Dickey was best deal, Morton farts too much and colon is a butterball.
Jake - 7 years ago
Best signings in terms of value
1. Chavez: least amount of money, was very effective in Oakland 2 and 3 years ago.
2. Colon: large amount of money but only a one year contract and in my opinion he's the best pitcher on this list for a one year deal
3. Dickey: eats innings. Wouldnt have given him as much money as Chavez
4. Hellickson: is honestly not as good as Colon but has a much brighter future. His results are so shaky I don't have a whole lot of confidence in him
5. Cashner: could turn out to be the best value. But Texas is a hitter friendly park and he hasn't put a solid season together since 2014. Potential is there but I don't trust him
6. Morton: he's always hurt and you give him a 2 year deal? 14 mil isn't a whole lot nowadays but I would rather have Neshek in the pen (they traded him and his option to cut 6.5 mil payroll or 2 mil buyout)
Jay Fan - 7 years ago
R.A. was undervalued in Toronto. Not his fault he was traded for Syndergaard. Innings eater.
Dickey was best deal, Morton farts too much and colon is a butterball.
Best signings in terms of value
1. Chavez: least amount of money, was very effective in Oakland 2 and 3 years ago.
2. Colon: large amount of money but only a one year contract and in my opinion he's the best pitcher on this list for a one year deal
3. Dickey: eats innings. Wouldnt have given him as much money as Chavez
4. Hellickson: is honestly not as good as Colon but has a much brighter future. His results are so shaky I don't have a whole lot of confidence in him
5. Cashner: could turn out to be the best value. But Texas is a hitter friendly park and he hasn't put a solid season together since 2014. Potential is there but I don't trust him
6. Morton: he's always hurt and you give him a 2 year deal? 14 mil isn't a whole lot nowadays but I would rather have Neshek in the pen (they traded him and his option to cut 6.5 mil payroll or 2 mil buyout)
R.A. was undervalued in Toronto. Not his fault he was traded for Syndergaard. Innings eater.