Best of Staten Island: Vote for your favorite pizza place (Poll Closed)
Rustic Pizza & Pasteria, 97 Lincoln Ave.; rusticpizzapasteria.com; 212-425-2623
19%
Staten Island Slice, 1880 Hylan Blvd.; statenislandslice.com; 718-524-6522
18%
Lorenzo’s Pizza of New York, 1910 Hylan Blvd.; lorenzosnewyork.com; 718-979-4700
7%
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizza Cafe, 1298 Forest Ave.; ungarocoalfiredpizzacafe.com; 646-968-4777
6%
Mimmo’s Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria, 15 Giffords Ln.; mimmosbrickpizza.com; 718-967-6560
5%
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern, 524 Port Richmond Ave.; deninossi.com; 718-442-9401
4%
Nonna’s Pizzeria, 27 Broward Court; nonnaspizzaonline.com; 718-227-8108
3%
Lee’s Tavern, 60 Hancock St.; leestavernnyc.com; 718-667-9749
3%
Big Al’s, 4069 Hylan Blvd.; bigalspizza.space; 718-356-8446
3%
Prime Pizza Kitchen, 1778 Hylan Blvd.; primepizzakitchenstatenisland.com; 718-351-5000
3%
Il Forno Pizzeria, 6382 Amboy Rd.; ilfornopizzasi.com; 718-317-1251
2%
Bravo Pizza & Sports Bar, 413 New Dorp Ln., bravopizzasi.com; 718-317-1010
2%
Brothers Pizzeria, 750 Port Richmond Ave.; 718-442-2332
2%
Joe and Pat’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, 1758 Victory Blvd.; joeandpatsny.com; 718-981-0887
2%
Ti Amo Pizza, 3555 Victory Blvd.; tiamopizzany.com; 718-477-0007
1%
Jimmy Max, 280 Watchogue Rd.; jimmymax.com; 718-983-6715
1%
Round Pie Pizza Company, 1957 Victory Blvd.; roundpie.com; 718-524-0000
1%
Classic Pizza, 3201 Richmond Rd.; classicpizzany.com; 718-987-2500
1%
Mona Lisa Pizzeria, 839 Annadale Rd.; monalisapizzeriasi.com; 718-967-1000
1%
Pizzeria Giove, 278 New Dorp Ln.; 347-286-0635
1%
Valducci’s, 3010 Veterans Rd W.; valduccispizza.com; 212-470-2277
1%
Nunzio’s, 2155 Hylan Blvd.; nunziospizzeriarestaurant.com; 718-667-9647
1%
DOUGH by Licastri, 1456 Richmond Rd; doughbylicastri.com; 718-668-1600
1%
Stefano’s Pizza, 55 Gunton Place; stefanosofstatenisland.com; 718-966-8700
1%
Sal & Lloyd’s Pizza Place, 3850 Richmond Ave.; salandlloydspizzaplace.com; 718-356-5350
<1%
Domenico’s Pizza & Pasta, 5838 Amboy Rd.; domenicospizzeriamenu.com; 718-966-0114
<1%
DiLeo’s Pizzeria, 2491 Victory Blvd.; dileospizzasi.com; 718-761-8888
<1%
Ambrosino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, 3161 Amboy Rd.; ambrosinospizza.com; 718-987-8800
<1%
Ciro Pizza Cafe, 862 Huguenot Ave.; ciropizzacafes.com; 718-605-0620
<1%
Frank And Danny’s, 4369 Amboy Rd.; frankanddannys.com; 718-317-1100
<1%
Pronto Pizza Pasta, 1077 Bay St.; prontopizzany.com; 718-442-3535
<1%
Mr. Pizza, 2325 Richmond Ave.; mrpizzas-siny.com; 718-370-0102
<1%
Michelangelo’s Pizza, 860 Post Ave.; michelangelospizzasi.com; 718-273-7541
<1%
Seppe Pizza Bar, 3 Navy Pier Ct.; seppepizzabar.com; 718-727-3773
<1%
Amici Brick Oven Pizza, 6309 Amboy Rd.; amicipizzamenu.com; 718-356-6060
<1%
Bella Mama Rose, 266 Morningstar Rd.; bellamamarose.com; 718-981-0545
<1%
Villa Monte Pizzeria, 7001 Amboy Rd.; villamontepizza.com; 718-984-9886
<1%
Campania Coal Fired Pizza, 3900 Richmond Ave.; campaniacoalfiredpizza.com; 718-227-3286
<1%
Crispy Pizza, 782 Richmond Terrace; crispypizzany.com; 718-420-6050
<1%
Domenico’s Pizzeria and Ristorante Antico, 3295 Amboy Rd.; domenicospizzeria.com; 718-351-2100
<1%
Tony’s Brick Oven, 1140 Bay St.; tonysbrickoven.com; 718-816-6516
<1%
Villa Monte Pizza, 240 Arden Ave.; villamontepizza.com; 718-984-7100
<1%
Rossville Pizza, 960 Bloomingdale Rd.; rossvillepizza.com; 718-227-4444
<1%
Pizza Parlor, 6 Sneden Ave.; pizzaparlornyc.com; 718-356-4233
<1%
Towne Deli & Pizzeria, 5373 Arthur Kill Rd.; townedelipizzasi.com; 718-227-1985
<1%
Village Maria Pizza, 768 Manor Rd.; villagemariastatenisland.com; 718-370-1818
<1%
Cafe Milano, 401 Forest Ave.; cafemilanosi.com; 718-720-1313
<1%
Il Sapore Cafe, 10 Akron St.; ilsaporesi.com; 718-690-3149
<1%
Gino’s Villa Monte Pizzeria, 2811 Richmond Ave.; villamontepizza.com; 718-494-6554
<1%
Original Giuseppes Pizza, 4300 Amboy Rd.; giuseppespizzasi.com; 718-227-8332
<1%
Palermo Pizza, 95 Page Ave.; palermopizzeriasi.com; 917-970-1341
<1%
Reggiano’s Brick Oven Pizza, 7339 Amboy Rd.; reggianosbrickovenpizzeria.com; 718-966-6610
<1%
Village Maria Pizzeria, 3995 Amboy Rd.; villagemaria.com; 718-984-9449
<1%
Goodfella’s, 1718 Hylan Blvd.; goodfellas.com; 718-987-2422
<1%
Pier 76, 76 Bay St.; pier76si.com; 718-447-7437
<1%
A&S Pizza, 87 Stuyvesant Place; aandspizza.com; 718-448-4142
<1%
Gino’s, 1351 Forest Ave.; ginospizzasi.com; 718-273-0945
<1%
Justino’s Pizza, 89 Guyon Ave.; justinospizzastatenisland.com; 718-668-2020
<1%
Vincent’s Deli & Pizzeria, 500 Henderson Ave.; vincentsdelipizzeria.com; 718-720-7335
<1%
Randall Manor Tavern, 735 Castleton Ave.; randallmanortavern.net; 347-855-2724
<1%
Bario’s, 446 Nome Ave.; bariosonline.com; 718-370-0100
<1%
Campania Coal Fired Pizza, 240 Page Ave.; campaniacoalfiredpizza.com; 347-983-4998
<1%
Euro Pizza, 3271 Richmond Ave.; ordereuropizzamenu.com; 718-966-7518
<1%
Bari’s Pizza, 596 Bay Street; https://barispizzany.com/; 718-876-0002
<1%
Cafe Luna, 1300 Hylan Blvd.; cafelunanyc.com; 718-351-3235
<1%
Lorenzo’s, 1100 South Ave; lorenzosdining.com; 718-477-2400 ext. 4
<1%
Mangia, 7517 Amboy Rd.; ordermangiamenu.com; 718-356-9300
<1%
Saporito Pizza, 896 Huguenot Ave.; saporitopizzany.com; 718-227-6300
<1%
Nucci’s, 4842 Arthur Kill Rd.; nuccissiny.com; 718-967-3600
<1%
Pronto Pizza Pasta, 337 New Dorp Ln.; prontopizzany.com; 718-351-2700
<1%
Avanti’s Pizzeria, 1650 Richmond Ave; avantispizza.com; 718-568-3000
<1%
Millie’s of Staten Island, 185 Bricktown Way; milliesoldworld.com; 929-284-4004
<1%
Crust Pizzeria, 2071 Clove Rd.; crustpizzasi.com; 347-861-0999
<1%
Gigi’s Cafe & Keke’s Pizzeria, 7423 Amboy Rd.; 718-554-4134
<1%
Rosebank Pizza, 1372 Bay St.; rosebankpizza.com; 718-447-5300
<1%
Torino Pizza Cafe, 1694 Richmond Rd.; torinopizzamenu.com; 718-351-3100
<1%
Pizza Parlor, 965 Jewett Ave.; pizzaparlornyc.com; 718-448-7700
<1%
Goodfella’s, 1817 Victory Blvd.; goodfellasusa.com; 718-815-8500
<1%
La Bella Pizza, 1499 Forest Ave.; labellasi.com; 718-981-5508
<1%
La Piazza Pizzeria, 1445 Richmond Ave.; lapiazzasi.com; 718-370-0707
<1%
Primo Pizza, 1282 Richmond Rd.; primopizzasi.com; 718-667-8882
<1%
Paesano’s Pizzeria, 12 Bradley Ave.; orderpaesanospizzeria.com; 718-761-2070
<1%
Plaza Pizza, 50 New Dorp Plaza; plazapizzasi.com; 718-667-7170
<1%
Pizza D’Oro, 3115 Victory Blvd.; pizzadoro.weebly.com; 718-698-8873
<1%
Via Napoli Pizzeria, 2626 Hylan Blvd.; vianapoliny.com; 718-667-8599
<1%
Mama Rosaria Pizzeria and Ristorante, 2146 Forest Ave.; mamarosariaspizza.com; 718-682-7793
<1%
Casa Nino’s, 1757 Arthur Kill Rd., casaninospizzahouse.com; 718-948-0440
<1%
Pronto Pizza Pasta, 738 Forest Ave.; prontopizzany.com; 718-448-1166
<1%
Pronto Pizza Pasta, 2935 Veterans Rd W.; prontopizzany.com; 718-356-2500
<1%
My Pizza and Restaurant, 755 Targee St.; mypizzany.com; 718-720-7777
<1%
Panini Grill, 538 Forest Ave.; paninigrillsi.com; 718-981-2999
<1%
Pronto Pizza Pasta, 3297 Richmond Ave.; prontopizzany.com; 718-356-2442
<1%
Gold Grill Pizzeria, 819 Forest Ave.; 718-569-7277
<1%
Kingdom Pizza Cafe, 4350 Amboy Rd.; kingdomcafesi.com; 929-467-7425
<1%
Cafe Luna, 31 Page Ave.; cafelunanyc.com; 718-227-8582
<1%
Nino’s Restaurant, 1110 Hylan Blvd.; ninosrestaurant.com; 718-448-3838
<1%
Avanti’s Pizza, 170 New Dorp Lane; avantispizza.com; 718-668-0490
<1%
J & R Pizza II, 133 McClean Ave.; jrpizza2.com; 718-727-2222
<1%
Casanova Restaurant, 3555 Victory Blvd.; ordercasanova.com; 718-682-1331
<1%
Oaxaca Pizzeria Deli & Taqueria, 1240 Castleton Ave.; 718-556-9416
<1%
closed
