SUPERNATURAL ALL THE WAY!!!!! I love ‘em both, but the boys have my heart! (Doesn’t hurt that I met them and was sandwiched between them for a pic????)
Amy - 3 years ago
What can I say. Supernatural is unique and original and it touched my heart.
Truthspeeker - 3 years ago
Smallville layer the foundation for Gotham, Arrow, Flash, Supergirl, Legends of Tomorrow, Black Lightning, Lucifer, Stargirl, Superman and Lois, Batwoman, Constantine, Titans, Doom Patrol, Watchmen, the Dark Knight Trilogy, and was a major influence for the MCU. This is literally BILLIONS of dollars in revenue. To not vote for it would be a joke.
Charolette - 3 years ago
I was watching Smallville when I saw the first preview of Supernatural. Being a fan of both Jensen and Jared I was hooked immediately.
Reading about the antics of Tom, Michael, Jensen and Jared were hilarious. I was sad to see Smallville end and watch the series once a year.
My heart is with the SPNFamily for life.
I'm hoping Michael talks about this on his podcast.
James Mayers Jr. - 3 years ago
Supernatural for my previous comments. Smallville is Small next to it????
Jodie A - 3 years ago
Supernatural all the way!!! #SPNfamily #AKF
James Mayers Jr. - 3 years ago
Best show ever! True to all the lores ever real or imagined. Innovative,Sensitive,Preachy,all the elements needed for the Ultimate Series Ever. Where Da Movie ? ????????????????????
Brittney - 3 years ago
I love both of these shows and watched both to the end however I'm giving sam & dean my vote only because their show had more seasons, plus its two hot guys vs one hot guy lol. Again I love both these shows, both are winners in my eyes and glad both made it to the final round.
Brad - 3 years ago
Always hold on to Smallville
Castiel Appleton - 3 years ago
Supernatural WAS my favorite show but they killed off Castiel in the final season and we never saw him again.. if he had just made one more appearance on that bridge with Sam and Dean by saying 'Hello Dean' and that way Sam and Dean and Cas would have been together, that would have been such perfection!!
And that way Castiel and Dean could have hugged and that would have been the final scene but then Dean could have said 'well then we got work to do!!' after the hug.
And why didn't Jack resurrect Castiel during that last vampire fight Dean and Sam had?? That way Dean probably wouldn't have died!!
But Dean did die and Sam moved on to get married and have a son named Dean, so why didn't Castiel ever visit them the whole time Sam Moved on??
So many things should have been different in the Supernatural series finale and the whole entire last season!
I mean why bring back the s....to play Ruby, the only reason why she was invited to come back is because she Jared's wife, everybody freaking hates her and the only reason why she got a role on Walker is because she's Jared's wife, she's a nobody and nobody else was offered the role on Walker they just handed it to her because she thinks she's the greatest thing that walks the planet!!
She sure did not age well!
Even on the set of Walker the cast and crew can't stand her and it's been noted that Jared won't stand up and take the lead on Walker because his wife's on set and his on screen partner who's a female does more of what he's supposed to be doing she takes the lead role on screen and everybody wants to get rid of the wife!!
Even the critics who watch Walker say the show is slow and boring and too many characters on the show and the problem is Jared, because his wife being there, it's been noted he seems to have a problem because his wife calls the shots and he wants to do what she says the show needs to be canceled it's a waste of Jared's Talent anyway!!
He did better on Supernatural because he had Jensen and his wife wasn't there!!
I do like Dannneel!! They should have had her on Walker instead of Genevieve!!
They need to hire Jensen and Misha and Alexander to be on Walker and get rid of everybody else that way Jared and Jensen and Misha and Alexander are together again. : ) Lol
The final season of Smallville really sucked too!!
I voted for Smallville because I didn't like what they did to Castiel!! : (
Sasha - 3 years ago
Supernatural ran for 15 seasons; it's the longest running genre show in the US. But when I think of the SPNFamily, AKF, Random Acts, GISH, & Stands, it's so much more than a tv show. ❤
unnom - 3 years ago
Sh@t, I think I just voted for Smallville when I wanted to vote for Supernatural! the titles were on the opposite position respect the one in the TVLINE article. Guys are you tricking us?
Natacha Nunes - 3 years ago
Supernatural all the way! AKF SPN Family!
Marion - 3 years ago
Supernatural is the Greatest Show ever.
Ayda - 3 years ago
there is no TV show past or present that i would choose over supernatural .
#SPN family
Teresa - 3 years ago
Supernatural was lightening in a bottle. The cast, the story, the fan base...it became more than just a show. It was and is a family. Supernatural fan for life!!
Rhyno - 3 years ago
"SOMEBODY SAVE ME" ------All day every day SMALLVILLE!!!
Shreya Saha - 3 years ago
Has to be Supernatural. Nothing beats that show!
#SPNFamily
Crystal - 3 years ago
The Winchesters have my heart forever! ❤
Khan - 3 years ago
Damn. After it's been 10 years since Smallville ended it still took down some of the CWs heaviest hitters like supergirl and tvd. This was the hardest choice I made. But supernatural is too good and I had to pick it.
Tyler - 3 years ago
Smallville, no question. Still the greatest TV show I've ever watched regardless of what it is up against. Never felt as connected to TV characters as I did watching that. I've also never experienced the same feeling of loss when it ended, knowing that was it. Countless memories watching this show with the same group of friends for years, we were a family alongside Clark and the gang. Nothing will ever take that away.
Kerry - 3 years ago
ALWAYS HOLD ON TO SMALLVILLE
In the middle of rewatching actually and i would always pick Smallville over any other show... Dont get me wrong Supernatural was a great great show and after Smallville ended i clinged to that show but it just kinda was the same season after season so kinda got boring to me... Love Jared and Jensen and am excited Jensen will be on The Boys for season 3...
Smallville for the win...
And for you folks that say you've never watched Smallville yall are missing out and im in shock...
Good luck to both shows
I LOVE Smallville, but Supernatural just has a certain something that makes every other show seem less than. It's difficult, but my vote goes to Supernatural. Maybe it also has something to do with them being my fellow Texans. ????
Bryan Davis - 3 years ago
Supernatural was great, but can't forget that Smallville started it all with the superhero TV shows, for that reason it will forever be iconic.
Holly - 3 years ago
SPN 100%
Marie Moriarty - 3 years ago
Supernatural
Ursula - 3 years ago
Loved them both; but SUPERNATURAL is my all time favorite!!! In the process of rewatching it right now ;-)
khulaid jamal - 3 years ago
I'll always hold on to smallville
Yashodara - 3 years ago
#supernatural
Jessica Valure - 3 years ago
Supernatural hands down, it will always be the best show on television any show that gives us Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki together is just amazing.
Matt - 3 years ago
This is hard a choice, it should be easy just to vote for Supernatural but that ending kinda ruined it.
Smallville is good start to finish untainted by the crap we see in shows today
Which to choose....
Cassie (Cas) - 3 years ago
spn is my ALL time go to fav show!! even over Arrow, and that says a lot! come #spnfamily, show our boys some love!! supernatural always
Stephen ray maples - 3 years ago
Smallville is the best show on CW No Doubt Tom Welling Michael Rosenbaum put on to the best performances of their careers go Smallville
K Poage - 3 years ago
These were my top 2 picks from the beginning. Very close but have to go with Supernatural.
Rhiannon - 3 years ago
Okay
#SPNFAMILY for the win
Faith - 3 years ago
if you don’t vote for Supernatural then you’re just crazy!
There will never be another show like Supernatural! Not only has it given me entertainment and joy but friends who are like family! It gave me Dean Winchester and Jensen Ackles!
Rosana - 3 years ago
Supernatural! Sem comparação pra mim é o melhor ????
Jennifer Browning - 3 years ago
NOTHING beats Supernatural! I could have watched 50 more seasons of that show.
Mike Olson - 3 years ago
Supernatural is not only the best show ever on the CW, it is also the best show I have EVER seen on television hands down.
Anything Jensen touches is gold! Both shows are amazing but NOTHING compares to Supernatural!
Michele A Campbell - 3 years ago
Never seen Smallville. Seen every supernatural love it
Holly Middleton - 3 years ago
Smallville was fun but Supernatural made me feel a lot more - sadness, excitement, humor…. So good. Never been so attached to fictional characters before!
Mindy - 3 years ago
#SPNFamily always
Bob - 3 years ago
Supernatural all day, everyday.
Lia - 3 years ago
#SPNfamily
Nate - 3 years ago
Gotta admit it's a close call, Smallville had it's good moments: but Supernatural was fun for the full 15 seasons. Smallville kinda stopped halfway for me, so Supernatural it is!
Christine - 3 years ago
I loved Smallville, but Supernatural is my all-time favorite show! It should win just based on its enormous and loyal fan base.
Lola - 3 years ago
#SPNfamily Supernatural will always have my vote
Aurora Revenclaw - 3 years ago
#Supernatural
Sue - 3 years ago
Supernatural gets my vote #SPNfamily.
glenn branker - 3 years ago
Smallville all day! Supernatural went on far too long.
Tarina Peters - 3 years ago
The absolute best show ever!
Ashley - 3 years ago
This was absolutely the most difficult choice for me. If I could vote for both, I would
Christina - 3 years ago
Def Supernatural! It was entertaining all the way to the end. I tried watching Smallville but could not get into it at all. Love Supernatural all the way!
Conny - 3 years ago
Supernatural all the way #SPNFamily ????
Joyce Elliott - 3 years ago
Smallville all the way!!!
Ryan - 3 years ago
Weird that both shows started on The WB and are in the final for best CW show. Ha. But gotta be Smallville. Supernatural ran way past the time it should have called it quits.
Always hold on to Smallville!
SUPERNATURAL ALL THE WAY!!!!! I love ‘em both, but the boys have my heart! (Doesn’t hurt that I met them and was sandwiched between them for a pic????)
What can I say. Supernatural is unique and original and it touched my heart.
Smallville layer the foundation for Gotham, Arrow, Flash, Supergirl, Legends of Tomorrow, Black Lightning, Lucifer, Stargirl, Superman and Lois, Batwoman, Constantine, Titans, Doom Patrol, Watchmen, the Dark Knight Trilogy, and was a major influence for the MCU. This is literally BILLIONS of dollars in revenue. To not vote for it would be a joke.
I was watching Smallville when I saw the first preview of Supernatural. Being a fan of both Jensen and Jared I was hooked immediately.
Reading about the antics of Tom, Michael, Jensen and Jared were hilarious. I was sad to see Smallville end and watch the series once a year.
My heart is with the SPNFamily for life.
I'm hoping Michael talks about this on his podcast.
Supernatural for my previous comments. Smallville is Small next to it????
Supernatural all the way!!! #SPNfamily #AKF
Best show ever! True to all the lores ever real or imagined. Innovative,Sensitive,Preachy,all the elements needed for the Ultimate Series Ever. Where Da Movie ? ????????????????????
I love both of these shows and watched both to the end however I'm giving sam & dean my vote only because their show had more seasons, plus its two hot guys vs one hot guy lol. Again I love both these shows, both are winners in my eyes and glad both made it to the final round.
Always hold on to Smallville
Supernatural WAS my favorite show but they killed off Castiel in the final season and we never saw him again.. if he had just made one more appearance on that bridge with Sam and Dean by saying 'Hello Dean' and that way Sam and Dean and Cas would have been together, that would have been such perfection!!
And that way Castiel and Dean could have hugged and that would have been the final scene but then Dean could have said 'well then we got work to do!!' after the hug.
And why didn't Jack resurrect Castiel during that last vampire fight Dean and Sam had?? That way Dean probably wouldn't have died!!
But Dean did die and Sam moved on to get married and have a son named Dean, so why didn't Castiel ever visit them the whole time Sam Moved on??
So many things should have been different in the Supernatural series finale and the whole entire last season!
I mean why bring back the s....to play Ruby, the only reason why she was invited to come back is because she Jared's wife, everybody freaking hates her and the only reason why she got a role on Walker is because she's Jared's wife, she's a nobody and nobody else was offered the role on Walker they just handed it to her because she thinks she's the greatest thing that walks the planet!!
She sure did not age well!
Even on the set of Walker the cast and crew can't stand her and it's been noted that Jared won't stand up and take the lead on Walker because his wife's on set and his on screen partner who's a female does more of what he's supposed to be doing she takes the lead role on screen and everybody wants to get rid of the wife!!
Even the critics who watch Walker say the show is slow and boring and too many characters on the show and the problem is Jared, because his wife being there, it's been noted he seems to have a problem because his wife calls the shots and he wants to do what she says the show needs to be canceled it's a waste of Jared's Talent anyway!!
He did better on Supernatural because he had Jensen and his wife wasn't there!!
I do like Dannneel!! They should have had her on Walker instead of Genevieve!!
They need to hire Jensen and Misha and Alexander to be on Walker and get rid of everybody else that way Jared and Jensen and Misha and Alexander are together again. : ) Lol
The final season of Smallville really sucked too!!
I voted for Smallville because I didn't like what they did to Castiel!! : (
Supernatural ran for 15 seasons; it's the longest running genre show in the US. But when I think of the SPNFamily, AKF, Random Acts, GISH, & Stands, it's so much more than a tv show. ❤
Sh@t, I think I just voted for Smallville when I wanted to vote for Supernatural! the titles were on the opposite position respect the one in the TVLINE article. Guys are you tricking us?
Supernatural all the way! AKF SPN Family!
Supernatural is the Greatest Show ever.
there is no TV show past or present that i would choose over supernatural .
#SPN family
Supernatural was lightening in a bottle. The cast, the story, the fan base...it became more than just a show. It was and is a family. Supernatural fan for life!!
"SOMEBODY SAVE ME" ------All day every day SMALLVILLE!!!
Has to be Supernatural. Nothing beats that show!
#SPNFamily
The Winchesters have my heart forever! ❤
Damn. After it's been 10 years since Smallville ended it still took down some of the CWs heaviest hitters like supergirl and tvd. This was the hardest choice I made. But supernatural is too good and I had to pick it.
Smallville, no question. Still the greatest TV show I've ever watched regardless of what it is up against. Never felt as connected to TV characters as I did watching that. I've also never experienced the same feeling of loss when it ended, knowing that was it. Countless memories watching this show with the same group of friends for years, we were a family alongside Clark and the gang. Nothing will ever take that away.
ALWAYS HOLD ON TO SMALLVILLE
In the middle of rewatching actually and i would always pick Smallville over any other show... Dont get me wrong Supernatural was a great great show and after Smallville ended i clinged to that show but it just kinda was the same season after season so kinda got boring to me... Love Jared and Jensen and am excited Jensen will be on The Boys for season 3...
Smallville for the win...
And for you folks that say you've never watched Smallville yall are missing out and im in shock...
Good luck to both shows
All the other choices were easy... until now! My two favorites. Sigh.
Supernatural without a doubt. However, why does the chart show Arrow beating Supernatural?
Supernatural without a doubt. However, why does the chart show Arrow beating Supernatural?
SPN is the best. I wish it never ended.
Supernatural forever ❤️ #AlwaysKeepFighting #SPNFamily
15 seasons of Sam & Dean Winchester plus BABY !!! No contest Supernatural is the winner !!!
Supernatural
There is NO tv show past or present that will top Supernatural EVER!
I LOVE Smallville, but Supernatural just has a certain something that makes every other show seem less than. It's difficult, but my vote goes to Supernatural. Maybe it also has something to do with them being my fellow Texans. ????
Supernatural was great, but can't forget that Smallville started it all with the superhero TV shows, for that reason it will forever be iconic.
SPN 100%
Supernatural
Loved them both; but SUPERNATURAL is my all time favorite!!! In the process of rewatching it right now ;-)
I'll always hold on to smallville
#supernatural
Supernatural hands down, it will always be the best show on television any show that gives us Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki together is just amazing.
This is hard a choice, it should be easy just to vote for Supernatural but that ending kinda ruined it.
Smallville is good start to finish untainted by the crap we see in shows today
Which to choose....
spn is my ALL time go to fav show!! even over Arrow, and that says a lot! come #spnfamily, show our boys some love!! supernatural always
Smallville is the best show on CW No Doubt Tom Welling Michael Rosenbaum put on to the best performances of their careers go Smallville
These were my top 2 picks from the beginning. Very close but have to go with Supernatural.
Okay
#SPNFAMILY for the win
if you don’t vote for Supernatural then you’re just crazy!
There will never be another show like Supernatural! Not only has it given me entertainment and joy but friends who are like family! It gave me Dean Winchester and Jensen Ackles!
Supernatural! Sem comparação pra mim é o melhor ????
NOTHING beats Supernatural! I could have watched 50 more seasons of that show.
Supernatural is not only the best show ever on the CW, it is also the best show I have EVER seen on television hands down.
Supernatural has my vote. However did enjoy a lot Smallville. But chosen between them is Supernatural.
Anything Jensen touches is gold! Both shows are amazing but NOTHING compares to Supernatural!
Never seen Smallville. Seen every supernatural love it
Smallville was fun but Supernatural made me feel a lot more - sadness, excitement, humor…. So good. Never been so attached to fictional characters before!
#SPNFamily always
Supernatural all day, everyday.
#SPNfamily
Gotta admit it's a close call, Smallville had it's good moments: but Supernatural was fun for the full 15 seasons. Smallville kinda stopped halfway for me, so Supernatural it is!
I loved Smallville, but Supernatural is my all-time favorite show! It should win just based on its enormous and loyal fan base.
#SPNfamily Supernatural will always have my vote
#Supernatural
Supernatural gets my vote #SPNfamily.
Smallville all day! Supernatural went on far too long.
The absolute best show ever!
This was absolutely the most difficult choice for me. If I could vote for both, I would
Def Supernatural! It was entertaining all the way to the end. I tried watching Smallville but could not get into it at all. Love Supernatural all the way!
Supernatural all the way #SPNFamily ????
Smallville all the way!!!
Weird that both shows started on The WB and are in the final for best CW show. Ha. But gotta be Smallville. Supernatural ran way past the time it should have called it quits.
“Always hold onto Smallville”