Do you blame LeAnn Rimes for Carly's loss?

3 Comments

  • steve smith - 14 years ago

    Lee Ann Rimes used to be great until she became uncontrolably horny for married men. And yes Lee Ann did screw up Carly's chances to win. Carly should of won, and would of had she had a decent relevant artist to sing with instead of Lee Ann Crimes. I mean seriously Tate had a relevant current chart topping group to jam with that was spot on. Lee Ann drug down that poor little girls chances, and she worked so hard! Tate sounds like most other country male singers he is not unique like Carly's pipes are. OMG when she did Somewhere Over The Rainbow! Enough said, sad so sad, thanks Lee Ann Rehab and shame on the X-Factor and/or her mentor for not choosing Celine Dion for Carly to sing with!!!!!!!!!!

  • Kimberley - 14 years ago

    Carly Rose had completely flawless performances the entire season. SHE CAN SING ANYTHING! Including LR's tired old song. That duet was terrible. Poor Carly Rose! Why on earth did X factor pair her with horrible LR? She has no class and is in a terrible state these days. Shame on Simon for not seeing how this would affect the outcome. My only solace is that Tate is a grown father out of work and needs the opportunity and Carly Rose has her whole beautiful life in front of her. She will have an amazing career. I will buy her first album. Most importantly, GO AWAY LR!

  • patty - 14 years ago

    I THINK LEANN DID A AWFUL JOB ON HER OWN SONG, CARLY SANG THAT SONG WAY BETTER THAN HER , AND SHE TOTALLY MESSED UP CARLY DURING THAT PERFORMANCE, CARLY IS BETTER THAN THAT, LEANN ACTED LIKE SHE WAS EITHER DRUNK OR ON SOMETHING, THEY ARE NOT SUPPOSE TO TRY TO TAKE THE SPOT LIGHT AWAY FROM THEM PEOPLE, BUT THE NERVE OF HER SAYING CARLY WAS HAVING TROUBLE WITH THE SONG IS INSANE, WHEN IN FACT LEANN WAS THE PROBLEM WITH THAT SONG. I DIDN'T LIKE THE WAY SHE PERFORMED AT ALL, SHAME ON HER AND SHE OWES CARLY AND HER FAMILY A APPOLOGY FOR TRYING TO TAKE THE SPOT LIGHT AND FOR ACTING LIKE SHE DID THROUGH THAT SONG....CARLY WE KNOW YOU COULD HAVE SMOKED HER ON HER OWN SONG.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment