The Judges had pre-determined the top 14 before the semi-finals began. It did not matter how they performed. The Judges wanted the Young and the Restless 15 & 16 year olds.
jed j elizares - 8 years ago
i stopped watching American Idol a few years ago because of it's shameful decisions. I decided to give it one last chance for redemption. What was i thinking. Can't compare to the Voice..
James - 8 years ago
The last one voted in should not have made it! What is wrong with these judges! Have no respect for any of them anymore and will never watch them again!
Betty - 8 years ago
I have lost all faith in this show! I now think the blasted thing is rigged !
KP - 8 years ago
Jenn instead of Amelia? Total outrage! Jen did not do well this week. The off key singing Wednesday should have sent her home.
MPEA - 8 years ago
I was really disappointed that they did not put Shelbie through. She did not hit one bad note--on Bohemian Rhapsody! An extremely difficult song to sing! She showed a different side, and she handled it convincingly. I was especially impressed with how she transitioned from one style to another. She has a terrific personality too. I was shocked at their unjustifiably harsh critiques of her. Can they bring her back if there's enough viewer outrage?
The Judges had pre-determined the top 14 before the semi-finals began. It did not matter how they performed. The Judges wanted the Young and the Restless 15 & 16 year olds.
i stopped watching American Idol a few years ago because of it's shameful decisions. I decided to give it one last chance for redemption. What was i thinking. Can't compare to the Voice..
The last one voted in should not have made it! What is wrong with these judges! Have no respect for any of them anymore and will never watch them again!
I have lost all faith in this show! I now think the blasted thing is rigged !
Jenn instead of Amelia? Total outrage! Jen did not do well this week. The off key singing Wednesday should have sent her home.
I was really disappointed that they did not put Shelbie through. She did not hit one bad note--on Bohemian Rhapsody! An extremely difficult song to sing! She showed a different side, and she handled it convincingly. I was especially impressed with how she transitioned from one style to another. She has a terrific personality too. I was shocked at their unjustifiably harsh critiques of her. Can they bring her back if there's enough viewer outrage?