Thank you for voting Crowdsignal Logo
569 Comments

  • Walter - 3 years ago

    SMALLVILLE!!!! There was no better show!

  • P. Roman - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL gets my vote I started watching when I was placed once a week in a hyperbaric chamber to help heal my right leg ( lost the leg anyway) the boys and the show got me through they would always put them on for me to watch once I went to help keep me calm, very claustrophobic. Sometimes I would close my eyes and just listen to the calming voices. Thanks guys for getting me through. Good luck.

  • P - 3 years ago

    I'm just so happy Smallville won against that stupid tree on a hill nonsense ????!.. I love both Smallville and supernatural. Like choosing between your own children ????.

  • Salvina D Polizzi - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Kyle Seagar - 3 years ago

    Smallville.. without question for me

  • Laura Detjen - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Even when it was inconsistent, it was still more compelling than anything else out there. I watched Smallville too, but after Michael Rosenbaum left, I lost interest. He was probably the reason I watched the show in the first place because I find superheroes boring. I did perk up in season 4 of Smallville when Jensen was in it. I followed him to Supernatural and was hooked for 15 years.

  • Laura Detjen - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Even when it was inconsistent, it was still more compelling than anything else out there. I watched Smallville too, but after Michael Rosenbaum left, I lost interest. He was probably the reason I watched the show in the first place because I ind superheroes boring. I did perk up in season 4 of Smallville when Jensen was in it. I followed him to Supernatural and was hooked for 15 years.

  • Jay - 3 years ago

    Correctly predicted each matchup from beginning to now. I wrote in the beginning it would come down to the top 2 shows Supernatural vs Smallville as they were and still are the best this network has had. It’s destiny for the Winchesters to face the Man of Steel. In the end, the gold standard, top of the food chain can be only 1. And without a doubt, the best show is Supernatural. Much love to Smallville, you’ll always be one of my favs, but congrats to the eventual and rightful winning Winchesters. Carry On Supernatural, Carry On.

  • K Kuz - 3 years ago

    SPN forever, family don't end in blood. Saving people, hunting things, the family business. Joined the hunt in 2005 and will watch till I die. The SPN fandom is the greatest in the world. No other fandom will ever come close to it.

  • Pamela - 3 years ago

    Always Supernatural, it's more than a show. Dean Winchester is one of the greatest characters ever and there's no one like the Angel Castiel. Such heart and sacrifice. The spn Fandom will live on forever.

  • Pauline - 3 years ago

    Smallville was good but Supernatural was my obsession show for 15 years. Great stories and strong relationships are what draw me to a show. My new obsession is Prodigal Son, but Supernatural will remain one of the best shows ever for me.

  • Vale - 3 years ago

    It will always be Supernatural SPN FAMILY FOREVER

  • Dyna - 3 years ago

    Supernatural is the best!

  • Missdeemontanamade - 3 years ago

    Supernatural is my absolute favorite show!!!!!❤❤❤❤

  • Jeff - 3 years ago

    Supernatural..anyday im off work mondays- thurs im always watching.. Never gets old and i believe better than any show.. Lets go Supernatural..

  • Morgan - 3 years ago

    Supernatural for the win. I hated hated hateddd the ending, but overall I did love the majority of the show. Seasons 1-5 are sl just perfection and I have a soft spot for Jack’s introduction episodes/early season 13.

  • Helena - 3 years ago

    Supernatural for the win. I can watch it over and over again, except for the last season and the one with metatron. Smallville was just ok. Honestly, superman's back story really isn't all that interesting, it's very limited in creativity just because of the story line. Supernatural covered everything, though sometimes repetitive, still far more interesting than Smallville. And the Fandom of supernatural is out of this world.

  • emilie_fastsagafr - 3 years ago

    Supernatural ❤️????

  • Christine - 3 years ago

    Totally unequivocally SUPERNATURAL all the way, all the time, every time!! Love my Boys!

  • emilie_fastsagafr - 3 years ago

    Let's go Supernatural yes dr badass Buenos dias bitches ❤️????????

  • Jason - 3 years ago

    Tough choice. These are 2 of my 4 all-time favorite tv shows, regardless of network, genre, or era. Ultimately went with Smallville for the win. Smallville only had 2 bad seasons (8 and 9), and 2 mediocre seasons (6 and 10). Supernatural had a lot more than just 2 bad seasons, and 2 mediocre seasons, and was literally supposed to end a decade earlier. It became way too inconsistent (1 bad season, then 1 good season) after season 5.

    However, Supernatural seasons 4 and 5 were friggin epic! Had it ended after season 5 like it was originally supposed to, I would have voted for it. But, it was allowed to go on for WAY too long after that, to the point where its quality became too diluted and it was a shadow of its former self. After season 8, there were more bad episodes than good ones, but still displayed flashes of brilliance several times a season.

    Interesting that Jensen Ackles was on both shows (Smallville season 4, then Supernatural season 1 began right after that).

  • emilie_fastsagafr - 3 years ago

    Supernatural Always dr badass. ????????❤️

  • TY - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Connman - 3 years ago

    Easy pick for me - Smallville is the best!

  • Melissa Zugelter - 3 years ago

    I love Supernatural. I've watched all 15yr episodes. I could watch them for life. They're the Greatest m

  • Kdz - 3 years ago

    Despite one of the worst endings to a great show ever. Still gotta vote Supernatural

  • LeeLaa Crowley - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way. I've watched both shows and Supernatural wins 100%

  • Anthony McCubbins - 3 years ago

    Although I think Supernatural will win this contest, I am still going with Smallville for my vote. These are probably my all time two favorite shows. Can't be mad no matter who takes first or second between these two great shows!

  • Victoria - 3 years ago

    Smallville. I have not watched one episode of Supernatural and I don't plan to.

  • Maria Wellman - 3 years ago

    Love Supernatural

  • Michelle - 3 years ago

    Both my top favourite shows, but gonna have to go with My boys The Winchesters SPN for the win

  • christine Lake - 3 years ago

    Although I liked Smallville, for me there can be no comparison. Supernatural forever. I am on my 5th or 6th rewatch (but only 2nd time all the way 1 to 15)

  • Russell Collins - 3 years ago

    Smallville by far was the best show.

  • Tanya G - 3 years ago

    Supernatural Always!! I've lost count of how many times I've rewatched this series.

  • Asif - 3 years ago

    I mean there are a lot of superman based show out there, even one is still going on. But SUPERNATURAL is one and only one. You cant find a show like this one, the best. #SPNfamily

  • Connie Dauch - 3 years ago

    Who would vote for Smallville when the real deal is Supernatural. GISH and SPN forever ,salt and a shotgun, I could deal with that!

  • Rob - 3 years ago

    LOVE both of these shows and won’t be mad at either winning but I have to go with Smallville here!

  • kath - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL !!!! ????????????

  • Abihail marcano - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL 100000000000000000000000000000% X 100000000%

  • Hajjsjs - 3 years ago

    ???? super

  • d0x360 - 3 years ago

    Listen... Supernatural was great for 5 seasons. Good for 7 and absolutely garbage for the rest.

    Smallville on the other hand was great by half way through season 1 and stayed great until it's last episode.

  • Tony - 3 years ago

    Smallville was a good Show. But I still have to go all the way with SUPERNATURAL !!!!!

  • Starla - 3 years ago

    All you SPN loyals come join us on FB SUPERNATURAL fanatics

  • Camillia - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL 1000%
    Such a great show I still to this day can't watch the final episode without crying......Also the characters were fine ass hell!!!! They need to make a movie!!! Smallville there's so many adaption of superman, I mean we all know whats going to happen just watch the movie and read the damn comic books.

  • ShellyK - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL !! ???? Don't forget the salt! ????

  • Luke - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Nate - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Susan Boyd Garrett - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!! I miss all of them. I miss the whole bunch. Watched it from the first episode, and killed my heart when they decided their run was done, they thought. Hey I am ready for 15 more years. SUPERNATURAL ROCKS FOREVER.!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Kristen Parks - 3 years ago

    Supernatural always and forever!
    #SPNFAMILY!

  • Maggie - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Bob - 3 years ago

    Smallville all the WAY!!! Been off the air for over 10 years and it is still at the top of the list. Supernatural just went off the air last year, so you have more people with it fresh in their minds.

    It is the show that started ALL the CW "Super" shows.

  • Remi - 3 years ago

    Smallville

  • Fonda - 3 years ago

    Supernatural!!! One of the best shows ever!!

  • Kimmie - 3 years ago

    Supernatural for the win. #SPNFamily

  • Karen - 3 years ago

    Supernatural

  • Charles - 3 years ago

    Supernatural started it's long journey beside Smallville so it's not surprising it's them at the end

  • Amelia Boos - 3 years ago

    IT'S NO CONTEST, SMALLVILLE ALL THE WAY! SUPERNATURAL, STUPIDNATURAL!!

  • Stefanie J Shalhoub - 3 years ago

    Supernatural is the only show that should be even considered for this contest.

  • Stefanie J Shalhoub - 3 years ago

    Supernatural is the only show that should be even considered for this contest.

  • Gaynor - 3 years ago

    No contest really. SUPERNATURAL wins hands down.

  • Trish - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way. Love Castiel!

  • Donna - 3 years ago

    Supernatural! Smallville started off good and steadily declined over the years. Supernatural held on to quality, and innovative shows to the end! Scoobynatural, The French Mistake, Changing Channels, Mystery Spot, Baby! How many classic episodes! Everybody sing, "A single man tear..."

  • Beth Baskett - 3 years ago

    Supernatural FOREVER!

  • Nathan Rosen - 3 years ago

    You cant simply go by number of seasons. Supernatural was dragged out over time by incredibly terrible stories due to simply ratings at the time. Smallville on the otherhand had incredible story development and died out because the actors were simply ready for something different. Although you cant blame them, they easily couldve gone for more seasons. Hell they even continued 2 more seasons in comic form! SMALLVILLE FTW anyday!

  • MeIAm - 3 years ago

    Snellville lasted 10 Seasons. Supernatural lasted 15. Seems to me we have a Clear winner by 5 Years.Unless you are some of those mathematically challenged people that still claim trump won?

  • sean sabon - 3 years ago

    Supernatural, of course

  • Aidan - 3 years ago

    This would have been an easier choice if The VD had beaten Smallville. So tough to call. I loved Supernatural and all 15 years of it but I have to go with all things DC even if it was formulaic: weekly kidnap +unconscious victim + clark to the rescue =everything goes back to normal for the next episode. Smallville for the win.

  • Goodday Biriala - 3 years ago

    Smallville for the win

  • Crystal - 3 years ago

    Supernatural hands down!!!!

    Jensen Ackles was in both!!

  • Dave - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way.

  • Amy - 3 years ago

    Supernatural. Always. For 15 years of my life- from high school, through college and then a family of my own, those boys were a part of it.

  • Anthony - 3 years ago

    These are the 2 best shows.

  • Crystal - 3 years ago

    While I watched Smallville I couldn't stick with it for the entire series. Supernatural, on the other hand, has had my heart since the day the first episode aired before all the millennials decided it was theirs ;) It's Supernatural all the way for me!!

  • Sharon Rankin - 3 years ago

    I have been watching Supernatural since it started in 2005. My family loves it. We still watch the reruns.

  • Ketki Raikwad - 3 years ago

    Forever SPN ❤

  • Steven Frederick Baljkas - 3 years ago

    I love Tom Welling and Smallville butt up against My Boys, The Brothers Winchester??!! NO CONTEST!

    SUPERNATURAL ALL THE WAY, EVERY DAY!

    I miss the great cast and wonderful writing and crazy adventures so much. Thank goodness for DVDs, reruns, and online streaming!

  • Jocelyn - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL - BABY!!! ⚡️❤️????⚡️❤️????
    No IFS ANDS OR BUTS .....
    WELL MAYBE A FEW BUTTS!!!

    ????????????????????????????????????????????????????‍♂️????‍♂️????‍♂️????????????

  • Kayla - 3 years ago

    After the countless lives that have changed after watching the show and the actors, if Supernatural doesn't win, I'm quitting the CW lol. The actors and creators of Supernatural deserve to know how much they've had made an impact on the world.

  • Tanya - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way!!! Jensen and Jared had such perfect chemistry on the show. I have watched every episode and have now started again from the beginning, there is no other show that I have wanted to do that with.

    #SPNfamily

  • John - 3 years ago

    Idgits!!

  • Effie joyce Pullins - 3 years ago

    Smallville was good, but Supernatural is my favorite it could had stayed on for 15 more years. I miss all of the cast and demons.

  • Woodsie - 3 years ago

    Also, to the people crying about the ending of the show? God got what was coming to him. And the boys got what they needed out of the series. Please tell us how you would have ended the show any better? It had to end some how, sadly, but they were also crunched on time due to covid...

  • Michael Beck - 3 years ago

    Its kinda funny smallville beat vampire diaries when the salvatore brothers were in smallville lol

  • Woodsie - 3 years ago

    Supernatural all the way. Smallville was just ok... let's put it this way. Jensen was in both shows. I love my comic book shows/movies/animated series. So, Tom and Jensen both have voiced batman. My favorite comic other than The Green Arrow. My sons name is Oliver for that exact reason. Buttt 15 seasons. 20+ episodes each. In the time supernatural had its run. 05' I was in 10th grade. Now I'm married and have a kid the same year spn ended. Smallville felt too "childish".

    Sorry but if spn loses this poll. You all should be ashamed of yourself.

  • Krystal Viola Smith - 3 years ago

    Smallville for the win. The best super hero show.
    Sorry Winchesters... its Clark Kent's destiny to defeat you.

  • Jared - 3 years ago

    100% supernatural!!! The chemistry of the winchester boys and supporting characters is unmatched. The incredible story lines and the humor are unheard of before this series. Which ended too soon in my opinion. Jensen & jared, we are all hoping for some kind of reunion!!

  • G - 3 years ago

    I am Batman!

  • Jessica - 3 years ago

    "Supernatural" and our Winchester Boys 'til the end of time! People like to complain about the "botched" ending, but I guess they're forgetting that Covid happened last year, sooo...yea!! Get outta the way, Clark Kent! ????????????????

  • Kyle Morgan - 3 years ago

    Supernatural was just too blasphemous for me.

  • Michael - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL!!! Smallville better NOT win this!!

  • Vanessa Lara - 3 years ago

    Supernatural had me from "Dad's on a hunting trip....."
    Smallville I had to force myself to finish, honestly I don't know if I ever did.

  • Sana Allan - 3 years ago

    Of course it is SUPERNATURAL. Why even bother with a tournament, you could've just asked people and you would've had your answer right away.

  • Athena - 3 years ago

    Dont know why it put the "????" marks...it was a statement lmao

  • Athena - 3 years ago

    Jensen was on Smallville ????

  • Sara - 3 years ago

    Love Smallville always and forever cause I'm Clark Kent all the way but supernatural the Winchester bros Jensen Ackles Jared padalecki and Misha Collins yeah got to vote them #SPNFAMILY

  • GodsonKen - 3 years ago

    I really really want to vote for Supernatural, as it is one of my favorites. I just hate how they ended it, especially the last season. I think Smallville had a much more polished and finished ending. If Supernatural had ended at season 5, then it would have been number 1 for me. Strong number 2 tho.

  • Lauren - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL FOR THE WIN

    BRING BACK SUPERNATURAL

    JARED JENSEN MISHA PLEASE COME BACK. WE LOVE N MISS YOU ALL SO MUCH

  • Charlie - 3 years ago

    While Sam, Dean, and Superman all appeared with Scooby and the gang, the Brother Winchester don't need capes. They have an Impala that helped mic drop the Devil himself. Supernatural's most legendary episodes were always when they took time to appreciate the fans and make fun of themselves a bit. With a tip of the cap to Smallville, folks, this isn't even close. Supernatural wins this, hands down.

  • Prabhjot Kaur - 3 years ago

    Winchester boys for life????❤️❤️❤️

  • Emilie - 3 years ago

    SUPERNATURAL FOREVER AND ALWAYS❤️

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.