This is an idealistic question. What has dying for a fellow Singaporean got to do with nationalistic pride and loyalty? Why so extreme as to link it to death? Would the MPs die for us Singaporean as we slowly 'die' our way to paying our bills among other things?
I feel strongly we are already showing our pride and loyalty as Singaporeans with what we are doing now, sacrificing time with family to work hard, keep the economy moving, paying our taxes like any law abiding citizen, respecting fellow Singaporeans, supporting policies that are suppose to better our lives (hopefully).
JG - 16 years ago
shopkedai: "I believe many will stay and die for the state".... DUH!
Singapore dun owe me anything & I dun owe Singapore anything, between us it's strictly business.
However, Singaporean's WILL die for the state, willingly or unwillingly. Why? As a former officer in the armed forces I know that the SAF protocol is to mobilise the reservists far in advance of any potential conflict. After reporting for mobilisation, the men will not be released until the threats have gone. At that point, the unwilling soldiers will have to decide whether to desert and face prosecution or to simply join the conflict.
PRs would sign the child as citizen should consider this carefully, don't presume you can escape when the crunch arrives.
Ah Loke - 16 years ago
TuffDaddy & Mk: similarly, some of us may vote "yes" now, but when it comes to the crunch...
Hans Pieters - 16 years ago
'To die for your country' is such an old fashioned and romantic idea. Nobody should say 'YES' to such a question. Moreover it is a complete nonsense question. I lived month in the Westin Hotel in Raffles City and I liked to look to the traffic from my balcony.
Nowhere - I lived fom Taipeh to Boston - did I see people so unwilling to let an ambulance with siren or fire brigade pass as as in Singapore.
So I could say as non Singaporean: Singaporean vote maybe YES but in every days life they are not willing to spend a minute to save lives of fellow citizens.
I am old (70+) but in the MRT most seats were taken by young lads and girls, no one ever in those months offered their seat. Even in New york are the young once better raised. Maybe HK is worse.
You will understand, t6hat I don't believe in the people of Singapore.
yeo boon chwee - 16 years ago
as a country and as a human , we should be united, if there is no country then where are all the people, country are make up of many people , so one should be too selfish , it take many ppl to build a country. We just cannot live by ourself alone. So i hope as a singaporean, i can do something for the ppl of singapore. becos i love my country and i love the ppl of my country.
Beecar - 16 years ago
I hardly can get people to give way to me when I try to switch lane daily , even my car's signal blink non-stop , do you expect me to believe we can die for each other ?
Hello , its Singapore you know !
Bengz - 16 years ago
This nation hasn't seen a major crisis since 1960s and until that crisis comes, we won't know if our fellow Singaporeans are willing to fight for one another. Although we don't really want crises to hit us, but challenging times produces heroes who bond the nation.
localised passer by - 16 years ago
hotel singapore. u dun die for a hotel do u?
shopkedai - 16 years ago
As a non Singaporean, I believe many will stay and die for the state. The land where we were born has an effect on us. There is spiritual connection between us and that part of the earth, we call home. Maybe it does not hit us right now is because, we are to busy making a living. Here we are talking about the true blue blood Singaporean, they will turn their laptops into laser beam when when call come. I have a great respect for this small great nation and his people.
JG - 16 years ago
The reality is that Singapore is hardly a nation, it's a place where people of different nationality come together to work and having a PR status or their child as a citizen is merely a convenience.
Without a doubt, Singapore needs this formula, to be open to the world best talents and the challenge for us Citizens is to compete with the best the global stage has to offer. And we should rise up to the challenge.
But to die for Singapore? I'm sure we can find greener pastures. For now I just hope the ministers of Singapore stop listening to the grass roots who just can't say no to them and have a reality check.
th - 16 years ago
It really depends on for what cause.
I will not die for drivers who drive as if they own the road, people who pretend to be sleeping on crowded mrts or gang members who still think it's cool to be one etc.
These can die first to to "cleanup" the population a bit.
BornInSingapore - 16 years ago
Half the country made up of foreigners. The FTs can die for Singaporeans.
Simon Khoo - 16 years ago
"Die"? You have got to be kidding me. Blood is thicker than water; I will only die for my parents or brothers, blood brothers...
Dang - 16 years ago
This question is too hard and too fast. A more moderate test of loyalty to each other as Singaporeans is this - If I have two shirts and I see a fellow citizen with no shirt, will I be willing to give hime my extra shirt?
singaporean 999 - 16 years ago
SOME ONE SHOULD POLL THE WHOLE CABINET MINISTERS AND MPs, COMPARE IT TO ORDINARY SINGAPOREAN, AND PRINT OUT THE STATS TO LET SINGAPOREAN KNOW.
THANKS
Singaporean - 16 years ago
Before challenging whether Singaporeans will die for their country, LKY should aski himself if he and his Ministers would at least be willing to work for their country for a couple of million dollars less.
worry - 16 years ago
the question is not so simple. If in the next 20 years, more foreigners become singaporeans/pr. And when the crisis arises, the foreigners aka new singaporeans/pr flock back to their homeland, then the question would arise, why would i want to sacrifice myself when more than 1/3 of singaporeans/prs are not born and bred singaporeans. They simply retreat back to their homeland while i stay back and sacrifice my life??? they took in foreigners too fast for the last few years although they slowed down recently , but the effect is felt already.
Mk - 16 years ago
@TuffDaddy: It's not "some", it's most.
Anon - 16 years ago
I think that a better question will be "will you live for the nation".
Don't feel like explaining what is so wrong/right about the word "dying" as I can go about writing a whole essay on this. All I can say is that there is a possible stigma involved about dying.
TuffDaddy - 16 years ago
some of us may vote a 'no' now, but i've always believed, when it comes to the crunch, singapore citizens will rise to the challenge.
Leave a Comment
Give others the chance to vote.
Share this poll, because the more votes the better.
This is an idealistic question. What has dying for a fellow Singaporean got to do with nationalistic pride and loyalty? Why so extreme as to link it to death? Would the MPs die for us Singaporean as we slowly 'die' our way to paying our bills among other things?
I feel strongly we are already showing our pride and loyalty as Singaporeans with what we are doing now, sacrificing time with family to work hard, keep the economy moving, paying our taxes like any law abiding citizen, respecting fellow Singaporeans, supporting policies that are suppose to better our lives (hopefully).
shopkedai: "I believe many will stay and die for the state".... DUH!
Singapore dun owe me anything & I dun owe Singapore anything, between us it's strictly business.
However, Singaporean's WILL die for the state, willingly or unwillingly. Why? As a former officer in the armed forces I know that the SAF protocol is to mobilise the reservists far in advance of any potential conflict. After reporting for mobilisation, the men will not be released until the threats have gone. At that point, the unwilling soldiers will have to decide whether to desert and face prosecution or to simply join the conflict.
PRs would sign the child as citizen should consider this carefully, don't presume you can escape when the crunch arrives.
TuffDaddy & Mk: similarly, some of us may vote "yes" now, but when it comes to the crunch...
'To die for your country' is such an old fashioned and romantic idea. Nobody should say 'YES' to such a question. Moreover it is a complete nonsense question. I lived month in the Westin Hotel in Raffles City and I liked to look to the traffic from my balcony.
Nowhere - I lived fom Taipeh to Boston - did I see people so unwilling to let an ambulance with siren or fire brigade pass as as in Singapore.
So I could say as non Singaporean: Singaporean vote maybe YES but in every days life they are not willing to spend a minute to save lives of fellow citizens.
I am old (70+) but in the MRT most seats were taken by young lads and girls, no one ever in those months offered their seat. Even in New york are the young once better raised. Maybe HK is worse.
You will understand, t6hat I don't believe in the people of Singapore.
as a country and as a human , we should be united, if there is no country then where are all the people, country are make up of many people , so one should be too selfish , it take many ppl to build a country. We just cannot live by ourself alone. So i hope as a singaporean, i can do something for the ppl of singapore. becos i love my country and i love the ppl of my country.
I hardly can get people to give way to me when I try to switch lane daily , even my car's signal blink non-stop , do you expect me to believe we can die for each other ?
Hello , its Singapore you know !
This nation hasn't seen a major crisis since 1960s and until that crisis comes, we won't know if our fellow Singaporeans are willing to fight for one another. Although we don't really want crises to hit us, but challenging times produces heroes who bond the nation.
hotel singapore. u dun die for a hotel do u?
As a non Singaporean, I believe many will stay and die for the state. The land where we were born has an effect on us. There is spiritual connection between us and that part of the earth, we call home. Maybe it does not hit us right now is because, we are to busy making a living. Here we are talking about the true blue blood Singaporean, they will turn their laptops into laser beam when when call come. I have a great respect for this small great nation and his people.
The reality is that Singapore is hardly a nation, it's a place where people of different nationality come together to work and having a PR status or their child as a citizen is merely a convenience.
Without a doubt, Singapore needs this formula, to be open to the world best talents and the challenge for us Citizens is to compete with the best the global stage has to offer. And we should rise up to the challenge.
But to die for Singapore? I'm sure we can find greener pastures. For now I just hope the ministers of Singapore stop listening to the grass roots who just can't say no to them and have a reality check.
It really depends on for what cause.
I will not die for drivers who drive as if they own the road, people who pretend to be sleeping on crowded mrts or gang members who still think it's cool to be one etc.
These can die first to to "cleanup" the population a bit.
Half the country made up of foreigners. The FTs can die for Singaporeans.
"Die"? You have got to be kidding me. Blood is thicker than water; I will only die for my parents or brothers, blood brothers...
This question is too hard and too fast. A more moderate test of loyalty to each other as Singaporeans is this - If I have two shirts and I see a fellow citizen with no shirt, will I be willing to give hime my extra shirt?
SOME ONE SHOULD POLL THE WHOLE CABINET MINISTERS AND MPs, COMPARE IT TO ORDINARY SINGAPOREAN, AND PRINT OUT THE STATS TO LET SINGAPOREAN KNOW.
THANKS
Before challenging whether Singaporeans will die for their country, LKY should aski himself if he and his Ministers would at least be willing to work for their country for a couple of million dollars less.
the question is not so simple. If in the next 20 years, more foreigners become singaporeans/pr. And when the crisis arises, the foreigners aka new singaporeans/pr flock back to their homeland, then the question would arise, why would i want to sacrifice myself when more than 1/3 of singaporeans/prs are not born and bred singaporeans. They simply retreat back to their homeland while i stay back and sacrifice my life??? they took in foreigners too fast for the last few years although they slowed down recently , but the effect is felt already.
@TuffDaddy: It's not "some", it's most.
I think that a better question will be "will you live for the nation".
Don't feel like explaining what is so wrong/right about the word "dying" as I can go about writing a whole essay on this. All I can say is that there is a possible stigma involved about dying.
some of us may vote a 'no' now, but i've always believed, when it comes to the crunch, singapore citizens will rise to the challenge.