The manuscript you reviewed (major comments, "needs 2nd round of review") gets published as-is. You:
Vow never to referee for the journal again.
Decide to recalibrate your comments to make them harsher, so the editor will take them seriously next time.
Guess that the other reviewers must have loved the submission, and that you were out-voted.
Consider that your criticisms may have been wrong.
Reiterate your criticisms of the paper in post-publication discussions of it.
Weep for the death of effective peer review.
See this poll on:
Leave a Comment
Please enter your name.
Please enter your email address.
Your Website (optional)
Please enter a comment.
Created at Crowdsignal.com