Based on his career is Derek Jeter one of the top five or eight players to have ever played for the New York Yankees ?

His career simply proves that he belongs in the upper echelons of Yankees' greats 40% (2 votes)
Great players should be judged against those of their own era and not against those of the past 40% (2 votes)
Leave it for the baseball historians to bicker selfishly over as they love to create controversy and an idiotic debate 20% (1 vote)
No I would not rank him inside the top five ! 0% (0 votes)
Too subjective a question but Jeter was always a great player to begin with as his record proves 0% (0 votes)
He should be judged against that of his teammates during the span in which he played 0% (0 votes)
Other 0% 0 votes

Total Votes: 5

See this poll on: https://poll.fm/7815455/embed

Give others the chance to vote.