Beth has to go. There are so many unlikable characters on the show. There's a handful of good side characters...Teeter is hilarious and Travis makes horse showing look incredible. Jimmy is my feel-good character and Rip...I just like him. Kaycee is okay. All the other main characters are either whiney or so weak or disgusting that they're intolerable.
Beth, is without a doubt the most evil and despicable thing I have ever seen on TV and In hope she dies brutally...and soon. That she had so much hated for Jamie and takes no responsibility for her part in the primary issue with her and Jamie, is, weak. I know everyone wants to jump up and down supporting her and acting like she's strong but the truth is that she's weak and sad... and that's why she has so much hate for everyone else, because she can't take responsibility for her own actions. If she left the show, it would be so much better.
Stacy - 2 years ago
We are extremely disappointed in Beth’s character in season 4. Pulling a knife on the woman her Father brought home -the vile language and hatred for just about everyone and everything is exhausting and unrealistic. My husband and I rolled our eyes at that scene and our opinion of Beth changed from favorable to can’t stand her. Then she fires the poor dude working there? It was ridiculous and unbelievable. Then there’s the scene where she makes the young boy cry when Beth tells him not to call her Mom. She is cruel and hateful. I got teary eyed when she told him that. Very bad judgement call on the writers. And, Rip continues to love and adore her?? Why?? What is there to love?? John has no backbone when he so easily let her continued living at the ranch. And that’s weird too - why does John need his grown daughter to live in his house? That’s not normal or healthy. I feel badly for the boy.
I don’t know why viewers don’t like Walker. He has tried repeatedly to change his life around and mind his own business. There’s a very good reason he had to stay in MT if anyone cares to think about that. He’s probably one of the most tender characters on the show. Please don’t get rid of Walker. I love his songs, many of which speak volumes. Give him a break!
Excellent writing with Jimmies character development. I adore him. He’s come a long way and matured into a decent, honest, hard working, talented man in the process. I hate to see him leave the show.
Rip could do better than Beth. Beth had no moral compass, other than Daddy. She’s so mean and hateful, it’s hard to embrace her character anymore. She’s a nuisance.
Kevin Costner is an icon. I will never say anything negative about him. One of my favorite actors.
An excellent show, thank you! Too much to say about all the characters… I could keep going on & on…
Oh, don’t care for Monica. She coddles the poor kid, too whinny, too skinny, and just dull. Once she told Caycee that she HATED him - I was done with her. Words you can never take back.
Rip is so loyal to John, understandably so. And, what woman wouldn’t want a man that has her back no matter what? He’s a handsome badass, AND MUST stay on the show. I’d take Rip with a whip any day!
Just don’t care for the numerous character flaws of BETH. She’s a spoiled bitch, overindulged think-she’s-all- that nutcase!
????
Noemi Santos Borges - 2 years ago
Beth is a amazing strong woman a love the confidence how she handles the family business... i love her anyway
Helen C Bennett - 2 years ago
I just rewatched all four seasons and all these comments about Garrett are interesting. Seems to me John Dutton has killed more people than Garrett. All for the love of his ranch. He certainly doesn't show much love for Jamie or Kaycee. He never smiles and is a very depressing character. Jimmie has got to go. Monica doesn't deserve Kaycee who also kills a lot of people. Actually other than Kaycee, Rip, the music and the beautiful scenery there is not much positive to say about the storyline anymore.
Kris - 2 years ago
Jaycee will stay b/c as he gets more in tune with the Indian ways it’ll create more conflict when the Duttons have to go head to head with the tribe. His wife only helps create a tie to their ways, other than that she’s not essential. Right now the Duttons n tribe are unified against the huge company wanting the airport & development. But soon they’ll go at eachother…
Chris - 2 years ago
I feel it will be Walker...Rip has -0- tolerance for him & has wanted him gone for a long time, now he's been caught with his lady. Rip has numerous reasons to take Walker to the 'train station'. Can't wait to watch the finale...
Carolyn - 2 years ago
Please get rid of Monica...she does nothing but whine and what woman in her right mind would continue to help her healthy 11 year old son take a bath and want to help dry him off??
Christina is a manipulative bitch and needs to go. Garrett Randall is a snake who wants to get his grubby hands on the Yellowstone Ranch via spineless Jamie.
Kayce needs to grow a set of balls and let Monica go if that's what she wants.
Fred - 2 years ago
The series needs to get rid of Garrett.. the untouchables rip john kaycee Beth. If they lose anyone of these characters the show would take a serious hit . Walker is expendable . Jimmy is putting some good in show and his story could be made a but more interesting he should stay .
I think it's Walker because of Beth going to him and not RiP. RiP has wanted him dead for awhile he will be on 6666 ranch show .
Karen - 2 years ago
And Jamie will work with the Duttons to get rid of Garrett. John and Beth (Beth now happy with a child of her own) will welcome Jamie back into the family and John will endorse Jamie for Governor.
Karen - 2 years ago
I think it’s going to be Christina. It would be the perfect setup for Jamie to give up their child to Beth as repentance for what he did to Beth.
I think Garrett will probably be the one to kill Christina which will lead to Jamie turning against his bio father and him to try and make amends with the Duttons.
John Claude - 2 years ago
It really doesn’t matter someone will be shot or injured and we’ll have to wait till season 5 to find out they survived !
CaraMaria - 2 years ago
I think Garrett needs to go, he is very sneaky. How did Jaime's ex girlfriend find him? He was surprised to see her at the ranch. His father is a snake in the grass. Jaime is a whimp has been through the whole picture. If he goes I won't miss him. Someone said Jimmy, I think he should stay he seems to have grown up and learned a lot
Peggy Anne Denham - 2 years ago
Please not Rip, Incredible Beth or Cayce.
frogbones - 2 years ago
There are a few characters that don't deserve to go cuz it would end the show. I vote for Garrett. I don't like him,.
Loving Yellowstone - 2 years ago
Garrett, walker, Jamie's baby momma or Monica need to go. I love John, Kayce Rip and Beth and love Rip and Beth as a couple don't change that ever!!! I love how confident Beth is she is how I wish I could be maybe not the language a lot of the time lol. But John, Rip, Beth and Kayce are why we watch the show if they are gone it isn't worth watching.
CM - 2 years ago
If Rip, John, or Beth are killed off, then Yellowstone is over as a series...just sayin'.
KATHRYNE REHFUSS - 2 years ago
Jimmy is a good character and watching him evolve has been fun. But, sure hope he doesn't end up with Mia ~ she's not good for him or anybody. Monica is a whiny frustration and frankly, I don't see how Kaycee has put up with her 'poor me' routine this long. If she's not around, Miss Pouty Lips could step in to soothe Kaycee and hopefully make a man of Tate (Monica sure isn't going to do that). Garrett is getting boring. But if he goes, who will think for Jamie? My vote is the baby momma or Garrett or, yes, Walker. Walker is exhausting.
Penny Andrews - 2 years ago
Please do not take rip,beth,kayce or John off the show, they are main characters who make the show great
Rachel - 2 years ago
I think if Rip, Kayce OR John are killed off the ratings will drop like a bowling ball from the sky. Killing of Jamie's baby momma would be interesting, leaving Jamie with a baby thus putting Beth in a position of 'how hateful could she be" . She has vowed to eventually kill anything he loves, even if it with her bare hands. Garrett or her...need to go.
Jennifer - 2 years ago
I love Jimmy and the direction he is going, John isn’t going anywhere, as far as I can tell the only options to go are Monica, garret, Jammie’s, his baby momma, or walker but we have been fooled before can’t wait!!!
Richard Creaghan - 2 years ago
To bad 1883 not on reg. Parmount channel only +
E A Curran - 2 years ago
I agree. No one would notice if they got rid of Jimmie. He’s pretty much destined to kill himself doing something on a horse.
Bill - 2 years ago
Please tell Sheridan that this season has become lame. Writing has gone totally downhill. Get rid of Carter, Tate, Monica, and most of all, Jimmy. Their storylines are just filler. Uninteresting filler. It used to be a must at 8pm, Sunday. Not anymore.
Beth has to go. There are so many unlikable characters on the show. There's a handful of good side characters...Teeter is hilarious and Travis makes horse showing look incredible. Jimmy is my feel-good character and Rip...I just like him. Kaycee is okay. All the other main characters are either whiney or so weak or disgusting that they're intolerable.
Beth, is without a doubt the most evil and despicable thing I have ever seen on TV and In hope she dies brutally...and soon. That she had so much hated for Jamie and takes no responsibility for her part in the primary issue with her and Jamie, is, weak. I know everyone wants to jump up and down supporting her and acting like she's strong but the truth is that she's weak and sad... and that's why she has so much hate for everyone else, because she can't take responsibility for her own actions. If she left the show, it would be so much better.
We are extremely disappointed in Beth’s character in season 4. Pulling a knife on the woman her Father brought home -the vile language and hatred for just about everyone and everything is exhausting and unrealistic. My husband and I rolled our eyes at that scene and our opinion of Beth changed from favorable to can’t stand her. Then she fires the poor dude working there? It was ridiculous and unbelievable. Then there’s the scene where she makes the young boy cry when Beth tells him not to call her Mom. She is cruel and hateful. I got teary eyed when she told him that. Very bad judgement call on the writers. And, Rip continues to love and adore her?? Why?? What is there to love?? John has no backbone when he so easily let her continued living at the ranch. And that’s weird too - why does John need his grown daughter to live in his house? That’s not normal or healthy. I feel badly for the boy.
I don’t know why viewers don’t like Walker. He has tried repeatedly to change his life around and mind his own business. There’s a very good reason he had to stay in MT if anyone cares to think about that. He’s probably one of the most tender characters on the show. Please don’t get rid of Walker. I love his songs, many of which speak volumes. Give him a break!
Excellent writing with Jimmies character development. I adore him. He’s come a long way and matured into a decent, honest, hard working, talented man in the process. I hate to see him leave the show.
Rip could do better than Beth. Beth had no moral compass, other than Daddy. She’s so mean and hateful, it’s hard to embrace her character anymore. She’s a nuisance.
Kevin Costner is an icon. I will never say anything negative about him. One of my favorite actors.
An excellent show, thank you! Too much to say about all the characters… I could keep going on & on…
Oh, don’t care for Monica. She coddles the poor kid, too whinny, too skinny, and just dull. Once she told Caycee that she HATED him - I was done with her. Words you can never take back.
Rip is so loyal to John, understandably so. And, what woman wouldn’t want a man that has her back no matter what? He’s a handsome badass, AND MUST stay on the show. I’d take Rip with a whip any day!
Just don’t care for the numerous character flaws of BETH. She’s a spoiled bitch, overindulged think-she’s-all- that nutcase!
????
Beth is a amazing strong woman a love the confidence how she handles the family business... i love her anyway
I just rewatched all four seasons and all these comments about Garrett are interesting. Seems to me John Dutton has killed more people than Garrett. All for the love of his ranch. He certainly doesn't show much love for Jamie or Kaycee. He never smiles and is a very depressing character. Jimmie has got to go. Monica doesn't deserve Kaycee who also kills a lot of people. Actually other than Kaycee, Rip, the music and the beautiful scenery there is not much positive to say about the storyline anymore.
Jaycee will stay b/c as he gets more in tune with the Indian ways it’ll create more conflict when the Duttons have to go head to head with the tribe. His wife only helps create a tie to their ways, other than that she’s not essential. Right now the Duttons n tribe are unified against the huge company wanting the airport & development. But soon they’ll go at eachother…
I feel it will be Walker...Rip has -0- tolerance for him & has wanted him gone for a long time, now he's been caught with his lady. Rip has numerous reasons to take Walker to the 'train station'. Can't wait to watch the finale...
Please get rid of Monica...she does nothing but whine and what woman in her right mind would continue to help her healthy 11 year old son take a bath and want to help dry him off??
Christina is a manipulative bitch and needs to go. Garrett Randall is a snake who wants to get his grubby hands on the Yellowstone Ranch via spineless Jamie.
Kayce needs to grow a set of balls and let Monica go if that's what she wants.
The series needs to get rid of Garrett.. the untouchables rip john kaycee Beth. If they lose anyone of these characters the show would take a serious hit . Walker is expendable . Jimmy is putting some good in show and his story could be made a but more interesting he should stay .
I think it's Walker because of Beth going to him and not RiP. RiP has wanted him dead for awhile he will be on 6666 ranch show .
And Jamie will work with the Duttons to get rid of Garrett. John and Beth (Beth now happy with a child of her own) will welcome Jamie back into the family and John will endorse Jamie for Governor.
I think it’s going to be Christina. It would be the perfect setup for Jamie to give up their child to Beth as repentance for what he did to Beth.
I think Garrett will probably be the one to kill Christina which will lead to Jamie turning against his bio father and him to try and make amends with the Duttons.
It really doesn’t matter someone will be shot or injured and we’ll have to wait till season 5 to find out they survived !
I think Garrett needs to go, he is very sneaky. How did Jaime's ex girlfriend find him? He was surprised to see her at the ranch. His father is a snake in the grass. Jaime is a whimp has been through the whole picture. If he goes I won't miss him. Someone said Jimmy, I think he should stay he seems to have grown up and learned a lot
Please not Rip, Incredible Beth or Cayce.
There are a few characters that don't deserve to go cuz it would end the show. I vote for Garrett. I don't like him,.
Garrett, walker, Jamie's baby momma or Monica need to go. I love John, Kayce Rip and Beth and love Rip and Beth as a couple don't change that ever!!! I love how confident Beth is she is how I wish I could be maybe not the language a lot of the time lol. But John, Rip, Beth and Kayce are why we watch the show if they are gone it isn't worth watching.
If Rip, John, or Beth are killed off, then Yellowstone is over as a series...just sayin'.
Jimmy is a good character and watching him evolve has been fun. But, sure hope he doesn't end up with Mia ~ she's not good for him or anybody. Monica is a whiny frustration and frankly, I don't see how Kaycee has put up with her 'poor me' routine this long. If she's not around, Miss Pouty Lips could step in to soothe Kaycee and hopefully make a man of Tate (Monica sure isn't going to do that). Garrett is getting boring. But if he goes, who will think for Jamie? My vote is the baby momma or Garrett or, yes, Walker. Walker is exhausting.
Please do not take rip,beth,kayce or John off the show, they are main characters who make the show great
I think if Rip, Kayce OR John are killed off the ratings will drop like a bowling ball from the sky. Killing of Jamie's baby momma would be interesting, leaving Jamie with a baby thus putting Beth in a position of 'how hateful could she be" . She has vowed to eventually kill anything he loves, even if it with her bare hands. Garrett or her...need to go.
I love Jimmy and the direction he is going, John isn’t going anywhere, as far as I can tell the only options to go are Monica, garret, Jammie’s, his baby momma, or walker but we have been fooled before can’t wait!!!
To bad 1883 not on reg. Parmount channel only +
I agree. No one would notice if they got rid of Jimmie. He’s pretty much destined to kill himself doing something on a horse.
Please tell Sheridan that this season has become lame. Writing has gone totally downhill. Get rid of Carter, Tate, Monica, and most of all, Jimmy. Their storylines are just filler. Uninteresting filler. It used to be a must at 8pm, Sunday. Not anymore.