Should we replace the term "xx is following you" by "xx is a FAN of yours" in Seesmic?

8 Comments

  • Kamath - 18 years ago

    Follow sounds right. I chose to follow you but haven't decided I am a fan yet. 'Fan' is too presumptuous. Lesson learned from twitter hehe...

  • Arthur Vinvinovitch - 18 years ago

    A Fan? It's too much.

  • headache - 18 years ago

    I'm a fan of "fan"! Don't be a follower, don't use "follow"!

  • Ryan Graves - 18 years ago

    I think that it doesn't matter if you call it fan or follower. However, if 2 people both follow each other it is a good idea to call them friends.

    The poll doesn't allow for this differentiation.

    I like that you care and are paying attention to the details! Good work.

  • Edwin Khodabakchian - 18 years ago

    Hi Seesmic Team,

    You should try to also keep in mind the use case where you want to send an email to one of your friend and ask them to XXXX you. If you use "Fan", XXX becomes "Hi I found this great service called Seesmic. Where is the link where you can become my fan". Not a good sentence (too arrogant). On the other hand "here is the link where you can follow my videos/me" is not as bad.

    Cheers,

    Edwin

  • jonathan - 18 years ago

    No. I can follow somebody not because I agree or "love" what he said but to stay inform of his point of view (exemple: media1938)

  • Rowsmic - 18 years ago

    follower == stalker
    fan == fanatic
    viewer == viewer

  • Frédérick Dubois - 18 years ago

    Most of the people I follow deserve my respect, but I'm not their fan! I want to know what's going on with them, what they are doing/working on, but being a fan is far beyond that.

    I wont tear my hair appart crying and yelling if I see them on the street! Unless "fan" is stronger in french, I'd say it's a little bit too much in this situation...

    thx

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment