Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo
569 Comments

  • Hailee - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Matt - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Matt - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Annie Arnold - 3 years ago

    I knew it would probably come down to these two shows.
    Smallville is the only acceptable show I would take winning this contest if Supernatural does not win.
    Vampire Diaries would of been my next choice.

  • Kathy - 3 years ago

    BUT, it's all REAL! It's the family business. Buttercup!
    I had this Shojo following me just last weekend.

  • Kathy - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL. Best ever they're my people, they're my tribe, they're my family. It's always a hell of a ride, the writing, actors, costumes, make up, directing.
    The special effects were special, the one liners are priceless. It just always feels like a good time.
    I have it on a few hours everyday since 2015.
    Wish I could have had a meet and greet.
    THIS SHOW WAS A PERFECT STORM the likes of which will never be seen again. Wishing everyone well.
    I deeply miss all my super friends and family.

  • Lori - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL

  • Monique Keener - 3 years ago

    Supernatural till the end

  • Rya - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. That show was great,! And even though the final episode was not up to par, every other episode was fantastic. One main plot with tons of little subplots in each episode was a stroke of genius. It was original and a lot of the lore was pretty accurate. It was fun and exciting to watch. Even my hubby liked it, and he doesn't like any of that "make believe stuff" ( Harry Potter, LOTR, Vampires, fairy tales, etc).

  • Seren Witriyani - 3 years ago

    Supernatural!

  • Nanci RC - 3 years ago

    Supernatural, la mejor serie para siempre, la que nunca olvidaré, la que siempre volveré a ver una y otra vez y la que fue la perfecta combinación de drama, miedo, comedia, acción, aventuras y la mejor química entre los protagonistas, dos hermanos en la serie y en la realidad

  • Aya Ahmed - 3 years ago

    Supernatural foreverrr.

  • Kelly Gears - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Mandi - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way!!!!!

  • Jason - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Drake - 3 years ago

    As good as Supernatural is I gotta say Smallville because Supernatural ending was soo BAD. IT WAS TERRIBLE, but Smallville had a much more satisfying ending...not to mention best theme song ever

  • Natasha - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Andrea - 3 years ago

    Supernatural no question

  • Rae wacker - 3 years ago

    Smallville, only this.

  • Kayla - 3 years ago

    Supernatural!!!

  • Yael - 3 years ago

    Supernatural is the best series of all time! To think I waited till it had already ended to watch it, just cause I don’t like hyped stuff. Lesson learned, hyped stuff can be pretty good too ????
    I wish I could watch and laugh with Dean and Sam for another 10 years! Watching the show for the 3rd time in less than 6 months btw ????

  • Sara - 3 years ago

    Supernatural! ????

  • Dina - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL,not for the actors but for the show itself its amazing I cam watch it over and over with not getting tired of it as for smallville watched it once and it was not bad but cant watch it again

  • Sylvia - 3 years ago

    Supernatural !! Hands down, shit i was hoping for a spin off with the wayward sisters from another mother.

  • KYLE ROBL - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Karen D Kaiser - 3 years ago

    Supernatural, Veronica Mars and up til recently Legends are the only shows ever worth watching on this channel. WB/UPN had tits and ads garbage except WB Supernatural and UPN's Star Trek Voyager until they replaced Jennifer Lien's Jes with the bosses girlfriend Jeri Ryan aka 7 of DD.

    Who was placed there solely for her breasts because she can't act proven by anything she was in being cancelled with in a year. Now CW continues with the boobarama. Instead of the sassy intelligent Wayward Sisters we get the silly screaming idiots of rebooted Charmed.

    Oh but they're not white and 1 is gay. So? Where have you been? Mob squad for non white and the Lieutenant for gay. 2 male gay men in a bed in 30 something. CW is behind the times but thinks they're cutting edge.

  • Hollie - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL HANDS DOWN????????????????????????

  • Lisa B - 3 years ago

    Supernatural... duh

  • Sara Ghaddar - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Duh.

  • Susan Moffitt - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Now, tomorrow and always

  • Any Wilson - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Every day.

  • Kimberly bachelier - 3 years ago

    Supernatural forever!!!!

  • Wanda R May - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL FAN TIL THE DAY I DIE.
    ABSOLUTELY THE BEST

  • Wanda R May - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL FAN TIL THE DAY I DIE.
    ABSOLUTELY THE BEST

  • Heda - 3 years ago

    Both shows are great, but noone can beat those lovely assbutts. Spn fam????

  • Clay Williams - 3 years ago

    Can't decide

  • Noel A Estrada - 3 years ago

    Supernatural of course i like Smallville but I love Supernatural and I grew up watching it.

  • Amy Lyon - 3 years ago

    There’s a reason I’ve only seen the other shows 20 times and I’m STILL watching supernatural for my 100th time you never get tired of it I love Sam and Dean….they make me laugh and are so awesome and wish it had been at least 20 seasons ……but I’ll NEVER get tired of rewatching it’s all I do all day….SUPERNATURAL is the best movie that will ever be made! And that’s my vote supernatural though I own all the series of both movies

  • Zonnica - 3 years ago

    Clicked the link,said thanks for voting but I didn't vote.

    SUPERNATURAL ALL THE WAY

  • Amy A Baker - 3 years ago

    Supernatural lasted for 15 yrs for a reason. Just two words "Sam & dean". Of course, Cass. They stopped 3 apocalypses oh and saved the world and make it gd again by taking chuck down and raising jack. Superman cldnt touch them w a 10 ft poll. They've got magic, weapons, and an angel. Smallville has the name for a reason.

  • Sean Barry - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Guadalupe - 3 years ago

    Supernatural, always ????

  • Cindy - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way. Hated to see it end. ????????

  • Gordon mickey - 3 years ago

    SAM & DEAN OFCOARSE THE BEST !!!!!

  • Svetlana - 3 years ago

    Supernatural!

  • Priscilla - 3 years ago

    I watched Smallville and I am a huge fan on the show. Tom Welling is an exceptional actor who really made you believe you were seeing the origin story of Superman. If Supernatural was not in this poll, I would've chosen Smallville. But Supernatural hands down is the best show ever on the CW. It made me laugh, cry and every emotion in between. The acting, writing and fan loyalty made this show extraordinary. Every time I wear my Supernatural t-shirt, I am stopped by people who want to talk about it. I am part of a group of people who have watch parties once a month with favorite Supernatural episodes. Supernatural is also a bonding experience with die hard fans. So I have to say Supernatural all the way.

  • Tressa - 3 years ago

    The boys. Always the boys. Wait! There was a show called Smallville? Eh. Who cares. Always my boys. In this order. Dean Sam Bobby Crowley and Cass. Idjits. Not even a question. Lol.

  • Pukuana Kumendong - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way! Its only the best show ever, awesome actors, characters, storylines and directing…..I love everything about it……SPN family forever!! ????

  • Sharon - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way!!!

  • TheDeadJester - 3 years ago

    Supernatural bored the hell out of me and apparently didn't draw in much in the way of ratings either. Everyone talking about bringing it back couldn't get many people to watch it at the end any way. I'll take Smallville

  • Valentina - 3 years ago

    Supernatural over and over again.
    The Winchester brothers are legends and legends never die.
    Team fee will 2.0 ????

  • Henry - 3 years ago

    Smallville all the way!!!

  • Braam - 3 years ago

    It is impossible to decide. Both these shows has been by far my favourite 2 shows. It should be a draw

  • Pauline Snyder - 3 years ago

    Enjoyed watching the bond between the brothers and how th;ey had each others back. And they definitely weren't hard to look at.

  • Carebear - 3 years ago

    Sam and Dean All the Way EVERYTIME!!!!

  • Woodsie - 3 years ago

    I'll throw this out there. Was an spn actor or actress sentenced to prison for being involved in a sex cult? No, but Smallville did. ????????

  • Ghoul - 3 years ago

    If it were sam & Dean v. Superman, they'd find a way to kill him quick. Especially since they know how to do magic

  • Ghoul - 3 years ago

    If Smallville beats Supernatural in the poll. That just means the poll is rigged. Everyone knows SPN is better than Smallville. Both are good but SPN is 1000x better

  • Angie - 3 years ago

    I have watched then both. I am a hard core fan of SPN. I continue to watch it on Netflix and honestly is the only reason I keep the subscription. I am a Dean girl. Even though Jensen is in Smallville still not enough to make me watch it all the time for that one season.

  • Debbie - 3 years ago

    Smallville always Still watch on hulu

  • Pendragon - 3 years ago

    I love both Supernatural and Smallville. I chose Smallville because I love Superman and wanting to be just like Clark Kent made me lose 67lbs right after high school! But, one show that was left off this list that would have clearly been a frontrunner right to the finish... Gilmore Girls! That show was more popular than both Supernatural and Smallville in its heyday.

  • Shonika - 3 years ago

    Let me say this again
    As much as I love Smallville
    SUPERNATURAL WILL ALWAYS WIN

    WINCHESTER
    TEAM FREE WILL
    2.0

  • Jenny Miller - 3 years ago

    Supernatural was a great show such great episodes massive fan of it loved the cast especially the main characters shame it had too end

  • Melanie - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. All day, every day, any day. So much more than 15 seasons of a fantastic show, SPN leaves behind a legacy far beyond reruns. It had a greater impact on the world that no other show before it can lay claim to. The “little show that could” most certainly did.

  • Sabrina Cole - 3 years ago

    Dude spn period I sincerely like smallville but my boys and yes that includes cas too will always win period

  • Shalle - 3 years ago

    Definitely SUPERNATURAL!!! ALWAYS, FOREVER, my boys will kick this contest in the ass like they have everything else!!!

  • Ana - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Winn - 3 years ago

    Spn fam all the way. Supernatural created something for me that no show ever could the supernatural family is a found family for sure but unlike any family ive ever seen real ride or dies for each other. Quoting another member of our family "if you ever need a ride or die just put i love supernatural on tumblr

  • Jennifer Hill - 3 years ago

    Supernatural but if smallville won I wouldn't be mad because I like that show too but I luv supernatural

  • Sylvia - 3 years ago

    Is there really any competition? 15 years of love for the show and the characters. Always true to supernatural.

  • Star - 3 years ago

    Supernatural HANDS DOWN

  • Star - 3 years ago

    Supernatural HANDS DOWN

  • Alexandra - 3 years ago

    Supernatural!!!

  • Laura C Crews - 3 years ago

    I really want smallvile to come back on the air too my favorite shows with all the same people

  • Laura C Crews - 3 years ago

    I absolutely love smallvile but supernatural kicks butt and I wish it was back on the air i love jarods p. New show walker but I like supernatural better. I miss Sam and dean and I keep watching the reruns but if chuck can bring them back from heaven 100 times then there new god can too and bring the whole family back together since walking dead. Is going off the air too. Wait why do they take all the best shows in the world. Off the air

  • Chelsea Pusczak - 3 years ago

    I love how the Supernatural fandom is going to take over and crush this poll like they do everything else. Supernatural made something special no one else can recreate. Sending love for our boys!

  • Helena - 3 years ago

    I really liked Smallville. But Supernatural I LOVE.❤️ The best series ever made.

  • Patricia - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL ALL THE WAY!!!!

    I DON'T BUY DVD'S OF TV SHOWS, LET ALONE SEASON'S. BUT I DO OWN EVERY SEASON (ALL 15) OF SUPERNATURAL. THAT SHOULD TELL YOU SOMETHING ABOUT HOW OUTSTANDING THIS SERIES IS...
    PLUS, EVEN THOUGH I OWN ALL 15 SEASON'S , I STILL WATCH SUPERNATURAL ON CHANNEL TNT. ????

  • Iveta - 3 years ago

    Supernatural absolutely the best show. Jensen and Jared are excellent actors, of coure there are a lot of great actors on this show. l laughed with them, cried and waited impatiently for more part. Supernatural is the best for me and l believe it will be for a long time. Love my boys....forever

  • Asia - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Alex Mac - 3 years ago

    Smallville hands down wins in my opinion. Smallville is the original first show that brought all these new shows to life like the flash and green arrow, all originated from Smallville. If it wasn't for Smallville Supernatural wouldn't even have existed because Jensen Ackles was originally a character in Smallville. He character gets killed off after 4 seasons. Once that happened he went on and started Supernatural. Plus Smallville hands down has the best portrayal of LEX LUTHOR EVER that alone is hard to beat. Michael Rosenbaum played that character perfectly.

  • Stefania - 3 years ago

    Supernatural sempre mi è piaciuto Smallville, ma adoro Supernatural e i nostri meravigliosi fratelli, con tutto il contorno di buoni e cattivi. Una delle serie più belle che abbia mai visto

  • Sapna - 3 years ago

    Supernatural always my fav show no matter what r the choices...

  • Tharani M - 3 years ago

    Supernatural always...

  • Flora - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL all the way. Wow what a rollercoaster. From the first episode to the last. And I laughed, cried and celebrated all the way.

  • Erin - 3 years ago

    Superntural for the sheer fact is was original. Based off of a simple theory "saving people, hunting things. The family business."

  • Mitakshi - 3 years ago

    Team supernatural ❤️

  • Alex L. - 3 years ago

    Supernatural wins even though I love both series 15 seasons of original work

  • Michael - 3 years ago

    Smallville was the original of the new superhero shows; the other show was just another mix of horror tropes that were common before it and continue, where you can see more original ideas in that genre like Lovecraft Country or Servant, to name just two recent examples. Smallville easily has my support.

  • Edward Nigma - 3 years ago

    I picked Supernatural. Smallville was great, but Supernatural was better. They had better material to draw inspiration from and every episode was amazing. Jared and Jensen were the perfect duo.

  • Alexander.H - 3 years ago

    I love Supernatural I am totally team Sam BUT SMALLVILLE allows us to see Superman before he is Superman why I love the upside & down of supernatural and the Winchester Brothers. I watch them from the very beginning and I fell in love with them I was the first of my family to watch Sam and Dean doing what they do best but I can say the same about Superman about Clark Kent, Smallville each generation has their own story of Superman but through all of the Superman.but I've seen the comics the animes the movies I can't find a Smallville maybe I just wasn't looking hard enough what Superman is Smallville and Smallville is Our Generations Superman origin story so my vote is Smallville all the way

  • Megan - 3 years ago

    Smallville takes the cake for me. It took Superman to the next level. Most of us watched that show and grew up right alongside the characters. And I can rewatch it over and over and never get bored. Supernatural.. I really enjoyed the first couple seasons. The paranormal and different creatures. It reminded me of Charmed. And then religion started coming in the mix, and taking over every episode; so they lost my interest there. TV was supposed to be an escape from all that, until it wasn't. So I didn't even finish the series.

  • Jasmine Rollins - 3 years ago

    Supernatural 1000% without a doubt in my mind. Two bad ass brothers taking on demons, angels, and other Supernatural beings, plus who couldn't love when Dean screamed because of the cat in the locker. Plus both of them were so handsome, who wouldn't wanna watch the show. Haha.

  • Eleanor - 3 years ago

    SMALLVILLE of course!
    SMALLVILLE paved the way for all of CW's shows thereafter to today.
    SMALLVILLE hands down!

  • Patrice - 3 years ago

    I love supernatural and always will .The boys yes

  • Mubaraka Suratwala - 3 years ago

    Supernatural...

  • Mary Reynolds - 3 years ago

    Supernatural best show ever, I love this show hated it had to end. I still watch reruns almost every day. I never get tired of watching this show.

  • Alex - 3 years ago

    Supernatural will obviously win, it's the best series I've ever seen and my favorite actor appears in it (Jensen) so definitely SUPERNATURAL

  • Keith - 3 years ago

    I love Superman, but Supernatural, in my opinion is the better series. The last episode of Supernatural had me bawling. It was on today, September 16th on TNT. I was invested emotionally in the Winchesters, their live for each other was palpable as well as the other characters they loved, Castiel, Jack, Bobbie, their mom Mary, their dad, the other hunters and the others. The whole show was superb. It could have endlessly gone on, but it didn't. It helped reinforce my fauth. Thank you Supernatural.

  • Casey - 3 years ago

    Supernatural hands down all day every day!! Nothing beats the family togetherness, beautiful people, comedic relief, and magical touch of Supernatural. They really were a tight knit crew and you can feel the love just watching it. I absolutely love the characters and how they vibe together. If you don’t vote for Supernatural, you’re an IDJIT! ????

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.