None of the options covered my views... And someone like Michael Behe, a ID proponent would have no options either.
I don't have a problem with evolution, but I do reject the naturalistic explanations. So I'm somewhere b/t 2 and 3.
I need another category!
Accept natural selection and genetic change over time as factors driving changes in populations of biological organisms
Reject evolution as a means adequate to account for all speciation
I guess the closest answer would be #2, but in my experience you have to differentiate what parts of evolution you're speaking about!