If Justin Hartley Leaves Y&R Do You Want Michael Muhney Back as Adam Newman?
35 Comments

  • Vicki Twibell - 5 years ago

    In my opinion M.M. IS Adam!! He made every scene worth watching and his sex appeal can't be matched!!! Please bring him back with no attention brought to his beautiful face...we know who he is!! I also noticed that Connor looks like him!

  • DEBRA BIAS - 5 years ago

    PLEASE BRING MICHAEL MUHNEY BACK AS ADAM NEWMAN. SECOND CHANCES ARE A BLESSING.

  • Janis sanchez - 5 years ago

    That smirk of Adams can only be done by Michael Muhney!He is the only one can play that part. And I swear that son , Conner, looks just like him.

  • aly - 5 years ago

    What if the Hartley Adam was really the Gabe Guy & was deliberately dissappeared, to bring back the real Adam Muhney. What if the real Adam Muhney has been held hostage somewhere or forced to be out of sight, with either Sage (if shes not really dead of course) OR with that clever little Chloe in the mix of it all seeking her ongoing revenge? Be creative in the solution of this Y&R writers, I've been watching this show for several decades, you can really juice this outcome for the fans!!!! MM is da man you need!!!

  • Shelly - 5 years ago

    It would be a big mistake to bring Michael back after what he did to hunter and who knows how many others. Gina and Jason are fabulous. They finally got it right. They have charisma. Justin and Claire have such chemistry ,it will be hard to replace him. I hope his show is successful but hope he can do both. Everyone would like the chemistry they have in their own lives. Michael never had it. Justin is stunning, Michael not at all. Love scenes were not the same electric quality as with Justin.

  • Shelly - 5 years ago

    It would be a big mistake to bring Michael back after what he did to hunter and who knows how many others. Gina and Jason are fabulous. They finally got it right. They have charisma. Justin and Claire have such chemistry ,it will be hard to replace him. I hope his show is successful but hope he can do both. Everyone would like the chemistry they have in their own lives. Michael never had it. Justin is stunning, Michael not at all. Love scenes were not the same electric quality as with Justin.

  • Judy caron - 5 years ago

    When will the christan reveal happen. When the child is adult they said February than may sweeps so sick of waiting come on get your act together y&r

  • mzglorybe - 5 years ago

    Michael Muhney WAS Adam. The young boy playing the part of his son, Connor, even looks like Muhney. I didn't think I'd like Hartley as much but he did a good job and I'm sorry to see him go, he was great in the role. If the person who fired Muhney is no longer an issue perhaps he would reconsider coming back. That is, of course, if the part of Adam remains open, but it looks like they've killed him off for good this time. Let's hope Chloe gets the boot she deserves. It's the least Y&R can do for us fans after losing the Adam/Chelsea saga we all love....and if we could get Billy Miller back as Billy, I'd be a happy fan. Gina's role as Phyllis has been really hard to get used to. She has such a hardness to her face, especially her mouth, seems like she is always sneering, whereas Stafford had a softness to her smile and was much more likable, even when she was nasty. That's my 2-cents!

  • camille scala - 5 years ago

    I never liked him. I cannot believe they would bring him back. The girl who plays Summer had an issue with him that is the reason they let him go. I think he made sexual advance towards her. Bring in a new Adam if you can't bring back Jusin Hartley. Give Chelsea and Adam (Justin Hartley) a 2nd chance.

  • charmain glass - 5 years ago

    Justin Hartman was great as Adam. The love/hate sparring between Victor and him was magical. I hope they recast the role of Adam with another talented actor. I really liked the first Adam. I got used to the second one, Michael Muhney, and I really liked the third one. In light of the conditions of Michael Muhney's leaving, I would like to see a fresh actor in the role in consideration of all concerned. I know it's hard for people to see clearly when a beloved actor is involved.

  • Donna Scott - 5 years ago

    I never watched Y&R until Steve Burton joined the show! It wasn't that he was a favorite of mine on G.H. but i was curious about Y&R for quite some time..I started watching and i never had an actor that got my attn: as Michael Muhney did...I didn't quite know what to think of him.. I just knew he was different than any other actor i knew..I became so mesmerized with this actor & his style that i didn't know what to think if that makes any sense...I was sort of crushed when he was let go from the show. Justin is a great actor but i always thought if this makes any difference that he was to tall for Chelsea & could never compete with Michael as Adam Newman... I now i'm in the minority but i still feel he could not take Michael's place!!! JMO
    Than you for letting me vent!!

  • Lana - 5 years ago

    Bring Michael back!!!! Please!!!

  • Sherry - 5 years ago

    Bring Adam back take Chloe down once and for all. Would love to see Michael M. back or Justin.

  • Wanda J Rush - 5 years ago

    I loved Michael Muhney as Adam. When they fired him as Adam, I didn't watch the show for weeks. I read the dailies but couldn't watch. When they brought Adam back, I have really enjoyed Justin. He and Chelsea have great chemistry. The show today just blew my mind away. Oh no, not again. I want Adam and Chelsea to be happy. Just pooey! .......then the Billy situation. I loved Billy Miller as Billy . He is the best and he and Victoria need to be together. ........so many changes. This is the only soap I watch and .....Love Love Love Y&R

  • Rene - 5 years ago

    We need him . Please do not kill him.l love him

  • Madi Dee - 5 years ago

    Love Love Justin Hartley as Adam. Please don't recast. Like mentioned above get rid of Chloe for good! Jail would be nice.

  • Vickie - 5 years ago

    After watching todays show, I wanted to cry! There had to be some way out! Adam could not have been in there! Then I get on to check the spoilers and find out he is going to be gone for good? You absolutely fall in love with Justin Hartley! And him and Chelsea have to survive this and be happy for more than a week or two! Please just have Justin and Chelsea go away for a while so Adam can do what he needs to do and return in the near future! Please! He is a fantastic actor! Let Justin know that he has gained our love for him and he can't just leave like that! Or that we certainly wish him not to!
    I also love Gina as Phyllis! Not only is she a gorgeous lady, but one hell of an actress as well! Hillary, ,Devon and Neil are the ones that should be leaving! Boaring!!!

  • Maureen Bara - 5 years ago

    I was so happy when Adam returned to the show and Justin Hartley has done an amazing job of building this role. I truly hope he returns.

  • Maureen Bara - 5 years ago

    Please do not kill Adam off AGAIN!! I love

  • Marguerite Teed - 5 years ago

    The question is about Michael not Billy or Phylis..Omg people get over Billy and Phylis
    Why can't you move on.I would like to see MM
    If Justin leaves he is great as an actor.

  • Marguerite Teed - 5 years ago

    The question is about Michael not Billy or Phylis..Omg people get over Billy and Phylis
    Why can't you move on.I would like to see MM
    If Justin leaves he is great as an actor.

  • Tanner tan - 5 years ago

    Young and restless bring back the original gangsters Michelle stafford billy Martin and Michael muhney and your rating will blow the roof off.

  • Lori - 5 years ago

    There is a Lord @ Y&R.....
    Michael needs to come back. He is the true Adam. Justin did a great job learning the role no doubt. But, no one can play the part like Michael does. I was trying to picture Micheal playing the role last week when Adam and Nick was having a bonding moment as brothers.!
    Will be waiting patiently in Virginia.

  • Long time fan - 5 years ago

    I love Justin Hartley he filled Michael Muhney role good !So if a recast bring back old Adam.
    I The

  • naisy prevost - 5 years ago

    I love both Michael Muhney and Justin Hartley but if Justin leaves then I want to see Michael back because he and Melissa (Chelsea) had awesome chemistry. I loved Billy Miller since his stint on all my children but I'm liking Jason Thompson's portrayal. And of course what can I say about Gina Tognoni I've loved her since guiding light. I love her as Phyllis. Please listen to me powers that be because I'm a true fan since a little girl watching with my mom.

  • Rlere - 5 years ago

    Get rid of the current Phyllis & Billy.

    He is too old and NO ONE can take Billy Miller's place. No one

  • Rlere - 5 years ago

    Only Adam

    Get rid of Phyllis & Billy

  • MaryV - 5 years ago

    First of all I totally agree with the first comment from Gail, that Travis would be a perfect Billy Abbott. But saying that the new Billy is awesome. I also agree with some of the other remarks I.e. Justin is a fabulous Adam, but Michael M. owned the role. I also stopped watching for a time, due to the craziness that seemed to be going on with the Y and R staff...Glad to see it coming back. Oh I also agree that Gina T. Is overacting couldn't stand all her whispering to Billy.

  • Gail - 5 years ago

    Simply love Justin Hartley as Adam! Hope this.doesntr.have to change. Feel Gina T is superior as Phyllis over Michelle S so would dislike her returning. As far as Billy,.dont think they have it right yet. The actor who is cast as Travis would.be a perfect Billy Abbott.

  • Marstid - 5 years ago

    Hartley is great playing Adam. If Hartly want play the role, leave it for a while. I was die hard Muhney but Hartley has taken the role over..

  • L. Collier - 5 years ago

    Please rehire Micheal Muhney whether Justin Hartley or not. Justin Hartley is a wonderful actor, however Justin Hartley acting skills bring the role of Adam to life.
    Please get rid of the new Billy. He was great as Dr. Drake on GH, but his good looks isn't helping him on Y&R. Send him back to GH...he is missed there.

  • GAIL COHEN - 5 years ago

    DEFINITELY GET MICHELLE STAFFORD, BILLIE MILLER, AND MICHAEL MUHNEY BACK AND
    WATCH YOUR RATINGS BLOW THE OTHER SOAPS AWAY

  • Jackie Jepsen - 5 years ago

    i like the current Adam, but please don't ever bring back the old Phillis, get rid of the current Billy and bring back Biller Miller, (I think that was his name) every time I get to really like a character, they take them away!!! Just leave the show as it is, except get rid on this Billy!!!!!

  • Longtime fan from TN - 5 years ago

    If Michael Muhney can step back into the role of Adam Newman plz do not recast. I have watched Y&R since it's beginning. I did not like the character of Adam at first but over time I've come to adore him and his family. Both Justin and Michael have done the character justice ..execellent acting skills. They both remind me of a young Eric Braden cutoos to the casting staff however plz do not recast the roll. I would rather lose a beloved character than see anyone else in the role.

  • WYOMING ELLIS - 5 years ago

    I had a hard time seeing Michael MUHNEY LEAVE. HE WAS GOOD. I GOT USED TO JUSTIN HARTLEY. YOU CAN'T DO THE SAME THING TWICE.NOW JUSTIN IS GREAT. SO IF HE LEAVE MICHAEL MUHNEY WILL BE THE ONLY ADAM TO GET USE TO AGAIN. HE WAS THE BEST ADAM.I QUIT WATCHING WHEN HE LEFT, BUT STARTED BACK WATCHING.IF JUSTIN LEAVE PLEASE BRING BACK MICHAEL MUHNEY. GET RID OF CHLOE FOR GOOD.THIS PHYLLIS OVER ACTS EVERY PART. SHE MAKES ME SICK. AND WHY DOES SHARON ALWAYS GET AWAY.IT'S NOT REALITY. BUT LEAVE VICTOR ALONE AND LET HIM PLAY HIS PART. CATHERINE IS STILL MISSED, SO LET THE FANS HAVE SOMETHING TO FEEL GOOD ABOUT WHEN WATCHING THE SHOW. AND WRITE SOME TO CLEAR ADAM ONCE AND FOR ALL AS WELL AS ADAM. GET RID OF HILLARY FOR GOOD, AND GIVE DEVON SOME COURAGE AND NOT TO BE A BLIND FOOL.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment