I love American Idol and the opportunity it gives these amazing vocalists. Although I appreciate giving some of last year’s contestants a comeback, I really feel that it’s unfair to take a spot away from this years talent. How about having a TOP 11 this year, bring Madison back, and then let America decide. I don’t know Madison personally, I just think she’s a great artist.
It’s been a year of CHANGE, a NEW NORMAL, this year could be a 10, but why not make it an 11. ❤️????????????
Re my previous comment. I did NOT put ? marks on my comment and no way to edit. It was Arthur Gunn All The Way⭐⭐⭐
No contest! Very happy to see Arthur Gunn back - will be cheering for him to win it all this year. Due to the constraints on performances during last year's pandemic, those contestants missed out on a season truly showcasing their talents. Excited that the public will be given a glimpse of one of those talents this year. Arthur Gunn all the way! ⭐????
None of them! Is was so unfair to this year’s contestants!
Sorry. Truth be told, as "recognizable" as Arthur Gunn is, he makes every song sound the same. Boring. Either Makayla or Louis Knight should go forward.
Madison should have been in top 10, by bringing back last year's losers it wasn't fair, they took away a spot she earned and deserved.
Y'all could say what you like but Arthur gun to me is the top 10 because of his own style of singing like Alejandro AKA scary pool party
I think louis knight has the best of all. All around. He is ready for a career. Although I do not agree with how they are doing this. They could have had a separate show for these guys. I think it was maybe a last minute decision. But keeping with the question. Louis knight would be my choice.
I was delighted to see them back.
Ms Elise is my favorite, such a beautiful voice.
But she keep picking the wrong songs.
Her voice is powerful and soulful.
The whole show seemed like a detour on the road to this season's AI.
Every year I get entertained from watching American Idol but I think it can get a little boring. The judges comments are always the same. Yesterday's come back competition was a fun addition. Why not shake things up a little? So for me regarding this part of the competition Arthur Gunn has my vote.
I always liked Merico and although he doesn't have the best voice. He has the full package. It appears very few agree.
None of them belong in THIS years top ten. What a stupid idea. Madison got screwed.