Would You Prefer Justin Hartley As Part-Time Adam Newman or Michael Muhney Full Time?

Poll choices
Posted 3 years.


  • Tinamarie - 3 years ago

    Michael muhney is the real Adam.

  • cindy - 3 years ago

    The show isn't the same without Adam. I watch every day waiting for him to come back. It's time. I like Justin but also michael. My fave is chelsea n adam. Now already. Chloe goes down. Nick should find someone else to love.

  • Taylor Tracey - 3 years ago

    Michael Muhney IS Adam Newman but if we can't have him, Justin is second choice. He's not believable, kinda weak like Nick Newman (sorry Joshua). Michael Muhney makes Adam Newman intense & dark. Justin hasn't captured that.

  • Leah - 3 years ago

    Justin Hartley made the character his. Michael Muhney made the character one dimensional, totally unlikeable by every one to whom I've spoken. I would much rather have Justin Hartley appear on a recurring basis. MM, I would have no interest in watching.

  • Sonya davis - 3 years ago

    Bring back michael

  • teresa chiles - 3 years ago

    I don't even watch young and the restless since Adam went off the show. They need to bring back michael muney

  • Lori - 3 years ago

    Here we go again....
    Haven't we gone down this road before?
    YOU know who we WANT....
    Please bring Michael back before we turn off Y&R.

  • Tallie - 3 years ago

    Adam is a thinking man. So that character needs a thinking actor to portray Adam. Hartley is just that and gave Adam a real core. The other actor did not have the attention getting Davy to the inner workings of Adam. He just delivered anger and depression. Hartley gave Adam light and exceptance...brought Adam into reality and not just hiding in the darkness without hope.

  • Kate S - 3 years ago

    Michael Muhney is the best Adam Newman. He made me love Adam, his chemistry with Melissa Claire Egan and both their talent is what made me love Adam and Chelsea and he brought me back to Y&R in 2011 when I stopped watching after Colleen was killed off. I was very sad when he was let go and while I do like Justin Hartley, I will choose Michael Muhney as Adam every time.

  • Judy Williams - 3 years ago

    Micheal Muhney is Adam. Bring him home. We fought for him when he left and we will fight for him to return. He's perfect to take over the lead when Victor leaves like Mrs. C.

  • Dinah S - 3 years ago

    Michael Muhney is the one that most of us all love. He also had good chemistry with Chelsea (Melissa). He was a stronger Adam, i thought. Justin was a good substitute but if he is not available now so then a fulltime Adam would be much better. I love the Adam character, he shakes thing up at Y&R. Its boring without him.

  • Linda Naylor - 3 years ago

    Bring the real Adam back Michael Muhney

  • Linda Naylor - 3 years ago

    Bring the real Adam back Michael Muhney

  • Linda Naylor - 3 years ago

    Bring the real Adam back Michael muhney

  • TONYA DAVIS-WHITE - 3 years ago

    Micheal already established chemistry and Justin we got use to. I'll take either one but I love Micheal. And I want my Adam back.

  • Loislane - 3 years ago

    ʍɨċɦaɛʟ sucks

  • Nancy Montalvo - 3 years ago

    Please bring Justin back!!!! Full-time. ALIVE!!! Not as a ghost.Sorry, Michael just would not have the chemistry and charisma as Justin.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars

Submit Comment