Best of Staten Island '25: Vote for your favorite plain pizza! (Poll Closed)
Napoli Pizza
25%
Ungaro Coal Fired Pizzza Cafe
22%
Brother's Pizzeria
16%
Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza and Trattoria
10%
Denino's Pizzeria and Tavern
7%
Joe and Pat's
6%
Jimmy Max
4%
My Pizza
1%
Dough by Licastri
1%
Ciro's
1%
Pizzeria Giove
1%
Gino's
1%
Gino's Villa Monte Pizzeria
<1%
Kingdom Pizza
<1%
Nonna's Pizza Great Kills
<1%
Nonna's Pizza Tottenville
<1%
Pier 76
<1%
Cafe Milano
<1%
Original Giuseppes Pizza
<1%
Round Pie Pizza Company
<1%
The Original Goodfellas
<1%
Tony's Brick Oven
<1%
Pizza Parlor
<1%
Domenico's Pizzeria
<1%
Frank and Danny's
<1%
Bravo Pizza and Sports Bar
<1%
Justinos Pizza
<1%
Mangia
<1%
Mr. Pizza's Pasta House
<1%
Palermo Pizza
<1%
Pronto Pizza PAsta
<1%
Sal and Lloyd's Pizza Place
<1%
Amalfi Coast Pizzeria and Restaurant
<1%
Casa Nino's Pizza Bar
<1%
Mamma Mia Pizzeria and Cucina
<1%
Amici's
<1%
La Piazza Pizzeria and Tap
<1%
Mona Lisa
<1%
Village Maria
<1%
Kills Boro Taproom
<1%
Lorenzo's Pizza
<1%
Pizzaioli of Staten Island
<1%
Plaza Pizza
<1%
Ti Amo Pizza
<1%
Torino Pizza Cafe
<1%
Big Al's Pizza
<1%
Il Forno Pizzeria
<1%
Panini Grill
<1%
Primo Pizzeria
<1%
Rossville Pizza
<1%
Crispy Pizza
0%
La Bella Pizza
0%
Michaelangelos Pizzeria
0%
Piccolo Pinos Pizzeria
0%
Sunset Pizza
0%
Vio Ponte Pizzeria
0%
closed
