26 Comments

• 
  proof in the RATINGS!! muahh - 12 years ago

  Umm... phych fans may have swarmed this poll, but talk to me when the show gets over 12 million viewers... I'll be nice, and say, talk to me when it get's more than 10. FACT, more people watch Simon... end of story. :o)

  Plus, he's wayyyy less annoying.

• 
  PSYCHO!!!!! - 12 years ago

  James for ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)

• 
  Karen - 13 years ago

  I think the proof of who's better is in the comments. The proof is in the pudding! James you are the best! There is NOTHING sexier than a sense of humor! Wait for iiiiiiiiiiit.... for tonight we talk to you live! Cuz its much harder if you're dead. lol

• 
  psych-o forver - 13 years ago

  James Roday all the way baby. So much hotter and have you seen his hair, so awesome. The Mentalist is just a really, really, really, really boring version of Psych. I mean really what would you rather have a crime fighting duo, girl screams, funny nicknames, and just plain funny and be laughing the entire episode with some drama OR would you rather have one guy, all drama, and no laughs. Seriously I watched 2 episodes of The Mentalist to give it a chance and that's 2 hours of my life I will never get back it was so boring.

• 
  iacomary97 - 13 years ago

  You're wrong. The best is Simon Baker.

  xD
  I'm joking guys. (The prove is my website)
  I'm totally in love with "Rodríguez". I have him on the Dextop *u*

  #Chocolate_Columbo...
  you're right!!!!

• 
  Alison - 13 years ago

  Shawn. And I have the evidence to prove it:

  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ssMh2-lZRoY&feature=channel_video_title

• 
  janajee - 13 years ago

  Shawn and only Shawn is TV's valid fake psychic. THAT IS ALL.

• 
  redenious - 13 years ago

  I like how no comments have mentioned the other guy.

  Shawn, yeah! Dude has swagger on stage!

• 
  Felicia Fancybottom - 13 years ago

  Shawn. You know that's right.

• 
  Marissa - 13 years ago

  James. Roday. All. The. Way.

• 
  Melanie - 13 years ago

  Shawn for sure, yo. All the way. No contest.

• 
  Jazz Hands - 13 years ago

  JAMES RODAY! ALL THE WAY! JAMES RODAY! ALL THE WAY!!! GOOOOOOOOO PSYCH!

• 
  Gus "Silly-Pants" Jackson - 13 years ago

  Most definitely Shawn/James Roday. I mean, have you seen that man's hair?

• 
  exactly one half of an 11 pound black forest ham - 13 years ago

  James Roday / Shawn Spencer is awesomeness, so..... x)

• 
  Abby - 13 years ago

  Shawn: You've seen "The Mentalist", right?
  Corporal Mackintosh: Yes!
  Shawn: It's like that.
  Gus: Except that guy's a fake.
  Shawn Spencer: Right. If I was a fake psychic, it would be eerily similar.
  Gus: Exactly the same.
  Shawn: A virtual carbon copy.

• 
  Big Head Burton - 13 years ago

  Shawn times a million, billion.

• 
  Chocolate Columbo - 13 years ago

  If Shawn doesn't win, i will slap your faces.

• 
  Laura - 13 years ago

  Shawn Spencer (James Roday), most definitely.

  Here's a simple equation for you:

  (Psych) - (comedy) - (originality) - (James Roday) + (network budget) = The Mentalist

• 
  MC ClapYoHandz - 13 years ago

  SHAWN! You know that's right.

• 
  Magic Head - 13 years ago

  James Roday, bros.

• 
  Wild Boy - 13 years ago

  The Australian is handsome but has a very low key personality...almost flatlined!

  No one can compete with James Roday's Shawn Spencer!

• 
  Rosie the Psych-o - 13 years ago

  The Mentalist is a FRAUD. Vote for Shawn!!

  Plus, he's soooooooooooo much hotter than Simon Baker.

• 
  Jeff - 13 years ago

  Anybody but Spencer.

• 
  psych is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!! - 13 years ago

  james (shawn spencer) roday for sure!!!!!!!! he is amazing on psych! he is amazing! :D :)

• 
  psych-o - 13 years ago

  Shawn is so cute! And he makes me crack up every single episode. He seems more dateable than the Mentalist guy who is really metro looking, but still cute.

• 
  a_fan - 13 years ago

  Shawn.

  End. Of. Story.