I'm guessing the predicted results would be that more people would take their child to the police over stolen shoes than water? Also, any reason why gender is specified?
I'm guessing heads is shoes then...
Shoes are worth more than water, will more people turn her in?
Shoes? It's about a bottle of water...
I'd make her do community service, and send an anonymous donation to the shop.
I'd make her mail the shoes back.
I would, however, make donate the shoes to a charity, and possibly strongly suggest she volunteers there for at least a month if she'd like me to calm down.