At first I thought, how can you choose just one?! After watching the videos, I can give a very slight edge to the dudes in #1. But, there's no way I could pick one or the other in #2.
If someone asked me that question face to face I'd be like 'duh, I'll take a hot guy anytime' but after watching those videos the cute wee doggies had my heart melting! I especially loved the dogs in towels, i mean I liked the guys in towels too but for a totally different reason ;-) What even made you come up with the question Dogs or Dudes?