Mitch should start, however only if the play calling is only designed to use Mitch's strengths. Mitch can be the QB1 if he is utilized properly. Don't make the same mistake Matt Nagy did by making him fit your scheme. Because you will end up like Nagy without a head coaching position. Let the man play his game not your!
Allen - 2 years ago
We should start Mitch.We (me included) criticized Mitch when he was incompetent. Well, Kenny was not exactly "lighting up the scoreboard" before his injury. Mitch came in and played with confidence. Maybe the time on the bench gave him time to "reflect", and he learned from it. I think that if (and a BIG if) he can put together two wins in a row, he will have the confidence that he seemed to lack before. Our linemen need to QUIT HOLDING so damn much. They usually ruin big plays that we have made. Maybe if we start fining them for it, it will cease and they will learn how to block properly Hint to linemen"Move your feet laterally and STAY WITH YOUR BLOCK until it is no longer necessary - plain and simple!
Amelia - 2 years ago
Kenny is the better choice but he needs to rest to be 100 per cent healthy. Better to let him rest another week.
Mike - 2 years ago
No rush back from a concussion for Kenny. Leave Tribisky make his money or pull him for a suited Rudolf if he comes out flat. Trubisky looks better when hes aggressive and he will play different with nothing to lose after being benched.
Ben - 2 years ago
Was hoping there was a third choice. Guess not.
Dave Capel - 2 years ago
You start Mitch!! Kenny is not that good of a passer. He floats his passes, Kenny can not make the throws Mitch made Sunday!!
John - 2 years ago
Where’s the laugh button?? These comments! LoL ????
NotBigBen - 2 years ago
So many fans are showing how football dumb they are, the team is split on age and opinions, Experience should always be the starters, talent is a baseless evaluator as mistakes will derail any wannabe star. STFU and stay with the hot hand, Tomlin would be an idiot if he went back to Kenny Pick-it!
Richard Lovelace - 2 years ago
We know who Trubitsky is. He was not the starter and the team led when he entered the game. Kenny Picketthad outplayed the G.O.A.T. He could win or lose it and therefore take the risk, without any accountability. A win is always welcome, but the game wasn't all about the Steelers. Brady was at his worst. Kenny Picket is the future and his game savvy, competitiveness, and leadership along with his skills are proving that. Play to win, but you are seeing on tape that Picket is QB1. He's a rookie and has the better skill set. It will pay off. Possibly this year because of the hectic AFC North, but certainly in coming seasons! There is no quarterback controversy in Pittsburgh unless the media tries to create one.
Richard Hughes - 2 years ago
Mitch should start.
Gary - 2 years ago
Start Kenny because u already named him your starter If u go back now IF Kenny passes protocol and start trubisky then what does that mean rubidium is now the starter cause Kenny got hurt? Trubisky did play well but he still is Trubisky. We don’t know we will get that again .. at least with Kenny there is consistency plus he gets experience … and I don’t think I he went down all that hard to begin with… to me being that they both are kinda evenly played with Kenny being a lil better .. I think it’s benifical to have both qbs to available for different situations … I think maby having Kenny come out after basically a lil more then half the game was to confuse the defense because they are now seeing something they haven’t seen all day which is why I think Trubisky was successful…. I say play both!!! Ease Kenny in and keep defense on there feet draw up diff plays for each QBs and the the defense on there feet.. while having both rookie energy and veteran player… why don’t any teams ever have two QBS that play… I think this would be beneficial for an offense.. I think that is where the nfl is headed now anyways being that once a pin drops on a QBS head they take them out and go into concussion protocol… pretty soon u will have to have two good QBS to be able to play .. but I’ll b ok with whatever Tonkin decides he knows better then anyone who will be ready and give them the best chance… I like Pickett but at the same time feel for Trubisky… who knows maby being benched unleashed the beast and will be on fire now .. or he will just be Mitch… will see
1Sly-OG - 2 years ago
If Kenny clears concussion protocol...start him!!! He needs real NFL game experience in order to improve his play. I like K.P., let him play & grow. This year's a bust anyway...maybe we get us a good high draft pick!!!!!
Bryan - 2 years ago
All Mitch did was try not to lose! You can't lead from that position!!
Pitt Alum - 2 years ago
There is no QB controvery. Pickett led the Steelers to 10 points on the board in the first half, Trubisky led them to 10 in the 2nd half. Pickett should have had another TD in the first half from the red zone but unfortunately Pickens, a rookie as well ran the wrong route on a back corner pass into the endzone zone. On the next play somebody blew their assignment and missed their assigned block allowing them to free run at Pickett and he had to throw it away. These are not in Pickett's control. Trubisky came in and played for his life and future and did an admirable job, but if he were to be relegated to starter again would likely revert to the timid QB afraid to take those shots he was taking to anyone but the check down and it would be the first four games over again. Pickett is clearly the better QB with the winning attitude needed.
Sean Kopinski - 2 years ago
I was excited to see Trubisky play so well after his poor performance/crap play calling by Canada in the first 3.5 games. If Pickett has a concussion from this past Sunday, let him rest. I don't foresee this team doing anything productive this season. Let Pickett rest so he can come in healthy against the Eagles and continue to gain valuable experience. If we can get a top 5 or top 10 draft pick, we can bolster a few different positions. ????
Jon - 2 years ago
Guys Pickett just got into an injury I think we should let him rest and regain his strength if we put him in sooner what if he gets more badly damaged??
Dan - 2 years ago
Gotta be Mitch. He’ll have the whole week to prep. Possible Kenny could clear protocol, but would have the time to prepare.
Dan - 2 years ago
Gotta be Mitch. He’ll have the whole week to prep. Possible Kenny could clear protocol, but would have the time to prepare.
Meighan arend - 2 years ago
I want Kenny but I think put trubisky in .and Kenny in on eagles game.....
Mitch should start, however only if the play calling is only designed to use Mitch's strengths. Mitch can be the QB1 if he is utilized properly. Don't make the same mistake Matt Nagy did by making him fit your scheme. Because you will end up like Nagy without a head coaching position. Let the man play his game not your!
We should start Mitch.We (me included) criticized Mitch when he was incompetent. Well, Kenny was not exactly "lighting up the scoreboard" before his injury. Mitch came in and played with confidence. Maybe the time on the bench gave him time to "reflect", and he learned from it. I think that if (and a BIG if) he can put together two wins in a row, he will have the confidence that he seemed to lack before. Our linemen need to QUIT HOLDING so damn much. They usually ruin big plays that we have made. Maybe if we start fining them for it, it will cease and they will learn how to block properly Hint to linemen"Move your feet laterally and STAY WITH YOUR BLOCK until it is no longer necessary - plain and simple!
Kenny is the better choice but he needs to rest to be 100 per cent healthy. Better to let him rest another week.
No rush back from a concussion for Kenny. Leave Tribisky make his money or pull him for a suited Rudolf if he comes out flat. Trubisky looks better when hes aggressive and he will play different with nothing to lose after being benched.
Was hoping there was a third choice. Guess not.
You start Mitch!! Kenny is not that good of a passer. He floats his passes, Kenny can not make the throws Mitch made Sunday!!
Where’s the laugh button?? These comments! LoL ????
So many fans are showing how football dumb they are, the team is split on age and opinions, Experience should always be the starters, talent is a baseless evaluator as mistakes will derail any wannabe star. STFU and stay with the hot hand, Tomlin would be an idiot if he went back to Kenny Pick-it!
We know who Trubitsky is. He was not the starter and the team led when he entered the game. Kenny Picketthad outplayed the G.O.A.T. He could win or lose it and therefore take the risk, without any accountability. A win is always welcome, but the game wasn't all about the Steelers. Brady was at his worst. Kenny Picket is the future and his game savvy, competitiveness, and leadership along with his skills are proving that. Play to win, but you are seeing on tape that Picket is QB1. He's a rookie and has the better skill set. It will pay off. Possibly this year because of the hectic AFC North, but certainly in coming seasons! There is no quarterback controversy in Pittsburgh unless the media tries to create one.
Mitch should start.
Start Kenny because u already named him your starter If u go back now IF Kenny passes protocol and start trubisky then what does that mean rubidium is now the starter cause Kenny got hurt? Trubisky did play well but he still is Trubisky. We don’t know we will get that again .. at least with Kenny there is consistency plus he gets experience … and I don’t think I he went down all that hard to begin with… to me being that they both are kinda evenly played with Kenny being a lil better .. I think it’s benifical to have both qbs to available for different situations … I think maby having Kenny come out after basically a lil more then half the game was to confuse the defense because they are now seeing something they haven’t seen all day which is why I think Trubisky was successful…. I say play both!!! Ease Kenny in and keep defense on there feet draw up diff plays for each QBs and the the defense on there feet.. while having both rookie energy and veteran player… why don’t any teams ever have two QBS that play… I think this would be beneficial for an offense.. I think that is where the nfl is headed now anyways being that once a pin drops on a QBS head they take them out and go into concussion protocol… pretty soon u will have to have two good QBS to be able to play .. but I’ll b ok with whatever Tonkin decides he knows better then anyone who will be ready and give them the best chance… I like Pickett but at the same time feel for Trubisky… who knows maby being benched unleashed the beast and will be on fire now .. or he will just be Mitch… will see
If Kenny clears concussion protocol...start him!!! He needs real NFL game experience in order to improve his play. I like K.P., let him play & grow. This year's a bust anyway...maybe we get us a good high draft pick!!!!!
All Mitch did was try not to lose! You can't lead from that position!!
There is no QB controvery. Pickett led the Steelers to 10 points on the board in the first half, Trubisky led them to 10 in the 2nd half. Pickett should have had another TD in the first half from the red zone but unfortunately Pickens, a rookie as well ran the wrong route on a back corner pass into the endzone zone. On the next play somebody blew their assignment and missed their assigned block allowing them to free run at Pickett and he had to throw it away. These are not in Pickett's control. Trubisky came in and played for his life and future and did an admirable job, but if he were to be relegated to starter again would likely revert to the timid QB afraid to take those shots he was taking to anyone but the check down and it would be the first four games over again. Pickett is clearly the better QB with the winning attitude needed.
I was excited to see Trubisky play so well after his poor performance/crap play calling by Canada in the first 3.5 games. If Pickett has a concussion from this past Sunday, let him rest. I don't foresee this team doing anything productive this season. Let Pickett rest so he can come in healthy against the Eagles and continue to gain valuable experience. If we can get a top 5 or top 10 draft pick, we can bolster a few different positions. ????
Guys Pickett just got into an injury I think we should let him rest and regain his strength if we put him in sooner what if he gets more badly damaged??
Gotta be Mitch. He’ll have the whole week to prep. Possible Kenny could clear protocol, but would have the time to prepare.
Gotta be Mitch. He’ll have the whole week to prep. Possible Kenny could clear protocol, but would have the time to prepare.
I want Kenny but I think put trubisky in .and Kenny in on eagles game.....