It's not that I dislike Singin', it's just that it's so over-rated. People point to this movie and say Kelly was the best (Hollywood) dancer of all time. He's not even the best dancer in this movie.
The Artist told this story better. Here's how meh Singin' is — given a choice between them, I'd watch Marjorie Morningstar first.
Robbie C - 8 months ago
Hmmm... the pinnacle of the hollywood musical or Stanley Kubrick's 9th best film? How will I ever decide.
Bill VanZandt - 8 months ago
I really like The Killing, and I'm glad it made it through after I had to vote against it last round. But Singin' In the Rain is my favorite movie of all time. Pure joy.
Trent Robb - 8 months ago
Classic madness. Musical vs brutal noir. I’m a noir kind of guy, voting for the musical. The performance of the song Singing in the Rain probably is the greatest representation of joy in movie history. Great movie, but just that …
Leave a Comment
Give others the chance to vote.
Share this poll, because the more votes the better.
It's not that I dislike Singin', it's just that it's so over-rated. People point to this movie and say Kelly was the best (Hollywood) dancer of all time. He's not even the best dancer in this movie.
The Artist told this story better. Here's how meh Singin' is — given a choice between them, I'd watch Marjorie Morningstar first.
Hmmm... the pinnacle of the hollywood musical or Stanley Kubrick's 9th best film? How will I ever decide.
I really like The Killing, and I'm glad it made it through after I had to vote against it last round. But Singin' In the Rain is my favorite movie of all time. Pure joy.
Classic madness. Musical vs brutal noir. I’m a noir kind of guy, voting for the musical. The performance of the song Singing in the Rain probably is the greatest representation of joy in movie history. Great movie, but just that …