This is the hardest choice for me, the comparisons just slide out of my thoughts.
Zodiac has... Downey? Tree of Life has... Dinos?
I voted Zodiac, purely off recency bias
Beth - 3 weeks ago
Golly - a nightmare vs a nightmare for me. Which one was less tramatic?
Erin Teachman (Los Angeles) - 3 weeks ago
What the heck to do with this matchup, two films that are basically not in dialogue with the same cinematic concepts at all. I have to go with Tree of Life though, it's the more audacious film, the one trying to reckon with storytelling itself, that is both profoundly universal and fascinatingly specific, I have to go with Malick over Fincher on this one.
Jonathan Anderson, Denver CO - 3 weeks ago
Oh man, this one hurts. Hoping my heart led me right here.
Leave a Comment
Give others the chance to vote.
Share this poll, because the more votes the better.
This is the hardest choice for me, the comparisons just slide out of my thoughts.
Zodiac has... Downey? Tree of Life has... Dinos?
I voted Zodiac, purely off recency bias
Golly - a nightmare vs a nightmare for me. Which one was less tramatic?
What the heck to do with this matchup, two films that are basically not in dialogue with the same cinematic concepts at all. I have to go with Tree of Life though, it's the more audacious film, the one trying to reckon with storytelling itself, that is both profoundly universal and fascinatingly specific, I have to go with Malick over Fincher on this one.
Oh man, this one hurts. Hoping my heart led me right here.