Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo

90 Comments

  • Bob Withers - 4 years ago

    No contest- Smallville by a long shot! Smallville is the very best superhero television series of all time!

  • Eu - 4 years ago

    Supergirl

  • Rob - 4 years ago

    Smallville...thx.

  • Steve Workman - 4 years ago

    Loved Smallville! I have all seasons on DVD and have watched them 5-6 Times all the way through. Would like to see a reunion bring it back. I'm sure some of the characters would come back. Especially if the money was right. Lol I did love the morals and values of always trying to do the right thing.

  • Kathryn - 4 years ago

    Supergirl

  • kelly - 4 years ago

    SMALLVILLE

  • Rob - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Whoami - 4 years ago

    Smallville!

  • Angel - 4 years ago

    Smallville you can’t compare to other shows.

  • Marcela - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Jimmy Neutron - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Keri - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Charles Lyons - 4 years ago

    Smallville period

  • George - 4 years ago

    Smallville is up up and a-WAY better that SuperWoke!

  • jimbo - 4 years ago

    Smallville Forever!!!

  • Robyn McCormick - 4 years ago

    Smallville for sure

  • Caro - 4 years ago

    Supergirl ♥️♥️

  • J - 4 years ago

    I choose both I love supergirl and smallville both great shows of there generations. I wish they did a cross over with smallville, sugergirl and superman and lois. I know they did that already but I want to see them just have one for one big epic episode. They can now do both supermans, cause Tom welling superman is now human. And it would be interesting to see how smallville Clark and lois two girls interact with there counterparts Clark and lois girls and superman and lois boys. Will one or both girls have powers or just one of them. Clark and lois meet Clark and lois , lex meets lex, sugergirl meets sugergirl. Lana meets Lana , Clark and lois girls meet Clark and lois boys.

  • Syed Mansoor - 4 years ago

    Smallville ist preffernce then Supergril.

  • Andrew Waterman - 4 years ago

    Smallville Rules above

  • Andrew Waterman - 4 years ago

    Smallville Rules above

  • Jessica Ramos - 4 years ago

    SUPERGIRL ❤️❤️

  • Yasmin - 4 years ago

    Supergirl

  • Sally - 4 years ago

    Smallville of course!!

  • Jimmy Lee - 4 years ago

    Smallville is just a great series!!

  • Cristina Rebeca - 4 years ago

    Por más que me guste Smalville, Supergirl se ha ganado un enorme pedazo de mi corazón asi que mi voto es para Supergirl

  • Autumn - 4 years ago

    Smallville hands down

  • Hishan Scofield - 4 years ago

    Smallville all the time♥️

  • Nicole - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Rocket - 4 years ago

    Smallville, a true legend

  • Luisa Ramírez - 4 years ago

    Supergirl

  • LaTonya - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Ivan - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Ivan - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Paul - 4 years ago

    Smallville is my number 1!

  • Travis Kraemer - 4 years ago

    Smallville! Supergirl's stories are just all over the place!

  • Bryan campbell - 4 years ago

    Smallville hands down. Supergirl is a great show, but smallville was something spectacular that just had a way of pulling me into the storylines. It is definitely one of my favorite shows that i have binge watched quite a few times. Only other show that could compare IMO would be supernatural.

  • Lisa Abernethy - 4 years ago

    Smallville all the way. Supergirl is good but Smallville was spectacular!

  • Sumair - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Steve - 4 years ago

    Smallville

  • Tee - 4 years ago

    SMALLVILLE!!!

  • Krystal T - 4 years ago

    LOVE LOVE SMALLVILLE! Watched it when I was a teenager and now my son loves watching it. It instills a lot of Family values.

  • Jennifer - 4 years ago

    I think in the end it will be between Supernatural and Smallville out of be the choices they are giving.

  • Timothy - 4 years ago

    Smallville Cause It Was One Of My Favorites And Today’s DC Shows Are Not As Good.

  • Brendan Whitted - 4 years ago

    Supergirl is ok, but I’m all seriousness, you cannot say it is better than Smallville with any kind of credibility. If you think Supergirl is better, you’re eiher too young to have actually experienced Smallville or you prefer shows with simplistic plots, force-fed social justice narratives, and boring supporting characters. Or hell, maybe both. Regardless, from an objective standpoint, the worst Smallville episode is better than the best Supergirl episode.

    Oh and that goes for the flash too

  • Munro - 4 years ago

    Supergirl all the way!!!!!!

  • Phil - 4 years ago

    Smallville was a better show, and it even had a better Supergirl!

  • Trinidad Chacon - 4 years ago

    Smallville hands down the best. Supergirl lost my attention as an adult but Smallville I grew up with them watching them and understanding the perspective.

  • Jami - 4 years ago

    SMALLVILLE!!

  • Vanessa Cardozo - 4 years ago

    Cmon Smallville literally ended almost ten years ago, get over it, Supergirl deserves the success and the attention.

  • Amber M Brown - 4 years ago

    I love supergirl but with Smallville you get more insight on his younger days growing up to an adult and not alot of supergirl past history of her growing up on the site. Very tough decision between the two but I'd have to say Smallville.

  • Kerry Ann - 4 years ago

    Smallville should take this whole tournament. It paved the way for shows like Arrow, supergirl, flash, ledgends etc.
    Im actually rewatchin Smallville in the middle of season 5
    Have the whole series on DvD... Loved the stories and the characters... Tom Welling hands down portrays the best Clark Kent he nailed it... Micheal Rosenbaum was the best Lex Luthor... Erica Durance will always be Lois Lane... Loved Allison Mack as Chloe even tho she was a made up character. Clarks parents were spot on and we cant forget the MAGNIFICENT BASTARD LIONEL LUTHOR showing lex father and how lex was raised in a loveless home showed how he came to be lex back story was one of the best besides Clark of course.
    Hands down Smallville should take the whole turney...
    ALWAYS HOLD ON TO SMALLVILLE!!!!

  • Jaycee - 4 years ago

    I love Smallville, but I had to go Supergirl. I am in the minority, that I know

  • Jay - 4 years ago

    Smallville always gonna be better I'm watching it again right now plus lana and lois sexy

  • Farai - 4 years ago

    Smallville will always win that is like my 1st love lol

  • leb - 4 years ago

    Smallville wins. Hands down.
    Sg is loaded with woke , diverse, current event mainstream news- story telling. I watched it the first season, and part of the second season. Then once it moved to the CW is when it went downhill fast. Terrible characters and character stories. Maybe it's popular with the woke leftist culture for those reasons, but if your comparing using valid comparisons like acting skills, story telling, characters you care about. Then SG is garbage.
    And before you say I'm just a redneck right wing, hater, I'm in love with dreamy. Probably the only good actor on the show. And she's hot.
    Smallville didn't have the cheap looking props, the characters were all very likable and the actors were spectacular.

  • Clark Wilson - 4 years ago

    I chose Smallville obviously. I like Supergirl, but Smallville is the infinitely superior Kryptonian shows. Funny how many if the Supergirl voters here have female names. Not being biased or anything, just pointing out my observation.

  • Mark Truitt - 4 years ago

    Smallville of course. This isn't even a competition. Anyone who says something like Supergirl is better should never have their opinion on anything taken seriously. Without Smallville, none of the current, or shows that have been since its end, would even been possible. And that is the case for both Marvel & DC alike. Hell, no other superhero/comic book show has had Smallville's longevity. That's just a fact. Oh and to the previous guy: No Smallville was not cancelled, it ended. It had a planned series finale & everything. Supergirl was a good idea on paper but was poorly executed. The majority of the series was things they stole from the various Superman comics, movies, & TV shows. They rarely even used anything from Supergirl's 60 plus year mythology. Hence the reason they had to think up something completely new when they decided to do Superman & Lois.

  • Javi - 4 years ago

    How Smallville is canceled and Supergirl is still on is a wonder to me. We were all awaiting to see the storyline move forward with Michael Rosenbaum and Tom Welling as well as the Kryptonians. We never got to advance that part of the story. Thankfully, Krypton came along to fill the void left by Smallville, then yet again, it only went 1 season. Sad...

  • Jeffrey Williams - 4 years ago

    Smallville by a landslide!!! ????Somebody Saaaaaaave Meeeee????

  • Apkorv - 4 years ago

    Supergirl is one of the worst shows ever, it got nothing on Smallville.

  • Shonika - 4 years ago

    As much as I like supergirl
    Smallville is everything I love it
    Smallville definitely have my vote

  • Zaddeus Smith - 4 years ago

    I like Supergirl but I LOVE Smallville. Smallville is literally my favorite show ever so it would actually would win this whole tournament for me...with only one other show as possible competition.

  • JJ Alvarado - 4 years ago

    Smallville of course. Supergirl can't even compete with Smallville!

  • Pierré Kapp - 4 years ago

    There is no debate. This shouldn't even be a question. Smallville wins. Period. End of discussion. Supergirl makes no sense and is just all wrong and boring. After watching Smallville, Supergirl is just.. Bleh. That is all.

  • Lupe - 4 years ago

    Smallville paved the way for the arrowverse. You wouldn't have supergirl without Smallville

  • Matt - 4 years ago

    Another instance where I love both shows. I chose Supergirl because it answers questions to issues that affect us now while maintaining a gripping storyline. Tom Welling will always be my favorite Clark Kent and Michael Rosenbaum will always be the best Lex Luthor, however, the entire cast of Supergirl won me over in spades.

  • Floura Kim - 4 years ago

    Please vote Supergirl y'all it's THE BEST SHOW OF ALL TIME

  • Kaden Laurence - 4 years ago

    Supergirl is the best show every no question????

  • Daniella Farlen - 4 years ago

    Smallville is okay but Supergirl always had me with those cliff hangers

    SUPERGIRL it is

  • Lauren H - 4 years ago

    SUPERGIRL duhh

  • Patricia davis - 4 years ago

    SUPERGIRL is the only way to go

  • Grace - 4 years ago

    SUPERGIRL ALL THE WAY

  • C Teller - 4 years ago

    Smallville kicks every CW show to the curb without breaking a sweat. Michael Rosenbaum > Jon Cryor, Tom Welling > Tyler Hoechlin

  • Mark W. - 4 years ago

    Smallville was the greatest TV show ever made. These new superhero dramas on The CW are trash.

  • Doric Kopinto - 4 years ago

    Smallville was the best CW TV show ever !
    The entire cast was excellent with Muchael
    Rosenbaum the best Lex Luthor ever & Tom
    Welling not given enough credit for playing
    the "big blue boyscout" to perfection ...
    Clark is not an easy part to play plus he
    really looks like Superman ! Also Kristen,
    Laura, Erica. & everyone fantastic ... !

  • Doric Kopinto - 4 years ago

    Smallville was the best CW TV show ever !
    The entire cast was excellent with Muchael
    Rosenbaum the best Lex Luthor ever & Tom
    Welling not given enough credit for playing
    the "big blue boyscout" to perfection ...
    Clark is not an easy part to play plus he
    really looks like Superman ! Also Kristen,
    Laura, Erica. & everyone fantastic ... !

  • Kamel - 4 years ago

    Superman has a boring storyline, I never considered his character exciting. The plot for superman as a high school teenager, discovering his powers was ABSOLUTELY GENIUS!! I've enjoyed every season and I truly miss this show. SMALLVILLE is the best!!

  • Kegan wager - 4 years ago

    Supergirl is way better. She is like the bomb dot com. She has the best personality and the best family. And the best superhero.

  • Mr. John - 4 years ago

    Smallville had higher ups and lower lows than Supergirl.

  • Candace - 4 years ago

    Supergirl

  • Sylvia Contreras - 4 years ago

    Smallville all the way. True fans for all 10 seasons. Have them all on DVD. Awesome actors. Tom Welling and Michael Rosenbum. A lot of other greater actors too.

  • Bobby Stevens - 4 years ago

    Smallville is EPIC

  • James Kisia - 4 years ago

    Smallville all the way...the best CW series and the Godfather behind the Arrowverse....the series that has the best Clark Kent (Tom Welling) and Lex Luthor (Michael Rosenbum) and the best theme song ever!!!

  • Lucy - 4 years ago

    Michael Rosenbaum beats Jon Cryor as Lex Luthor any day.

  • Ada - 4 years ago

    Supergirl all the way!!!

  • Demetri - 4 years ago

    Smallville all day.

  • Zee - 4 years ago

    I like Supergirl but Smallville is everything! And has my favorite Lex Luthor in Superman's story.

  • Kelli - 4 years ago

    I love supergirl, Smallville is okay, but supergirl is really awesome and has some powerful messages.

  • Tim Costello - 4 years ago

    ALWAYS HOLD ON TO SMALLVILLE!!!!!

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.