Hmm.. you guys are off you nut! Scotty's just another country singer.. Yeah he's good but Haley and Lauren appeal to everyone! Go Girls! I hope Scotty goes home!
Chloe - 13 years ago
I agree i hope lauren fattie and scotty in the final cuz nobody will watch 2 dull country singers. everything scottie sings is the same. sounds the same. Halley is original with a strong voclas and unique voice. jlo is a bitch cuz she is so jealous and wants either ugly boy scotty or fatty to win. she is too untalented to judge singing cuz she cant sing herself.
HALEY 4 THE WIN!! WOOT!!!!! - 13 years ago
Haley is the best singer of the 3. NO DOUBT. Can you imagine Lauren or boring Scottie tackling any of those 3 songs? LOL! It would be spectacle. Instead..Jimmy threw them softballs for songs...easy melodic, non-challenging pieces. I hope the less talented country bumpkins make it to the finals so we can finally put that last nail in Idol's coffin.
deonna - 13 years ago
they all r good but i want scotty 2 WIN! GO GET SCOTTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Bert P - 13 years ago
How could you say Haleys "growl" is fake! She just has a raspy voice and I think it's totally natural. Scotty's Amazed didn't do a thing for me. I'm a country fan first and foremost and I love "Amazed", but I have to go with Haley this time. She can sing anything.
ooby dooby - 13 years ago
Whether the judges play favorites or not doesn't matter as they don't vote, we do. Personally I miss Simon. Everyone this year is afraid to be critical. Jimmy's pick for Haley had great potential, just listen to Stevie Nicks sing it. Haley kinda looks lke a sining poledancer. I'm not trying to be mean.
Cate - 13 years ago
Lauren is a sweet southern bell to be sure, however Haley is in it to win it! Go Haley!
Would love to see an all girl final for a change! Wouldn't that be awesome?
Jlo would have a complete cow if Scottie with his shaved head wasn't in it. How much
more of playing favorites could Jlo get with the comment about Scottie's hair in the
finale? I do think the judges and Jimmy picked a more difficult degree of song for Haley and
quite frankly jimmy's pick was just boring.
wanda - 13 years ago
UMMMM......... EXcUSE ME BUT LAUREN ALAINA IS NOT GOING HOME, IN FAcT SHE'S GOING TO WIN! BUT, HALEY IS GOING HOME!
wanda - 13 years ago
UMMMM......... EXcUSE ME BUT LAUREN ALAINA IS NOT GOING HOME, IN FAcT SHE'S GOING TO WIN! BUT, HALEY IS GOING HOME!
Fran - 13 years ago
I have rewatched Scotty's performance several times this morning. Not a single missed note, perfect timing, no overuse of background singers, and he is the only one really stretching out of his comfort zone...and doing it well, I might add. He may not look like your typical "idol," but he sure sounds like it!!!
susan - 13 years ago
I don't get Haley. James , Scotty, Lauren, Pia and Casey are all so much better than she is. She's awkward and her "growl" is forced. She's more of a lounge entertainer to me than a star or someone who could sell records. I really don't get her appeal at all. But to each his/her own. I am happy for her because she's having the time of her life.
van - 13 years ago
i really agree, Lauren Alaina should stay....she's a great performer...
ooby dooby - 13 years ago
Haley is so Karaoke. If Zep or Stevie Nicks ever turned in a performance like that they would have been booed off the stage. She is a combo of Broadway/burlesque.
LAlainafan - 13 years ago
LAUREN SHOULD STAY!!
aRose - 13 years ago
I think the reason TPTB finally booted David Archuleta's dad was because he had been so obnoxious and interfering throughout that season. Several sources had commented on this at the time.
Belle - 13 years ago
Doesn't anyone else feel that it was ridiculously unfair having Haley's Dad on the stage? It was outrageous. A few years ago they banned David Archeleta's Dad from the studio because he was giving his son song advice and now they allow ONE of the contestants an unfair advantage. It seemed that the producers were trying to show a warmer side to the snarling, back-talking, ice princess.
Emjay - 13 years ago
GO TEAM HALEY!!!
Elaine - 13 years ago
Haley for the WIN!
Troy - 13 years ago
Ha! you wish...They know who is going to win...Haley!!!
Jeff - 13 years ago
I am so glad that most of the people think this is asking who is going to win.
Scotty, c'mon, bye.
Hmm.. you guys are off you nut! Scotty's just another country singer.. Yeah he's good but Haley and Lauren appeal to everyone! Go Girls! I hope Scotty goes home!
I agree i hope lauren fattie and scotty in the final cuz nobody will watch 2 dull country singers. everything scottie sings is the same. sounds the same. Halley is original with a strong voclas and unique voice. jlo is a bitch cuz she is so jealous and wants either ugly boy scotty or fatty to win. she is too untalented to judge singing cuz she cant sing herself.
Haley is the best singer of the 3. NO DOUBT. Can you imagine Lauren or boring Scottie tackling any of those 3 songs? LOL! It would be spectacle. Instead..Jimmy threw them softballs for songs...easy melodic, non-challenging pieces. I hope the less talented country bumpkins make it to the finals so we can finally put that last nail in Idol's coffin.
they all r good but i want scotty 2 WIN! GO GET SCOTTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How could you say Haleys "growl" is fake! She just has a raspy voice and I think it's totally natural. Scotty's Amazed didn't do a thing for me. I'm a country fan first and foremost and I love "Amazed", but I have to go with Haley this time. She can sing anything.
Whether the judges play favorites or not doesn't matter as they don't vote, we do. Personally I miss Simon. Everyone this year is afraid to be critical. Jimmy's pick for Haley had great potential, just listen to Stevie Nicks sing it. Haley kinda looks lke a sining poledancer. I'm not trying to be mean.
Lauren is a sweet southern bell to be sure, however Haley is in it to win it! Go Haley!
Would love to see an all girl final for a change! Wouldn't that be awesome?
Jlo would have a complete cow if Scottie with his shaved head wasn't in it. How much
more of playing favorites could Jlo get with the comment about Scottie's hair in the
finale? I do think the judges and Jimmy picked a more difficult degree of song for Haley and
quite frankly jimmy's pick was just boring.
UMMMM......... EXcUSE ME BUT LAUREN ALAINA IS NOT GOING HOME, IN FAcT SHE'S GOING TO WIN! BUT, HALEY IS GOING HOME!
UMMMM......... EXcUSE ME BUT LAUREN ALAINA IS NOT GOING HOME, IN FAcT SHE'S GOING TO WIN! BUT, HALEY IS GOING HOME!
I have rewatched Scotty's performance several times this morning. Not a single missed note, perfect timing, no overuse of background singers, and he is the only one really stretching out of his comfort zone...and doing it well, I might add. He may not look like your typical "idol," but he sure sounds like it!!!
I don't get Haley. James , Scotty, Lauren, Pia and Casey are all so much better than she is. She's awkward and her "growl" is forced. She's more of a lounge entertainer to me than a star or someone who could sell records. I really don't get her appeal at all. But to each his/her own. I am happy for her because she's having the time of her life.
i really agree, Lauren Alaina should stay....she's a great performer...
Haley is so Karaoke. If Zep or Stevie Nicks ever turned in a performance like that they would have been booed off the stage. She is a combo of Broadway/burlesque.
LAUREN SHOULD STAY!!
I think the reason TPTB finally booted David Archuleta's dad was because he had been so obnoxious and interfering throughout that season. Several sources had commented on this at the time.
Doesn't anyone else feel that it was ridiculously unfair having Haley's Dad on the stage? It was outrageous. A few years ago they banned David Archeleta's Dad from the studio because he was giving his son song advice and now they allow ONE of the contestants an unfair advantage. It seemed that the producers were trying to show a warmer side to the snarling, back-talking, ice princess.
GO TEAM HALEY!!!
Haley for the WIN!
Ha! you wish...They know who is going to win...Haley!!!
I am so glad that most of the people think this is asking who is going to win.