cute, selfless, humble girl like Elizabeth. You can ship any other single lady with Lucas, but for Nathan it will always be Elizabeth as the perfect fit. Lucas and Fiona, and any other single lady (I can't remember any other single ladies because there isn't a lot in the show.) I can see why people want something different for Elizabeth, but she knew what she was getting into when she fell for Jack. But it's should never be the Job that stops you from loving the person. It is who the person is. Elizabeth is not dumb, she knew Jacks job was extremely dangerous, she knew he would save anyone's life for his, he was brave, a gentle man, and courageous. Same as Nathan. and Elizabeth knows what she is getting herself into with falling for another Mountie. She knows the hard work, the many leavings, the rick of his life, but she is willing to take it. Just as with Jack. I know why people think no more Mounties for Elizabeth. he will just die and leave Elizabeth heartbroken again. BUT we cannot ignore the obvious. She ran into his arms in the finale, SO SO grateful it wasn't him that died. SO happy he can still be with her. And the chances of Nathan dying in the show it SOSO slim. Just because Jack died, not ALL Mounties die you know. and the show wouldn't let us endure another death, and Elizabeth grieving. Please see that what happened happened, and even though lots of people who are team Lucas want things the change in the show, and hope for something new, look at the obvious facts and feelings here, and I hope you can see Nathan is on the lead. #TEAMNATHAN!! :)

  • MAB - 4 years ago

    The chemistry between Nathan and Elizabeth is off the charts! Their eyes speak with all their emotions. I started watching season 6 wanting anyone but a mountie for Elizabeth but after seeing her with Nathan, you just feel that it is real between them. The heart wants what it wants. #teamnathan

  • Daniel Omar - 4 years ago

    Good morning, good afternoon or good night.
    Guys, I respect everyone's opinion and I really understand all the arguments.

    But, let's think a little about the outcome of this series or what are the next steps to be followed.
    If the right choice was Nathan, what was the point in Jack's death? Because if the idea of ​​the series' scriptwriters / producers was to kill Jack, why then bring a character like him (just changed the name)? Elizabeth's big concern in the first five seasons (we can't throw that away in the trash) was that Jack's job could kill him. And that is exactly what happened. And, she even left a son for her to raise alone. So, for the love of God, why would she marry another police officer? There is no sense in that. It doesn't get into my head (I'm sorry). Then the actor decides that there is something more important in life than the series he is doing, and they are going to kill Elizabeth's husband again. Guys, please think about it a little. There is no point in her having a relationship with another police officer.
    What won her over in Jack was not his profession. It was charisma and romanticism. None of this is in the character of Nathan's character.
    I keep thinking about where this series is headed: if she marries the policeman who came to town to take Jack's place, then wouldn't it be better to just change the actor who played Jack? Because the guy has the same profession and bravery as Jack ... and now he's going to have the same woman? For the love of God!!! It makes no sense. It was just having changed the actor and the character would remain.
    I confess: if she has a relationship with Nathan, I will end the series. I am very disappointed with this.

    On the other hand, there is chemistry between Lucas and Elizabeth. It is something new. To forget the tragedy (not to use another word) of Jack's death. The guy likes her a lot and respects her in every way. It represents that she can live without Jack. Which, like everyone else in that city, is moving on. All the widows (widowers) who got back together in the series were looking for something new. Why, then, will Elizabeth be any different?
    Guys, the series is based on the books already mentioned. It doesn't have to be the same. If she were to end up with an officer, all she had to do was change the actor. So, please don't make me see her marry another cop. I mean, that she will be worried for the rest of her life whether or not her husband will die from work? Again, it doesn't make sense after Jack's death.

  • Daniel Omar - 4 years ago

    Bom dia, boa tarde ou boa noite.
    Pessoal, respeito a opinião de todos e realmente entendo todos os argumentos.

    Mas, vamos pensar um pouco sobre o desfecho dessa série ou quais os próximos passos a serem seguidos.
    Se a escolha certa fosse Nathan, qual o sentido de Jack ter morrido? Pois se a ideia dos roteristas/produtores da série era matar Jack, por que então trazer um personagem igual a ele (só mudou o nome)? A grande preocupação de Elizabeth nas primeiras 05 temporadas (não podemos jogar fora isso no lixo não) foi o fato de o trabalho de Jack poder matá-lo. E foi justamente o que aconteceu. E, ainda deixou um filho para ela criar sozinha. Então, pelo AMOR DE DEUS, por que ela iria se casar com outro policial? Não existe nenhum sentido nisso. Isso não entra na minha cabeça (me desculpe). Aí o ator decide que existe coisa mais importante na vida do que a série que está fazendo, e vão matar o marido de Elizabeth de novo. Gente, por favor, pensem um pouco nisso. Não tem sentido ela se relacionar com outro policial não.
    O que a conquistou em Jack não foi a profissão dele não. Foi o carisma e o romantismo. Nada disso está na personalidade do personagem de Nathan.
    Eu fico pensando no rumo que esta série está para tomar: se ela se casa com o policial que veio para a cidade para ocupar o lugar de Jack, então não seria melhor só trocar o ator que fazia o papel de Jack? Pois o cara tem a mesma profissão e bravura que Jack... e agora vai ter a mesma mulher? Pelo amor de Deus!!! Isso não faz sentido. Era só ter mudado o ator e o personagem iria permanecer.
    Eu confesso: se ela se relacionar com Nathan, vou encerrar a série. Estou muito desapontado com isso.

    Por outro lado, há química entre Lucas e Elizabeth. É algo novo. Para esquecer a tragédia (para não usar outra palavra) da morte de Jack. O cara gosta muito dela e a respeita em todos os sentidos. Representa que ela consegue viver sem o Jack. Que, assim como todo mundo naquela cidade, está seguindo em frente. Todas as viúvas (viúvos) que voltaram a se relacionar na série foram em busca de algo novo. Por que, então, Elizabeth vai ser diferente?
    Gente, a série é baseada nos livros já mencionados. Não precisa ser igual não. Se fosse para ela terminar com um oficial, bastava trocar o ator. Então, por favor, não me façam ver ela se casar com outro policial não. Quer dizer, que ela vai ficar o resto da vida preocupada se o marido vai morrer ou não com o trabalho? Mais uma vez, isso não faz sentido após a morte de Jack.

  • Gayle - 4 years ago

    Lucas reminds Elizabeth of her Hamilton life, perfect on the surface... but what you see is hollow. I like what someone else said.... this is not called WCT$. Plus Elizabeth has not been disowned. She is still a wealthy woman in her own right who chooses to work hard and live simply and lovingly care for others.

    Nathan reminds her of her Hope Valley life! Nathan, shy and flawed as is is, is authentic. He is multidimensional.

    Nathan has been abused as a child by his father.... yet has reached above that to become a father who is loving to his abandoned niece. And it’s obvious she adores him! That is greater than the light of a thousand candles!

    Nathan has told Elizabeth in the woods at Christmas: ‘There is no place I would rather be.’ When she was ready to give up her writing and said she was told the best writing came from the heart, he gave her the tool to inspire herself: What’s in your heart? And she started writing what was in her heart. He observed her loyalty to her friends with no ‘but’ attached. Such simple belief, acceptance, declarations are more heady than champagne to one with the soul of a poet like our Elizabeth.

    Personally, I love the humor, the faces, the sweetness, the light, the frailty, the flaws / the layers there are to Nathan. This is a man who makes me smile at all the sweet simple things.

    A family counselor once made a point that each gift from a man to a woman counts as one point.... whether it was a diamond ring or a wildflower. I’d rather get my husband’s attention everyday in small ways. The little meaningful things are what sustain a relationship over the long haul! And that is where Nathan is a huge success! If he had fewer interruptions, he would have even more success.

    Right now Nathan seems to need Elizabeth more than she needs Nathan.... but I think needing to be needed is what Elizabeth is all about! So Nathan is already perfect for her! And when Nathan is in a secure relationship with Elizabeth, the ways he can help her will truly shine through!

    #TeamNathan

  • Carla - 4 years ago

    Lucas is the one! He pushes Elizabeth in a positive way. They work on publishing together, Gowen Oil issues to save families in town, he freely offers saloon for wedding & hosts Christmas meal. Wants the town to have a library. Allows her to become comfortable to fall in love again in her time. He said he travel much & now ready to settle down.
    If not Lucas, bring Jacks first cousin to town (aka Daniel).
    One way to get Daniel back into WCTH.

  • Annie - 4 years ago

    Nathan, Nathan, Nathan, Nathan, NATHAN!

    :) #Team Nathan

  • J. Mclaughfin - 4 years ago

    I feel Lucas should go with Elizabeth. Elizabeth already had a Mountie. Why should she have one again? Nathan may end up getting shot like jack did.

  • WCTH - 4 years ago

    Of course Nathan! It’s so obvious that Elizabeth loves Nathan. Lucas really likes Elizabeth, the reason why he is giving so many things to try and impress her, and she is flattered, but that doesn’t mean she likes Lucas back. Elizabeth doesn’t need nice things to be impressed, which is why she is choosing Nathan over Lucas. She only looks at the person, and his heart, not what he can provide and give her gifts. Lucas always go to her, I don’t think she ever once went to Lucas just to talk. While she always to Nathan, and wants his company more than anyone else’s. And she loves Allie a lot, we can all see that she has intentions to raise her a good loving way. Another reason why Nathan likes Elizabeth so much, because he sees how good Allie and Elizabeth get along, and Nathan strives for the best for Allie, and Elizabeth is the best for Allie. It’s hard for Elizabeth to trust Lucas, and they are so different. Yes they share a love for stories, but I feel Lucas wants to go to the big city, and not stay in Hope Valley for long. Which is why..... he goes with Fiona!!! Lucas and Fiona are soooo perfect! They can travel to big cities together, and run the oil business together, and they are so a like that they are soul mates. I bet you they will end up together, considering the fact how the season ended. A Mounties job is dangerous, but I doubt he will die in the show. Because jack already died, there is no way he would die also, and leave Elizabeth like that, especially in the show. TEAM NATHAN!!!!

  • Lucas Bouchard - 4 years ago

    I think I am not the best match for Elizabeth. I'm wasting all my money on her. :(
    Sorry Elizabeth. I think nathan is the man to go.

    #teamnathan

  • Ned Yoast - 4 years ago

    At my store, Nathan is my best customer.

    #teamnathan!

  • Bill Avery - 4 years ago

    As a Sherif, I've always loved Mountie's. Go Nathan!!!

    #teamnathan!

  • Florence & Molly - 4 years ago

    What We've heard in town, Lucas is only trying to impress Elizabeth. it's not love when you have to express it through giving gifts. Nathan will express how he feels to Elizabeth. Elizabeth already showed him how she felt by hugging him in the Finaly of Season seven

  • Carson Sherperd - 4 years ago

    I was always team Nathan. All Mountie's are good people and Nathan is the best!

  • Abigal Stanton - 4 years ago

    Even though I left the show, Lucas was always on my bad side. The short time I had with Nathan, Elizabeth deserves a man like him.

  • Faith Carter - 4 years ago

    #teamnathan!

    It's time to make the show how it's really supposed to be. A Mountie (Nathan) falling in love with a Woman (Elizabeth). That's what Janette Oke wrote about. Don't betray Janette Oke!

  • Henry Gowen - 4 years ago

    From my perspective, I feel Elizabeth would go better with a Mountie not a gambler. Janette Okes story is based off of a Mountie falling in love with a woman and if Elizabeth went with Lucas, they are betraying Janette Okes story. Elizabeth would go better of with a Mountie not a gambler who always hides things behind her back. Team Nathan all the way!

  • Nathan Grant - 4 years ago

    I am Team Nathan obviously cuz of my name. Nathan is the better choice for Elizabeth. Lucas will definitly end up with Fiona because she just lost her Job and she could work at the Oil company with Lucas. That leaves with Elizabeth and Nathan together of ever.

  • JLM - 4 years ago

    With all of the foreshadowing that has taken place I personally think it is pretty clear that she and Nathan will wind up together. If you look at every detail from the music being played in the background of certain scenes to the apple symbol and the picture taken by Carson at the wedding then it becomes clearer that it is heading in that direction. These are all things that can't be ignored or explained away as coincidence. I counted how many times those apples showed up between Nathan and Elizabeth and it was at least 8 or 9 times throughout season 7 and the books in season 6 were another huge indicator. Alice In Wonderland in and of itself was huge. The saloon is called the Queen of Hearts. Every little detail they put into the script is done intentionally. Nathan is not boring either, he is actually very complex and quiet does not mean boring. Lucas tries too hard and Elizabeth is curiously intrigued by him and flattered by him, but her real feelings are lying with Nathan and that scares her because he is a Mountie like Jack was. In the end her heart is probably going to follow the words on that plaque that Nathan gave to her and she will do what she has been afraid to do all along and love another Mountie. Nathan asked her "what's in your heart," (btw the music playing in that scene was the exact same music playing in the background at Jack and Elizabeth's wedding) and Rosemary told her she would know when the time was right. Nathan told her she mattered to him, something that Lucas has not even come close to admitting to her yet out loud in words. I think it came full circle with that final embrace and her heart chose in that moment when she realized she had almost lost him. Just a few of my thoughts on the subject at hand.

  • Peg kopko - 4 years ago

    Nathan, the chemistry is off the charts. I think we will find Nathan has more depth to him than we think.

  • Mandy Spittler - 4 years ago

    The heart wants what the heart wants. I see the character Elizabeth in a bit of a tizzy right now, blinded by all the attention from Lucas - who knows which buttons to push to get what he wants. Not sure what he really wants from her. Not sure of a lot of things. But I believe Elizabeth's heart is being drawn to Nathan - who represents home, family, integrity and a passion (which having been married such a short while, she must miss). we've just seen a glimpse of. Who needs her. Our heroine wants a husband and father for her son and someone to do life with in an era and place where that requires hard work and dedication and strength of character. Marriage to her seems to be this - to cheer each other on, fight battles with, build a family with, realize dreams with - not have them handed to her on a silver platter. What she has been written to always want. She didn't expect to fall for the New Mountie, but he in his own quiet, awkward way is catching her interest. She wants more. Maybe without knowing it, he's captured her heart. Not love yet - but she wants him in her life in a big way. And of course he's smitten. His niece is on board, Jack, Jr. responds to him, Bill's in his corner (I believe), he loves Hope Valley, too and his heart is hers for the taking. He surrenders a piece of it each time they meet. That's what I see happening. We'll see where the writers take us, but what a ride it has been so far. Just waiting for Season 8!!!

  • Toby Bouckhuyt - 4 years ago

    No question, Nathan is the man for Eliz, love our new,tall, blue eyed,humble respected mounty. He would love and protect Eliz and lil Jack (another mounty's son) like no one else. Eliz and Jack barely got started, Nathan and a beautiful blended family are what we want,loaded with storylines, plenty left to tell. He gets the parenting thing. And that spectacular finale for E & N by Hallmark, WOW???? ! A no brainer compared to the gambler, saloon owner, non parent, plus now oil co owner.Lucas knows little about how to run it and what to do with all those pitfalls ahead. He's all seduction to Eliz and deception, she wouldn't be happy. This is about Eliz overcoming her fears, following her 'instincts', her ❤, I can see E & N doing just that. Otherwise they need to change name of the show. This is WCTH❤, not WCT$, it'd be a shame to go that far off track from the original story which is about a teacher and mounty. Keep it original,keep it realistic, keep it wholesome. Love the show so much, so far. Maybe someone else for Lucas but not Eliz and her dear baby Jack.

  • Karen - 4 years ago

    #teamnathan
    Nathan is definitely the best and should be the only choice for Elizabeth. Right from Nathan’s 2nd episode t th he chemistry, longing looks and friendship blossomed between these two. Nathan is a sweet, loving, very handsome, brave and sexy family man and will make Elizabeth a great husband. I think the potential for fun and exciting storyline’s is huge.
    #GrantUsAFamily

  • Miriam Pedro - 4 years ago

    Nathan for sure! I feel Lucas is just giving her things with his money, and he seems to be hiding something. Nathan is a good sweet person, and a father for Jack, while Elizabeth is a mother for Allie. AND the purpose of the show is a school teacher falling in love with a Mountie. Elizabeth fell in love with Jack. teacher and Mountie. and now it should be Nathan. Janette Okes books are based on mounties, and if Elizabeth goes with Lucas, they would be going against Janette Oke, and basically going against the rules. ALSO Elizabeth always goes to Nathan, talks to him. while Lucas goes to Elizabeth. I feel Lucas like her more than she likes him. It's clear Elizabeth has more feelings for Nathan, and truly cares for his well being, and his family and job. I know he is a Mountie, and his job is dangerous, but the chances of him dying in the show is very slim, because it will happen all over again, and it will get boring. Lucas will always be hiding something from Elizabeth, it's hard to build trust with him, we all know that. but Nathan is a good man, any Mountie is. and he's a good father, he truly cars about Allie. think of Elizabeth Grant

  • Team Jack (or Nathan) - 4 years ago

    I chose „I just miss Jack. Neither compares to him.“ It is because I’m still missing him and I wish he could’ve seen his son - at least a few times before he died. In my opinion there is a possibility that he comes back because they never found the body and Daniel Lissing said he would like to come back. So I have a tiny hope we will see him again - now with a deeper love between him and Elizabeth. Before he died they had just the tingling kind of love you have in honeymoon.

    But if Jack won’t come back, I would like to see her with Nathan. I know that he is also a Mountie but Elizabeth is a strong woman who never chose safety. Besides, I’m my opinion she now needs someone who isn’t that charming because she already had this type of love with Jack. Now it’s time for a calm love.

  • Christine - 4 years ago

    Lynn Tyler we'll have to agree to disagree on this one. First I looked up the definition of "sorry" and "apology" is a synonym so I'm afraid that argument doesn't fly. Second, I'm not sure how one can compare a dance with the season 7 finale. Lucas certainly wasn't happy and I think maybe underestimated Elizabeth's feelings for Nathan. One other point, while Lucas is helping with publishing her book it was Nathan who inspired Elizabeth to "write from her heart." If he hadn't who knows if there would have even been a book. After Lucas told her that the best writing comes from the heart she tried but only ended up with an overflowing waste basket of crumpled paper. It wasn't until Elizabeth and Nathan had that chance meeting that Elizabeth was inspired. Remember these words; "So what's in your heart?' That was the moment Elizabeth connected to her own. It was shortly after that meeting that she began writing. Those five simple words went from Nathan's heart to hers. He gave Elizabeth her dream in the midst of her discouragement and doubt. As I see it Lucas gave her the knowledge but Nathan gave her the heart. She and Nathan connect on the heart level and from what I've seen their chemistry is off the charts! Just sayin'...

  • Lynn Powell - 4 years ago

    Elizabeth should be with Lucas. They have so much in common and can truly challenge, support and help each other. I would rather watch ElIzabeth and Lucas in a meaningful relationship as she enjoys and appreciates seeing Lucas grow closer to little Jack than watch a ready-made family that has Elizabeth parenting and teaching a pre-teen while trying to raise her own son. I think Elizabeth deserves to be with someone who can focus on her and her needs as she learns to trust and love again. I would love for her next romantic relationship to be with Lucas.

  • Jeffery - 4 years ago

    This show needs more romance. The obvious choice is Lucas. Why put Elizabeth thru more heartache with another Mountie? Been there done that...she would always worry. Let her true character shine! Shen needs romance...and Lucas wins that area BIG TIME!!!

  • Rem - 4 years ago

    Lucas - simply because he’s really good looking and has better chemistry with Elizabeth

  • Linda - 4 years ago

    Nathan and Elizabeth belong together. Clearly, when she ran into Nathan's arms, the way she hugged him tightly in front of all citizens of Hope Valley is the moment of truth. Rosemary told Elizabeth that she would know when the time came and this moment proved her feelings are stronger for Nathan and she made her choice. They remit wonderful chemistry together and I can't imagine moving forward with a storyline for Elizabeth without Nathan as her choice.

  • Em - 4 years ago

    I definitely say Nathan. Lucas seems really sly and fishy. Nathan is the best because he seems more realistic and kind. Elizabeth needs a strong character after Jack. Lucas couldn’t be what Nathan could

  • Lynn Tyler - 4 years ago

    100%, absolutely Lucas!! He has done so many things to show her he cares for her. She needs someone to challenge her, and he does. He’s the reason her dream of being a published author is coming true! The episode “Heart of a Writer” was my favorite this year. The non-date, which was really a date, and their conversations were beautiful. Plus Rosemary and Lee taking care of little Jack (when he says “duck” and drops it on the floor and their response), so precious! I just hate to see Elizabeth with another Mountie. Let’s have a new storyline for her. Getting her book published, meeting Lucas’s family—such great potential! By the way, Lucas had a great apology concerning sending her book chapters to his mother. He actually said the words “I’m sorry”, not just “I owe you an apology” which is when a person doesn’t really even say those words. You owe it but you don’t even say I’m sorry? Nathan tells Elizabeth that if you can’t follow your instincts, than you’re in real trouble. It seems that this whole time her instincts have led her to Lucas. She chose him for the dance, she chose him to read her book, she chose to follow his suggestions concerning her book. I hope the writers aren’t misleading us.......either way, I hope they will allow her to make this choice once and for all, and allow her some fun and happiness in her romance. Which, by the way, is totally Lucas!

  • Maria - 4 years ago

    If there’s anything I’ve learned in life, it’s this- Always go with the awkward, shy guy l, and not the one with all the right moves! That almost always ends badly. I’d definitely trust Nathan more than Lucas.
    Also, I’m married to a cop, who was super shy and awkward when we met, so I might be biased. ????

  • JEAN MILANO - 4 years ago

    I think Nathan has more of a story line. More intrigue with his job, a family man and gives Elisabeth a run for her money. The question is will she hold back because he is a Mountie and the danger of the job is too much for her. I like the pull and tug between their characters. Lucas is too accommodating in order to getwhat Lucas wants.

  • Crystal - 4 years ago

    I'm still a favorite of Lucas! I am on team Lucas.
    I think she would be better with him because they are both professionals in their own way (of course Nathan's job is too). Nathan just seems too shy and unsure as a character and I don't think them two should get together. 1: when she was with Jack, him being a mountie, she let her wall down, she let him in, they got married, they had a baby, they were in love. Then tragedy strikes and he dies and her heart was broke.
    2: Nathan is a new guardian to Allie and is raising her on his own.
    Now two years later she (Elizabeth) is still trying to pick up the pieces. I think her hooking up with Nathan would just set her back. Of course they could be each other's support system and raise both kids together, but mixing that with a new relationship will be very trying to them which I don't feel they deserve right now. So yes I definitely think her and Lucas should be together. Even though at the beginning of season 6 when he first came onto set his character gave me the vibe that he was shady, maybe a criminal, or hiding something big but, as the past two seasons went on he definitely seemed to me like a decent up and up guy.
    So again...I'm rooting for Lucas not for Nathan.
    Yes of course Lucas has money, well Elizabeth comes from a wealthy family also. I do not think he is buying her love. I feel he is just doing what he knows and going about it in a way he is familiar with. I'm sure deep down as humble as Elizabeth is, I feel she might miss her wealth to a degree. As far as Lucas not trying to bond with Baby Jack, Nathan hasn't either. And for the fans who want to get technical as far as the time frame that the show is based on... people back then did not jump into a relationship and get their kids involved. They had more respect and morals in that department. They waited until they knew the person they were with was either going to be the right one or at least someone that they are going to spend a very long time with, then introduced their children into that relationship.
    Both guys are great in their own way for Elizabeth, I personally feel Lucas is the best "choice".
    And as far as Fiona... I am glad she stuck up to her boss. I feel that she definitely made the right choice staying in Hope Valley. I think she should see what kind of relationship blooms with Carson. I think Fiona should work with Carson but not as closely as faith did. A work and personal relationship should have boundaries. I hope in season 8 we find more out about Rosemary and Lee and hopefully they either get pregnant or in some other way have a baby (adoption or surrogate through Susie his sister).

  • MARILYN JONES - 4 years ago

    I vote Nathan because one he one be a good father for Jack and Elizabeth would be a good person to raise Allie. And he not trying to buy her love like Lucas. I think the phone lady would be better for Lucas

  • Donna Darrh - 4 years ago

    I vote Lucas because he is so sweet and supportive of her. He has always been there for her like Jack was there for her. With Nathan she is always having to help him with his problems, but he has never once been there for her; at least not like Lucas has been. I seen how Elizabeth worried about Jack being a mounty. I don't want her to end up heartbroken again being with Nathan like she was with Jack.

  • DJ - 4 years ago

    Lucas is my choice.
    I think he has shown how much he cares for Elizabeth, and he encourages her to
    be a confident lady.
    I wish there had been more interaction with little Jack as well as Elizabeth.
    Nathan needs to be with someone new. He a good actor but his character is dull.
    I like Carson with Fiona, I am not a fan of the nurse that was working with Carson, glad she left. But there does need to be more changes in Series 8. Series 7 was more of all the series.

  • Karen Barlett - 4 years ago

    Nathan is best one for Elizabeth as he is mire down to earth. to me lucas is shady and I don't trust. He isstressed a lot of the time. #team Nathan

  • Wonderwendi - 4 years ago

    Aside from a dozen other reasons to vote for Nathan, let's consider the time period in which this is set. The 'school marm' would NEVER be seen with the saloon keeper! When his character was introduced, he was portrayed as shady and perhaps even criminal. A few 'good deeds' and folks seem to have excused all that. He simply does not deserve Elizabeth.

  • Maggie - 4 years ago

    I picked Lucas, but also feel as others do about him hiding something. However it is time for Elizabeth to take her rightful place in the community.She comes from money and I think she misses it. Lucas is a great reminder of her former life and that story line should be explored.

  • Stephanie Terry - 4 years ago

    Got to fo with Lucas. There is so much more there than just chemistry. I think Nathan is more of someone of the past and seems to be a hot head regarding her. I think Lucas brings out the best in Elizabeth and she in him. That is something worth building upon. Voting for Lucas.

  • Anastasia S. - 4 years ago

    #TEAMNATHAN!
    No offense to all the people who vote for Lucas, but Nathan is definitely the right choice. Lucas is still super shady and just tries to woo Elizabeth, and he doesn’t even interact with Jack that much. We all know she cares so much for Jack so Nathan is the right choice. Sure he is a Mountie like Jack, but that doesn’t mean that it will be the same story again. Jack and Nathan are not the same person. So to everyone saying that they like Lucas because they don’t think Elizabeth should go with another Mountie, is wrong (no offense). Nathan and Elizabeth also make a good pair because they both have children to raise, so they would help each other in that department too. Also, I think Lucas knows she will pick Nathan. He clearly saw how Elizabeth ran into Nathan’s arms, he can’t deny that he knows she will pick Nathan. Another reason to not pick Lucas, is because he just keeps doing all the romantic stuff because he used his money. He doesn’t even try to just take her out somewhere without all the champagne and expensive things. He is just trying to “buy her love”. Whereas Nathan, just tries to get every moment they are together and make the most of it. As you know, it took him until the season 7 finale to asks her out, because he was considerate of her still recovering from the death of Jack sr. That is just some reasons why I am Team Nathan all the way. Also it is clear that she feels a stronger attraction to him than Lucas, but it just took her a long time to find out because Lucas kept taking her to all these stuff so it is technically Lucas’ fault that she wasn’t actually able to spend that much time with Nathan. Elizabeth is definitely going to pick Nathan because she realized how important he is to her after almost losing him. I rest my case. If you agree with me, start your comment with “abc Anya”. If you disagree with me, start your comment with “def Anya”.

    #TEAMNATHAN

  • Ruth hody - 4 years ago

    I think Nathan because he seems to be more interested in children and more like a hope valley person

  • Gen Alfaro - 4 years ago

    I always go for the underdog Nathan.
    Lucas seems to have it all, a very clever businessman, that gives me some misgivings on his character...he comes out too good a suitor to be true...maybe a woman likes to be pursued like the way he does to please Elizabeth, he'll give the moon to her if he can...who can't be charmed and be carried away by those gestures. But dont be tricked ladies, Lucas has all those resources, those connections bc he is well off. Who doesn't like a well off, well able man to support his family....at the end of the day, the ultimate test,whose has got the depth of character to be a man who loves you enough to put his life on the line for the woman or family or people he loves!

    Hasn't Nathan showed us already what he is made of when took responsibility to raise his niece, and is doing a great job at it?

    at the end of the day, Elizabeth will choose someone whose heart is made of priceless gem, genuine strength of character! Hearties look at the heart, not those externalities. What is seen is just the tip of the iceberg, what matters most is what lies beneath the surface????????

    Now I rest my case????????????

  • Isabel R - 4 years ago

    I started watching this show recently and I fell in love the chemistry that Elizabeth and Jack had. Can he return to the show?

  • Charity - 4 years ago

    I think there appears to be more chemistry with Lucas because the show is being written in that direction. The writers need to step up and give Nathan a better chance to show chemistry with Elizabeth. Nathan is just a good ol quiet dude taking his time getting to know her... It moves at a snail's pace because most of the romantic interactions are written for Lucas and Elizabeth. Plus, Lucas... he always appears to be hiding something. :/ Team Nathan!!

  • Joni Kaiser - 4 years ago

    She cannot go with another Mounty, his job could leave her alone again.

  • Nanci - 4 years ago

    Nathan is boring. Lucas offers her so many things to be involved in and pursue. Nathan is a nice guy, but not interesting at all

  • Mimi J. - 4 years ago

    I like Lucas better because he's more charming. Though Nathan is probably the logical choice. He has a niece to raise and Elizabeth has little Jack to raise. They would make more sense logically. I just think the Mountie love story has already been done and I would like to see something else. Also I don't like how petty Nathan was when he found out about Elizabeth's date. He never told her how he felt but was upset with her. However, there's something about Lucas' character that doesn't sit right with me either. He's too pushy and seems sneaky. He actually has the potential of becoming the town villain. Sometimes he reminds me of Henry from the first couple of seasons....a shrewd business man. Maybe the show can introduce a new character, an honest man that is self assured who will love Elizabeth and little Jack unconditionally.

  • Hollyister - 4 years ago

    I say Nathan only because he doesn’t seem as guarded about stuff as Lucas is. Is more heartfelt and not all fancy.

  • Patti - 4 years ago

    Just because Nathan is a Mountie is not a reason not choose him. Yes it's possible he could get killed but Lucus is a salon owner bad things happen in salons too. Lucas is pushy and tries to hard like it is a contest. Team Nathan!!!!!

  • peggy Jo Moreno - 4 years ago

    I would like to see Elizabeth with Nathan. Lucas is gonna get too possessive.

  • Sheri H. - 4 years ago

    This is going to sound odd, but I'd like to see her with Carson, the doctor :) But her best bet now is Lucas. He has made great efforts in wooing her, while Nathan is moody, grumpy and has awkward social skills.

  • Louise Shew - 4 years ago

    Nathan has a niece,Elizabeth has a child so they would make an awesome family together!A big yes to Nathan and Elizabeth????❤❤

  • Tricia MAC - 4 years ago

    Lucas is charming and so dreamy! He is working hard to win her love! I think they’d make the best couple!

  • Loave - 4 years ago

    Lucas is too sneaky. Look at what he did in regards to the book she was writing. He sent it to his mother without asking Elizabeth. No, I think it should be Nathan and Elizabeth. He is not sneaky and is coming out of his shell to ask her out. It's time for Nathan to settle down and for Ally to have a good mother figure in her life. Jack will need a father figure who won't be sneaky about anything.

  • Tanya - 4 years ago

    Team Lucas! He pushes her and challenges her which is important for her growth. Elizabeth won't do anything for herself and Lucas always is there thinking of her happiness. Nathan is boring and has his own growing to do. The way he treated Elizabeth in the storm episode. Not appropriate. He doesn't elevate her to be the best she can be and would let her stay in her comfort zone forever.

  • Linda - 4 years ago

    I like both but I think Lucas is a little too sneaky and tries to run Elizabeth's life... there's something he is hiding... Nathan seems more reserved and would be a good father and husband and he is not as suspicious as Lucas

  • Tee - 4 years ago

    I saw how elizabeth ran into nathan arms when she thought he got shot. She has major feelings for him. Should be nathan.

  • MJ - 4 years ago

    Nathan! He is perfect for her and Jack and she will be perfect for Nathan and Ally.

  • Carrie Elizabeth Sowash - 4 years ago

    I think we see more chemistry because more opportunities have been scripted for Lucas. Even though Lucas does all of these things for Elizabeth, is he truly thinking of and loving Elizabeth or just trying to buy her love. I think he is "blindly" trying to manipulate her feelings and her career...from sending her writing off to buying the oil company he may not thinking about what is best for Elizabeth, but how can I get her to choose me.

  • Lorii - 4 years ago

    I think Elizabeth should pick Lucas. Lucas is a breadth of fresh air to the show & he deserves to be with Elizabeth. Nathan is boring & not for her. Nathan is too shy & backward.

  • Havier - 4 years ago

    Burn me once, shame on you. Burn me twice, shame on me. She needs Lucas for her heart's sake. Don't want her suffering every time Nathan goes off somewhere dangerous. Please save her heart from pain again.

  • Liane - 4 years ago

    I agree with Joan Jones’ observations about Lucas vs Nathan. Plus, I think if Elizabeth chooses Nathan and becomes a mom to Allie, that would be a too predictable plot line. To me, Elizabeth also has more chemistry with Lucas.

  • Patricia Barnes - 4 years ago

    I think Elizabeth is in love with Nathan, but is afraid the same thing will happen to him/her as happened to Jack. He's not Jack - perfect for her.

  • Gladys Rauber - 4 years ago

    I vote for Lucas.
    He is the most attentive and makes
    More time to be with Elizabeth. However, Lucas couldturn out to be too possessive and jealous later

  • Elizabeth Stotts - 4 years ago

    I do not think Elizabeth is in love with Nathan I think she thinks of Jack when she is around him I think Nathan is something familiar to her I think Lucas is a much better choice for her

  • A. Doyle - 4 years ago

    Lucas all the way. How can she resist how dreamy he is. Nathan lacks confidence in the love department and barely smiles. Lucas is romantic and knows how to treat a woman. Besides choosing another mounty could bring her pain once again. She needs to take a risk with the “mystery man” Lucas. And Lucas needs her to truly become the honorable man he wants to be. It’s time for Elizabeth to make a change in the kind of man she falls for. Otherwise it’s the same story all over again.

  • Patricia L Hepburn - 4 years ago

    She would never marry another Mountie and go through that heartache again. Nathan is a jerk anyways.

  • Kellie Griffis - 4 years ago

    In reality neither compares to jack and I wish he would return but if I have to pick one, I'd choose Nathan. I love Lucas but I don't think he's right for Elizabeth. However if I were in her place I'd be scared to get with another Mountie after what happen to jack. But love is a risk. So Nathan it is.

  • P. DYER - 4 years ago

    I absolutely think Nathan is the best choice! He is the perfect fit for her life and for his life. I really hope the decision is made early in next season. This has gone on long enough! Great, great season. Can't wait till season 8. Lucas and Fiona make a better couple.

  • Donna K Vandegrift - 4 years ago

    We have a season 8. So Happy. That was the announcement.

  • Cindy Jo - 4 years ago

    Yes I know Nathan is a Mountie, but the strong decent dependable family oriented person is what Elizabeth's character needs and seems to be leaning towards. Lucas is handsome, and does seem like he has a lot in common with her.....but the Elizabeth of her old life. Not the Elizabeth with a child to raise in frontier town. That guy would be Nathan. And let's face she's attracted to him and his strength of character. Lucas isn't a bad guy, other than being pushy, he's just not'the guy'.

  • Cecelia Mason - 4 years ago

    Nathan is shy and his niece needs mother figure he will be the best family man not Lucas.

  • Mel VanEgdom - 4 years ago

    Team Nathan all the way. He'd get the chance to ask her out if Lucas wasn't so pushy. He seems to interrupt AR just the right times. I also feel Lucas's character is shady. He seems a lot like Henry to me. I'm afraid he has lots to hide and Elizabeth would get hurt. Don't feel he has the best of intentions for anyone but himself. Ali also needs a mother figure.

  • Gayle - 4 years ago

    Lucas

  • Barbara Bramlett - 4 years ago

    I like her to pick Nathan. He seems to have more in common with her. She likes Alley and Nathan is a solid character. Although his profession is risky.

  • A.l. Norris - 4 years ago

    I'm hoping Nathan gets her vote, but I know how this television racket can cross us all.

  • Trisha Dunn - 4 years ago

    I liked the fact that the rugged Nathan character moved slow in showing his affection towards Elizabeth. Quite the opposite with the charmed Lucas character who moved fast. The choice...Mountie vs Saloon Owner or ???? Who best fits Elizabeth and her #1 sweet little Jack?

  • Joanne Caruso - 4 years ago

    Nathan is the one for her hope she picks him.

  • Cheryl McElroy - 4 years ago

    Nathan is the best choice for Elizabeth!
    Allie also needs a mother and Elizabeth will be the best choice for that.

  • Cheryl McElroy - 4 years ago

    Nathan is the best choice for Elizabeth!
    Allie also needs a mother and Elizabeth will be the best choice for that.

  • Kathleen Lacik - 4 years ago

    Nathan and Elizabeth make a better couple!

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment