One Tree Hill is the best and it’s not a show about a tree on a hill. OTH teaches you great lessons. Don’t be Naley and get married in high school. I can’t don’t get pregnant in high school because that happens everyday to teens. OTH for the win!!!!!!
Beth F - 3 years ago
“Always and forever.” -Naley
Lexie - 3 years ago
ONE TREE HILL. Hands down! Best show ever.
Bella M - 3 years ago
Sorry but I’ve seen Smallville when my dad watched all the time on DVD when we had them but I thought it was boring so when he watched it I wouldn’t be in the room so I say One Tree Hill is better tbh sorry
Alexis - 3 years ago
Looking a the comments it could be that One Tree Hill surprise wins over Smallville in this round… (a surprise for me, from the beginning I thought it’d end with Supernatural vs. Smallville)
anna l portman - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill, #1 Always. Always and Forever ;)
Cathy - 3 years ago
My fav two shows is OTH and vampire diaries.
Angela - 3 years ago
Smallville!! The last two to face off should be Supernatural and Smallville. Best two CW shows ever
Matt - 3 years ago
Smallville was in a class of its own. Tom Welling played a phenomenal Clark Kent and Michael Rosenbaum played the best Lex Luthor in the history of the Superman universe. Ultimately, the entire cast, crew, and music scene set the bar for all superhero shows that would follow. Go Smallville!
Stephen - 3 years ago
Smallville all day everyday
Tina - 3 years ago
Smallville the final two have to be smallville and Supernatural! Of course Supernatural will win but Smallville is just as awesome! And of course they both have Jensen Ackles in them!
Erica - 3 years ago
Smallville!!!! OTH was so boring!!! You people have no imagination and it shows!!
Jaxson Phoenix Sr - 3 years ago
Smallville all the way.
Shelly - 3 years ago
One tree hill is my favorite show of all time.
Kate - 3 years ago
OTH always & forever
jimmy woo - 3 years ago
Smallville... I love it. I still watch it.
Jason Frady - 3 years ago
If you haven't watch a show how can you say it's boring
Bella C - 3 years ago
Sorry I’m not a fan of Smallville really plus I haven’t seen it I kinda also think it’s boring tbh so I say OTH is better
Becky - 3 years ago
I was just about to go watch One Tree Hill tbh it’s a good show and I love it
Alex - 3 years ago
I'm actually slowly re-watching OTH since I was a teenager when it was first on tv, and it's still SO good. Love that show, definitely gets my vote over Smallville!
I’m voting for ONE TREE HILL one tree hill forever
Bailey - 3 years ago
“There is only One Tree Hill.” One Tree Hill 4eva!!!
Ava - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill baby
Princess Aurora - 3 years ago
This Princess votes for OTH
Aurora - 3 years ago
OTH!!!!!!
P - 3 years ago
The Michaelsons lost? What a surprise. Should have known some stupid show no one has ever heard of would win. And now that stupid show about a tree on a hill is gonna win against Smallville too I suppose. Unbelievable.
Ashley - 3 years ago
Scott Brothers for the win baby!!!
Ariel - 3 years ago
OTH forever baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jill - 3 years ago
That's a tough one. Loved both shows. But for me, it's Smallville! Loved how they brought Tom Welling and Erica Durance back for the Arrowverse crossover Crisis of Infinite Earths. It made me miss Smallville even more. Would love a spinoff with both those actors back and Michael R.'s Lex!
Aria P - 3 years ago
OTH for the win baby!!!! The Scott Brothers beat the Mikaelson Brothers which I find shocking tbh but still OTH 4ever
Aria - 3 years ago
This pretty little liar loves OTH so she votes for them sorry Smallville fans
Apple - 3 years ago
OTH for the win!!!!!
Antoinette - 3 years ago
OTH Forever!!!!!
Taylor - 3 years ago
Smallville
Regina - 3 years ago
I watched OTH with my bestie and her sister so tbh I vote on OTH cause I think it’s the best
Anna Z - 3 years ago
As Naley says Always and Forever so I will be always and forever be OTH fan
moonlight - 3 years ago
Let's see.. Angsty teens versus angsty teens doing the Superman legend. That's an easy one. Smallville, of course.
Andrea - 3 years ago
OTH baby!!!!!
Amelia M - 3 years ago
I love OTH I keep watching it over again on Hulu
Amber - 3 years ago
Sorry but I’m crazy about Naley so therefore OTH is my vote
Brooke - 3 years ago
Just go Brooke yourself
Haley - 3 years ago
Always and forever
Henry christophe - 3 years ago
Smallville of course,too much drama on one tree hill,could not stick with it ,on the other hand I saw all the episodes from Smallville, even own the serie on DVD!
Amaya - 3 years ago
OTH is the best!!!!!
Amanda - 3 years ago
You are gonna have to Brooke yourself if you don’t vote OTH but like Naley says to each other Always and forever
Allison - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill is always and forever
C Teller - 3 years ago
Always hold on to Smallville.
Alison - 3 years ago
Always and forever gonna be OTH
Crystal - 3 years ago
100% OTH
Amelia Boos - 3 years ago
SMALLVILLE 4EVER!!
Kallark - 3 years ago
Smallville!
Laura - 3 years ago
You All Better Go Brooke Yourselves If You Didn't Vote OTH!!!! ????
Sara - 3 years ago
OTH Always!!
Brianna - 3 years ago
SMALLVILLE HANDS DOWN THE BEST NO CAP (tom welling fine self????)
Jay - 3 years ago
It’s Smallville. The 2 best shows this network has ever had were Supernatural and Smallville. Both gone now, never forgotten. And they will be the final 2 shows to battle it out. Sorry to fans of the others, can’t stop Clark Kent’s destiny to take on The Winchesters.
Alison C - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill always sorry Smallville fans
Alice - 3 years ago
I never really watch Smallville yet but I think my dad use to watch it when I was younger but in my opinion One Tree Hill is better
Mona - 3 years ago
I watched OTH with my sister and I must say I love it just as much as her so my vote is for One Tree Hill
Alexis - 3 years ago
OTH *heart eyes* all the way!!!!
Flower - 3 years ago
ONE TREE HILL!
Small villa was boring. In my opinion
But I think the winner of this whole thing will be the best show ever!
Supernatural
Alexa R - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill!!!!!
Purvies Taylor - 3 years ago
The CW programming would never have lasted to create all the other shows if it wasn't for Smallville!
Jennifer - 3 years ago
“Always hold onto Smallville”
Joseph P Toth - 3 years ago
One tree hill.
Nomcy - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill
Dwight - 3 years ago
Smallville all the way. If it wasn't for smallville their would be no arrowverse. Supernatural would be #2. Stopped watching OTH after season 3
Purvies - 3 years ago
Both are great shows but OTH is from the creators of Smallville so Smallville is the winning OG!
Farai - 3 years ago
It was always gonna be Smallville
Zaddeus D Smith - 3 years ago
I love me some OTH but not more than Smallville takes the cake for me. Smallville wins the whole tourney for me...even if it's going against my 2nd favorite show ever in the final four.
Mansoor - 3 years ago
Always Smallville
Fran - 3 years ago
Smallville
Mia - 3 years ago
OTH Always & Forever
KimTC - 3 years ago
Always hold on to Smallville!!!!
S - 3 years ago
I love them both. This one was hard but in the end Smallvile better in my opinion
Sara - 3 years ago
Love OTH 100% but had to go with Smallville 100%
Kyndra - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill always and forever!
Dannii - 3 years ago
SMALLVILLE ALWAYS ????????????????
Alexa - 3 years ago
OTH has my vote 100%
Alexa - 3 years ago
OTH has my vote 100%
Alexa - 3 years ago
OTH has my vote 100%
Alexa - 3 years ago
OTH has my vote 100%
Alexa - 3 years ago
OTH has my vote 100%
Sal Galvan - 3 years ago
Smallville is the show that keep superman relevant for so many years! I have to admit there were times when the show lagged but I kept watching all seasons! It paid off when Clark got his CGI suit! LOL!
Summer - 3 years ago
Love both shows so very much, but I had to go with Smallville on this one.
Kisha - 3 years ago
I loved both shows, but I gotta go with Smallville
Abby - 3 years ago
OTH all the way!!!
Vanessa - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill!!!!
Lisa - 3 years ago
OTH
Beth - 3 years ago
One Tree Hill????????????
Katy - 3 years ago
OTH ALWAYS & FOREVER
Ripper777 - 3 years ago
Smallville has this in the bag, no need for any super powers here
novoten - 3 years ago
I know OTH has no chance but beating The Originals was a huge success by itself. Top 1 show always and forever
Liz - 3 years ago
Oth all day, everyday
Anna - 3 years ago
How am I supposed to choose?! My favorite Superman story, or Naley/Leyton/Brulian?! Durance vs. Bush?! Superman vs. Basketball?! You’ve really hurt me this time, TVLine…..
One Tree Hill is the best and it’s not a show about a tree on a hill. OTH teaches you great lessons. Don’t be Naley and get married in high school. I can’t don’t get pregnant in high school because that happens everyday to teens. OTH for the win!!!!!!
“Always and forever.” -Naley
ONE TREE HILL. Hands down! Best show ever.
Sorry but I’ve seen Smallville when my dad watched all the time on DVD when we had them but I thought it was boring so when he watched it I wouldn’t be in the room so I say One Tree Hill is better tbh sorry
Looking a the comments it could be that One Tree Hill surprise wins over Smallville in this round… (a surprise for me, from the beginning I thought it’d end with Supernatural vs. Smallville)
One Tree Hill, #1 Always. Always and Forever ;)
My fav two shows is OTH and vampire diaries.
Smallville!! The last two to face off should be Supernatural and Smallville. Best two CW shows ever
Smallville was in a class of its own. Tom Welling played a phenomenal Clark Kent and Michael Rosenbaum played the best Lex Luthor in the history of the Superman universe. Ultimately, the entire cast, crew, and music scene set the bar for all superhero shows that would follow. Go Smallville!
Smallville all day everyday
Smallville the final two have to be smallville and Supernatural! Of course Supernatural will win but Smallville is just as awesome! And of course they both have Jensen Ackles in them!
Smallville!!!! OTH was so boring!!! You people have no imagination and it shows!!
Smallville all the way.
One tree hill is my favorite show of all time.
OTH always & forever
Smallville... I love it. I still watch it.
If you haven't watch a show how can you say it's boring
Sorry I’m not a fan of Smallville really plus I haven’t seen it I kinda also think it’s boring tbh so I say OTH is better
I was just about to go watch One Tree Hill tbh it’s a good show and I love it
I'm actually slowly re-watching OTH since I was a teenager when it was first on tv, and it's still SO good. Love that show, definitely gets my vote over Smallville!
I’m voting for ONE TREE HILL one tree hill forever
I’m voting for ONE TREE HILL one tree hill forever
“There is only One Tree Hill.” One Tree Hill 4eva!!!
One Tree Hill baby
This Princess votes for OTH
OTH!!!!!!
The Michaelsons lost? What a surprise. Should have known some stupid show no one has ever heard of would win. And now that stupid show about a tree on a hill is gonna win against Smallville too I suppose. Unbelievable.
Scott Brothers for the win baby!!!
OTH forever baby!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
That's a tough one. Loved both shows. But for me, it's Smallville! Loved how they brought Tom Welling and Erica Durance back for the Arrowverse crossover Crisis of Infinite Earths. It made me miss Smallville even more. Would love a spinoff with both those actors back and Michael R.'s Lex!
OTH for the win baby!!!! The Scott Brothers beat the Mikaelson Brothers which I find shocking tbh but still OTH 4ever
This pretty little liar loves OTH so she votes for them sorry Smallville fans
OTH for the win!!!!!
OTH Forever!!!!!
Smallville
I watched OTH with my bestie and her sister so tbh I vote on OTH cause I think it’s the best
As Naley says Always and Forever so I will be always and forever be OTH fan
Let's see.. Angsty teens versus angsty teens doing the Superman legend. That's an easy one. Smallville, of course.
OTH baby!!!!!
I love OTH I keep watching it over again on Hulu
Sorry but I’m crazy about Naley so therefore OTH is my vote
Just go Brooke yourself
Always and forever
Smallville of course,too much drama on one tree hill,could not stick with it ,on the other hand I saw all the episodes from Smallville, even own the serie on DVD!
OTH is the best!!!!!
You are gonna have to Brooke yourself if you don’t vote OTH but like Naley says to each other Always and forever
One Tree Hill is always and forever
Always hold on to Smallville.
Always and forever gonna be OTH
100% OTH
SMALLVILLE 4EVER!!
Smallville!
You All Better Go Brooke Yourselves If You Didn't Vote OTH!!!! ????
OTH Always!!
SMALLVILLE HANDS DOWN THE BEST NO CAP (tom welling fine self????)
It’s Smallville. The 2 best shows this network has ever had were Supernatural and Smallville. Both gone now, never forgotten. And they will be the final 2 shows to battle it out. Sorry to fans of the others, can’t stop Clark Kent’s destiny to take on The Winchesters.
One Tree Hill always sorry Smallville fans
I never really watch Smallville yet but I think my dad use to watch it when I was younger but in my opinion One Tree Hill is better
I watched OTH with my sister and I must say I love it just as much as her so my vote is for One Tree Hill
OTH *heart eyes* all the way!!!!
ONE TREE HILL!
Small villa was boring. In my opinion
But I think the winner of this whole thing will be the best show ever!
Supernatural
One Tree Hill!!!!!
The CW programming would never have lasted to create all the other shows if it wasn't for Smallville!
“Always hold onto Smallville”
One tree hill.
One Tree Hill
Smallville all the way. If it wasn't for smallville their would be no arrowverse. Supernatural would be #2. Stopped watching OTH after season 3
Both are great shows but OTH is from the creators of Smallville so Smallville is the winning OG!
It was always gonna be Smallville
I love me some OTH but not more than Smallville takes the cake for me. Smallville wins the whole tourney for me...even if it's going against my 2nd favorite show ever in the final four.
Always Smallville
Smallville
OTH Always & Forever
Always hold on to Smallville!!!!
I love them both. This one was hard but in the end Smallvile better in my opinion
Love OTH 100% but had to go with Smallville 100%
One Tree Hill always and forever!
SMALLVILLE ALWAYS ????????????????
OTH has my vote 100%
OTH has my vote 100%
OTH has my vote 100%
OTH has my vote 100%
OTH has my vote 100%
Smallville is the show that keep superman relevant for so many years! I have to admit there were times when the show lagged but I kept watching all seasons! It paid off when Clark got his CGI suit! LOL!
Love both shows so very much, but I had to go with Smallville on this one.
I loved both shows, but I gotta go with Smallville
OTH all the way!!!
One Tree Hill!!!!
OTH
One Tree Hill????????????
OTH ALWAYS & FOREVER
Smallville has this in the bag, no need for any super powers here
I know OTH has no chance but beating The Originals was a huge success by itself. Top 1 show always and forever
Oth all day, everyday
How am I supposed to choose?! My favorite Superman story, or Naley/Leyton/Brulian?! Durance vs. Bush?! Superman vs. Basketball?! You’ve really hurt me this time, TVLine…..
.