Who SHOULD win 'American Idol'?

29 Comments

  • George J Delfino - 3 years ago

    Casey Bishop SHOULD HAVE WON !
    Her being sent home was shocking !!
    Most talented and versatile singer in a
    LONG TIME !!!

  • Pauline - 3 years ago

    So much talent . Obviously they are the top three. Winner CHAYCE

  • Lisa Gordon - 3 years ago

    I pray that Willie should win he has a terific voice he is the best

  • Bren - 3 years ago

    Wonderful Willie is the winner. Beautiful songs.

  • Donna Mastri - 3 years ago

    The last 3 contestants are all amazing in their own way. It's really hard to choose. My favorite from the beginning has been Chayse so that's who I'm hoping wins. I really hope Willie & Grace get recording contracts also, they deserve it! ❤️

  • Joseph Ignarro - 3 years ago

    All three are so good I can’t decide .but my fav is grace .too bad a three way tie wasn’t allowed

  • J - 3 years ago

    I would love to see Willie win. He can straight up sang. I would have loved to see Casey in the finale instead of Grace. I do think that Grace has a beautiful voice but the way she acted when she and Willie sang the duet at the end turned me off from her. Willie turned to her to commend her and did not look his way at all. She kept looking at the judges. She shows poor showmanship. I would love for Willie to win he is the best singer. But I like Chayce too. They can all sing so should get good contracts. But Grace needs to learn some manners.

  • Jane - 3 years ago

    The American Idol contestants released singles on iTunes last week. Chayce debuted at #1, Grace debuted at #18, and Willie debuted at #31. The 4th and 5th place contestants both placed ahead of Willie and Grace. Of the 3 contestants left, Chayce is the only singer/songwriter still there. Aside of Chayce being "eye candy," he has the talent to back it up. The iTunes charts agree. When Ryan Seacrest asked him about his placement on the charts, he seemed very humble about it when he said that his original song debuted at #1. I'd love to see either Chayce or Willie win.

  • Jayelle - 3 years ago

    I think all 3 have amazing voices. I'm hoping that Chayce will win. I think he is the most improved. I think Willie has improved as well. I like that Grace took the advice from Joss Stone and stopped constantly doing runs throughout the songs, but there's something about her that rubs me the wrong way. Out of the 3 of them, I would buy Chayce's and Willie's albums, so I would be happy if either of them would win. In many of the past seasons of American Idol, the most improved contestants have won. They were usually the underdogs at the beginning of the season.

  • Manda - 3 years ago

    I feel like alot of others that have commented on the web. Chance will probably win because his story and looks will have the tweens and Granny's voting but as far as talent, Willie could have a great Gospel career and Grace has a wonderful pop voice that is the more current of the three. I'm not saying that Chayce has no talent, I like his voice ok but I'm not sure that he knows himself as a true artist yet and his voice on a whole record? I don't hear a #1 single voice with him or enough versatility to provide enough for a record yet. Maybe with some experience and training.

  • Kim Zimmerman - 3 years ago

    The world really needs Willie right now. To lift us, inspire us, and give us happy thoughts. Someone should give him a contract and shove him down our throats. He can be a smooth operator, a soulful angel, or a badass sexual healer. With just a little more self confidence he can and will heal our wounds

  • Lynn - 3 years ago

    I look at 2 things.....talent and the probability of making it in a singing career. All 3 are talented. But from what I've seen of personalities/looks/stage presence Chayce is the clear winner. Looks as well as talent matter when you are in "show" business.

  • Dean Storie - 3 years ago

    Personally I want chayce to win but damn Willie is a powerhouse I believe willie has it in the bag

  • Gail Mallory - 3 years ago

    Grace is the clear winner.. she is totally amazing Bless her journey..????????

  • Stacey - 3 years ago

    The right 3 are definitely in the top 3. I read about so many people complaining that Casey got voted out, but if she is as good as they all think she is they should be confident that she will get signed by someone even without winning or being in the top 3. I would love it if Grace won, but I am good with any of them winning.

  • Rockgolf - 3 years ago

    Grace is the modern Kelly Clarkson, the wildly talented unknown. Willie is the modern Ruben Stoddard, the plus sized velvet soul singer.
    Chayce is any of 10-15 subsequent WBWG (white boy with guitar) Idol winners, interchangeable and soon forgotten.

  • Maureen Mereigh - 3 years ago

    Willie the winner

  • Mary Theriault - 3 years ago

    I think Chayce should win!! He is a people person ~ he is idol material Chayce had to learn like all Idol winners he didn’t graduate from college as a music star he had to work at it and it showed every week he has the looks, voice, and works the stage…don’t get me wrong they are all wonderful singers ~ To me Willie can sing anything and he has true feelings~ he was self thought when he first sang he was so nervous because he didn’t have schooling to learn confidence, he is a sole singer and he you will never hear him on America’s top 40 and like Chayce the same thing they are idol material they are what it’s all about !!! And Grace, she is a wonderful singer but she came to idol knowing she is good and she can belt out any note with out a flaw but being a college grad in music she has been taught to be the best so that is not fair~ already knowing everything before she was a contestant… but my first choice was Cassie as she learned singing in a hair brush with no school for that she could sing everything ~ self taught she worked the stage and connected with the audience and is Beautiful ~ to me ~ She is Idol material…

  • J.J - 3 years ago

    WILLIE..WILLIE..WILLIE..you the man..GOD has given you a very SPECIAL GIFT.. ENJOY it ...LOVE it and make the WORLD hear and feel it through your beautiful voice...GOOD LUCK..

  • Denise - 3 years ago

    I’m fine with any of the 3 winning. Each have their own natural talent that is wonderful. Grace can belt out anything and seems to really have an understanding on how to control her voice and draw us in. Willie reminds me of Rubin when Rubin won American Idol, and although Rubin was wonderful, we never really heard from him again. I think that is what would happen with Willie. Chayce knows how to empty his soul into a song which touches you and that is a great talent.

  • Emenda Bridges - 3 years ago

    I think Chyace will be the better Idol. He has the stamina and the personality the others do not.

  • Diane Falkowitz - 3 years ago

    Chayce is okay, nothing like Willie or Grace as far as raw talent. They'll probably vote for Chayce because they can't decide between Willie or Grace. Grace can be more versatile than Willie. I'd like to see Willie move around more and be more interactive with the audience. Grace does that very well. Chance needs to put his guitar down occasionally and connect with the audience more, I believe.

  • Janet Driggers - 3 years ago

    I really want Grace to win...but wouldn't be upset if its Willie. Both of them actually have TALENT. But Chayse cannot really SING. If he wins, it is not because of talent....its because of a lot of young girls who think he's hot.

  • Cinder - 3 years ago

    Im positive, wihoever doesnt win, will get a contract anyway!!.
    Best of luck to all! My 2 faves are on here, hard to choose.

  • Jennifer Hoover - 3 years ago

    Grace is clearly the one who should win, her voice is unmatched! Chayce is only eye candy. Willie should not even be in the top 3 (a lot of times he sounds like Eric Cartman singing).

  • Yolanda Nieto - 3 years ago

    Willie should win this!! His voice is inspirational and that's what singers should do. Inspire. I pray he wins. He will touch a lot of pepe

  • Yolanda Nieto - 3 years ago

    Willie should win this!! His voice is inspirational and that's what singers should do. Inspire. I pray he wins. He will touch a lot of pepe

  • Annie Townsend - 3 years ago

    Willie can just straight out sang..... Anything!! Period!!????

  • Pamela Smith - 3 years ago

    WILLIE BETTER WIN HE IS AMAZING

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment