What a bunch of selfish losers. I would gladly trade your citizenship and hand it over to those less fortunate. You people can live in fear and let your hate destroy you. Trump would step over your lifeless body for a nickel and you all feel like he has your back. You would kick out a child because you are mad you have to "prest 1" for english. I am an American born and raised...my great grandparents came from Italy legally for opportunity and the ability to provide a better life for their children and generations to come. I have no doubt that they would have swam, walked, or crawled into the US, legally or illegally for a chance. You are self righteous, self serving, selfish people and I am ashamed to live in the same community as you. Aside from electing a complete moron to president, I am most bothered by the realization that half of you are such pieces of sh*t. I am not some whiney liberal...I hate politics. I base my views on what is right, not out of fear, hate, or because of political party lines. Easy to cast stones when nobody is threatening your freedom....but wat long enough....your turn is coming.
Case Hardened - 10 years ago
It is amazing to view the Liberal's Bigotry.
The SWJ simply cannot believe that "People of Color" are capable of creating beautiful, functioning societies.
No. These "unfortunates" must be "saved" by incorporating them into Majority White, Western Secular Countries. To send them home is a death sentence.
Actually, it isn't.
The overwhelming evidence shows the polar opposite. The illegal immigrant IS perfectly functional, and pleased with their culture. They proudly display flags of their origin, and learn only enough English to survive (which is often very little, indeed). They despite your language, your flag, your president, your bigotry.
SMJ - the Illegal wants only one thing from you - YOUR MONEY.
Frank L'Heureux - 10 years ago
2-7-17
City Council
Salem City Hall, 93 Washington Street, Salem, MA 01970
978-745-9595
Dear Council, I am writing today to express my opposition to the proposed city ordinance to make Salem a" Sanctuary City".
First of all, I don't believe it is necessary to denote or label our city as a "Sanctuary City" Salem is a progressive and compassionate city already.
Creating this ordinance and putting our federal funding at risk is a mistake and completely unnecessary.
It is essentially imposing a defiance tax on the local residence.
The Mayor said in an article in the Boston Globe February 5th 2017 she does not believe The Presidents order would jeopardize Salem's Federal funding. That is just not good enough.
Those funds I am sure would be and can be put to good use for our city and our citizens.
I don't think it is fair to risk that funding and potentially higher taxes to replace that funding for a group of people who essentially broke the law and cut in line to get here. We are already supporting illegal aliens in countless ways, but we need to draw the line somewhere.
Frank L'Heureux
Shirley Marescalchi - 10 years ago
As soon as our Vets and homeless that are here have a system in place that serves them well . These Americans needs have to be better met first for programs to be successful for all.
George Coelho - 10 years ago
It must be wonderful to be a politician and see everything through rose colored glasses. Sure, no human being is illegal, but there are millions here illegally, why is that so hard to understand? They broke the law, send them all back. How many more should we allow to come here? When will our Liberal leaders be satisfied? At 20 million? 30 million? Generally, as a country, we have been raising our kids to be delicate little snowflakes, full of love and good feelings , like gentle little lambs, and that would be wonderful if the whole world was like that but, it's not. The countries that the majority of these people come from, have no lambs, only wolves and, as soon as we become a minority, the slaughter will begin. As I look around Salem and the surrounding towns, I don't see any immigrants trying to assimilate to our language and our customs, only the other way around. We have to give them our hard earned money, provide them with translators, all kinds of signage in their native language, when does it end? These people offer very little to society and take an enormous amount from us. Had you told me 27 years ago, when I bought my home in Salem that I would have to drive and walk on filthy streets and sidewalks and be forced to live among drug dealers and trash pickers I think I would have picked a little more carefully.
Christina - 10 years ago
Natalie's comment says it well:
"In the history of immigration, millions of people came to our country and followed proper procedure to become legal citizens. It is so unfair to them to allow or protect people who are here illegally and are given benefits that should be only for citizens.
Think about immigration to this country in the early years and what people had to go through and how they were treated in the process of becoming citizens. It is an insult to them to allow people to live here without going through the now civil and humane process to become a U.S. citizen. We are a country of immigrants but there are laws about for becoming a citizen and those laws need to be followed."
T.W. Knoll - 10 years ago
Obviously, $1o,ooo,ooo is a lot of money. A lot of zeros there. But the proposal does not threaten that money. In affect, what this proposal does is state clearly where we stand as a city on the issue of immigration. It says that we are going to do good for our fellow man and give them a chance. It says that we will not assume based on ethnicity that so and so is a criminal. And (what is most important to some) it says this without jeopardizing our federal funding. In fact it says this while hardly chsnging anything at all. This is the middle ground; as of now the fact that the poll is nearly tied is evidence of that.
Open but cautious arms are better than either extreme.
JBostick - 10 years ago
It's clear that the decanters here haven't even read the ordinance and are reacting based on pure bias with no facts to back up their opinions. If you read the proposed ordinance it's very clear.
No provision of the proposed ordinance will violate Federal or State law, nor impact Federal or State funding.
No provision of the proposed ordinance will obstruct immigration enforcement or prohibit cooperation among law enforcement agencies.
Do your homework.
Robyn - 10 years ago
Seems there are some misconceptions about Sanctuary Cities in this chain of comments. The ordinance doesn't change any of our immigration laws - what it does is take a stance that the police won't require papers for people who haven't committed a crime. For example, if someone goes to the police station to report domestic abuse or a theft in their neighborhood, they can do so without the police asking to prove they live here legally. It also requires that children in our schools don't have to provide papers to attend schools. Many people who live here illegally ARE working and ARE paying taxes. They don't get to depend on social security down the road and certainly aren't claiming their tax returns - so that's all to your benefit. Also, study after study has proven that because the entire community can trust the police, there is much less crime - people are less likely to try to handle scary situations on their own without calling the police, and are less likely to ignore scary things (like theft, violence, or domestic abuse).
Don Nadeau - 10 years ago
Wow. I see the national propaganda machine is misdirecting and demonizing effectively again. Another witch hunt. Will we ever learn? No, obviously, no. More innocent deaths on our hands. And, yes, this national pogrom kills. It kills the children and the already-exploited "under-the-table" poor. Who's using who? Where do most US taxes go? Who are the biggest tax cheats? Please find all the facts (which takes real research and critical thinking) before demonizing a convenient lump of poor folk who have very little recourse, like many tyrannical regimes have done and still do. My ancestors were persecuted in this very city with the same arguments during the filthy industrial revolution. We do need to grow up. So grow up and stop blaming the weakest.
Georgio Adonis - 10 years ago
The Navy Seal that was just killed in combat for our freedoms is already rolling in his grave. Treasonous Salem officials I'm sure never served a day in uniform. Mass will go red also because of you morons continue to triple down on a lost anti tax payer/ Anti-American ideology...2018 will mark the death of the diseased Senate, it's going all red because of your unpatriotic , spit in the faces of tax payer's religion.
Natalie - 10 years ago
In the history of immigration, millions of people came to our country and followed proper procedure to become legal citizens. It is so unfair to them to allow or protect people who are here illegally and are given benefits that should be only for citizens.
Think about immigration to this country in the early years and what people had to go through and how they were treated in the process of becoming citizens. It is an insult to them to allow people to live here without going through the now civil and humane process to become a U.S. citizen. We are a country of immigrants but there are laws about for becoming a citizen and those laws need to be followed.
Susan Piaggio - 10 years ago
Salem residents pay a lot in taxes to live here. Making our city a sanctuary city sounds wonderful but I feel that our taxes will only continue to rise if this should happen. Thank you for allowing me to voice my opinion.
Phil hanson - 10 years ago
I wishci could cherry pick which laws i decide to follow. If someone 1st act coming here is to snub their nose to the law then how many other laws are they going to ignore? Driving illegally with no insurance, working under the table and not paying into the system, more kids in. An already terrible school system, cops who are already stretched too thin. The city just cant afford this. Besides. Its already too crowded here. I cant believe that we are even having this discussion. It is a feel good legislation which does nothing for the tax paying base. If it goes forward i will be taking my income, and moving my business elsewhere.
Melissa Mastrianni - 10 years ago
If you think it is worth it to break the law, AND kill your tourism, AND lose most of your tax paying residents, AND lose tax payer funding, all for some ridiculous ideology of white guilt and liberalism, then be my guess, but I'm telling you, you will regret it. You better think about it long and hard, because once the money is gone, and you have to constantly raise taxes, and your tax and tourist base leaves, all you will be left with are a bunch of ungrateful people who destroy your city and use you for every last drop they can get out of you. Take a good look at some other sanctuaries cities first, like San Fran, amd ask yourself if you want that. Fools. And also, ask yourself if it's worth gettnig Voted out of office.
Sharon Shea - 10 years ago
How people have been wound up to fear illegals is astonishing. US citizens are at risk from drug abuise, car accidents, lack of health care, their own reckless desisions, you name it. People have certaiinly been sidetracked into worrying abou the wrong issues.
Paul Finn - 10 years ago
Kate Steinle and Matthew Denice's (and countless other American's) preventable and brutal killings by ILLEGAL aliens in this country is all you need to know when answering this question. I wish politicians had as much passion towards defending the American people as they do to defend the ILLEGAL population. Right now there are two sets of laws, one for law-abiding tax payers and the other for illegal aliens.
Griselda Blanco - 10 years ago
Human beings are not illegal. And no one is asking you to 'pay' for anything. What they are asking for is to be treated with respect and dignity as human beings. Our country has been a home to immigrants through every generation.
Sheila Murphy - 10 years ago
No, tax payers should not have to pay for undocumented persons in our country. Deport them. They are breaking the law!
Brenda Horowitz - 10 years ago
Any politician that thinks their city should be a sanctuary to ILLEGAL ALIENS should be put in prison for treason!!!!!!!!!
What a bunch of selfish losers. I would gladly trade your citizenship and hand it over to those less fortunate. You people can live in fear and let your hate destroy you. Trump would step over your lifeless body for a nickel and you all feel like he has your back. You would kick out a child because you are mad you have to "prest 1" for english. I am an American born and raised...my great grandparents came from Italy legally for opportunity and the ability to provide a better life for their children and generations to come. I have no doubt that they would have swam, walked, or crawled into the US, legally or illegally for a chance. You are self righteous, self serving, selfish people and I am ashamed to live in the same community as you. Aside from electing a complete moron to president, I am most bothered by the realization that half of you are such pieces of sh*t. I am not some whiney liberal...I hate politics. I base my views on what is right, not out of fear, hate, or because of political party lines. Easy to cast stones when nobody is threatening your freedom....but wat long enough....your turn is coming.
It is amazing to view the Liberal's Bigotry.
The SWJ simply cannot believe that "People of Color" are capable of creating beautiful, functioning societies.
No. These "unfortunates" must be "saved" by incorporating them into Majority White, Western Secular Countries. To send them home is a death sentence.
Actually, it isn't.
The overwhelming evidence shows the polar opposite. The illegal immigrant IS perfectly functional, and pleased with their culture. They proudly display flags of their origin, and learn only enough English to survive (which is often very little, indeed). They despite your language, your flag, your president, your bigotry.
SMJ - the Illegal wants only one thing from you - YOUR MONEY.
2-7-17
City Council
Salem City Hall, 93 Washington Street, Salem, MA 01970
978-745-9595
Dear Council, I am writing today to express my opposition to the proposed city ordinance to make Salem a" Sanctuary City".
First of all, I don't believe it is necessary to denote or label our city as a "Sanctuary City" Salem is a progressive and compassionate city already.
Creating this ordinance and putting our federal funding at risk is a mistake and completely unnecessary.
It is essentially imposing a defiance tax on the local residence.
The Mayor said in an article in the Boston Globe February 5th 2017 she does not believe The Presidents order would jeopardize Salem's Federal funding. That is just not good enough.
Those funds I am sure would be and can be put to good use for our city and our citizens.
I don't think it is fair to risk that funding and potentially higher taxes to replace that funding for a group of people who essentially broke the law and cut in line to get here. We are already supporting illegal aliens in countless ways, but we need to draw the line somewhere.
Frank L'Heureux
As soon as our Vets and homeless that are here have a system in place that serves them well . These Americans needs have to be better met first for programs to be successful for all.
It must be wonderful to be a politician and see everything through rose colored glasses. Sure, no human being is illegal, but there are millions here illegally, why is that so hard to understand? They broke the law, send them all back. How many more should we allow to come here? When will our Liberal leaders be satisfied? At 20 million? 30 million? Generally, as a country, we have been raising our kids to be delicate little snowflakes, full of love and good feelings , like gentle little lambs, and that would be wonderful if the whole world was like that but, it's not. The countries that the majority of these people come from, have no lambs, only wolves and, as soon as we become a minority, the slaughter will begin. As I look around Salem and the surrounding towns, I don't see any immigrants trying to assimilate to our language and our customs, only the other way around. We have to give them our hard earned money, provide them with translators, all kinds of signage in their native language, when does it end? These people offer very little to society and take an enormous amount from us. Had you told me 27 years ago, when I bought my home in Salem that I would have to drive and walk on filthy streets and sidewalks and be forced to live among drug dealers and trash pickers I think I would have picked a little more carefully.
Natalie's comment says it well:
"In the history of immigration, millions of people came to our country and followed proper procedure to become legal citizens. It is so unfair to them to allow or protect people who are here illegally and are given benefits that should be only for citizens.
Think about immigration to this country in the early years and what people had to go through and how they were treated in the process of becoming citizens. It is an insult to them to allow people to live here without going through the now civil and humane process to become a U.S. citizen. We are a country of immigrants but there are laws about for becoming a citizen and those laws need to be followed."
Obviously, $1o,ooo,ooo is a lot of money. A lot of zeros there. But the proposal does not threaten that money. In affect, what this proposal does is state clearly where we stand as a city on the issue of immigration. It says that we are going to do good for our fellow man and give them a chance. It says that we will not assume based on ethnicity that so and so is a criminal. And (what is most important to some) it says this without jeopardizing our federal funding. In fact it says this while hardly chsnging anything at all. This is the middle ground; as of now the fact that the poll is nearly tied is evidence of that.
Open but cautious arms are better than either extreme.
It's clear that the decanters here haven't even read the ordinance and are reacting based on pure bias with no facts to back up their opinions. If you read the proposed ordinance it's very clear.
No provision of the proposed ordinance will violate Federal or State law, nor impact Federal or State funding.
No provision of the proposed ordinance will obstruct immigration enforcement or prohibit cooperation among law enforcement agencies.
Do your homework.
Seems there are some misconceptions about Sanctuary Cities in this chain of comments. The ordinance doesn't change any of our immigration laws - what it does is take a stance that the police won't require papers for people who haven't committed a crime. For example, if someone goes to the police station to report domestic abuse or a theft in their neighborhood, they can do so without the police asking to prove they live here legally. It also requires that children in our schools don't have to provide papers to attend schools. Many people who live here illegally ARE working and ARE paying taxes. They don't get to depend on social security down the road and certainly aren't claiming their tax returns - so that's all to your benefit. Also, study after study has proven that because the entire community can trust the police, there is much less crime - people are less likely to try to handle scary situations on their own without calling the police, and are less likely to ignore scary things (like theft, violence, or domestic abuse).
Wow. I see the national propaganda machine is misdirecting and demonizing effectively again. Another witch hunt. Will we ever learn? No, obviously, no. More innocent deaths on our hands. And, yes, this national pogrom kills. It kills the children and the already-exploited "under-the-table" poor. Who's using who? Where do most US taxes go? Who are the biggest tax cheats? Please find all the facts (which takes real research and critical thinking) before demonizing a convenient lump of poor folk who have very little recourse, like many tyrannical regimes have done and still do. My ancestors were persecuted in this very city with the same arguments during the filthy industrial revolution. We do need to grow up. So grow up and stop blaming the weakest.
The Navy Seal that was just killed in combat for our freedoms is already rolling in his grave. Treasonous Salem officials I'm sure never served a day in uniform. Mass will go red also because of you morons continue to triple down on a lost anti tax payer/ Anti-American ideology...2018 will mark the death of the diseased Senate, it's going all red because of your unpatriotic , spit in the faces of tax payer's religion.
In the history of immigration, millions of people came to our country and followed proper procedure to become legal citizens. It is so unfair to them to allow or protect people who are here illegally and are given benefits that should be only for citizens.
Think about immigration to this country in the early years and what people had to go through and how they were treated in the process of becoming citizens. It is an insult to them to allow people to live here without going through the now civil and humane process to become a U.S. citizen. We are a country of immigrants but there are laws about for becoming a citizen and those laws need to be followed.
Salem residents pay a lot in taxes to live here. Making our city a sanctuary city sounds wonderful but I feel that our taxes will only continue to rise if this should happen. Thank you for allowing me to voice my opinion.
I wishci could cherry pick which laws i decide to follow. If someone 1st act coming here is to snub their nose to the law then how many other laws are they going to ignore? Driving illegally with no insurance, working under the table and not paying into the system, more kids in. An already terrible school system, cops who are already stretched too thin. The city just cant afford this. Besides. Its already too crowded here. I cant believe that we are even having this discussion. It is a feel good legislation which does nothing for the tax paying base. If it goes forward i will be taking my income, and moving my business elsewhere.
If you think it is worth it to break the law, AND kill your tourism, AND lose most of your tax paying residents, AND lose tax payer funding, all for some ridiculous ideology of white guilt and liberalism, then be my guess, but I'm telling you, you will regret it. You better think about it long and hard, because once the money is gone, and you have to constantly raise taxes, and your tax and tourist base leaves, all you will be left with are a bunch of ungrateful people who destroy your city and use you for every last drop they can get out of you. Take a good look at some other sanctuaries cities first, like San Fran, amd ask yourself if you want that. Fools. And also, ask yourself if it's worth gettnig Voted out of office.
How people have been wound up to fear illegals is astonishing. US citizens are at risk from drug abuise, car accidents, lack of health care, their own reckless desisions, you name it. People have certaiinly been sidetracked into worrying abou the wrong issues.
Kate Steinle and Matthew Denice's (and countless other American's) preventable and brutal killings by ILLEGAL aliens in this country is all you need to know when answering this question. I wish politicians had as much passion towards defending the American people as they do to defend the ILLEGAL population. Right now there are two sets of laws, one for law-abiding tax payers and the other for illegal aliens.
Human beings are not illegal. And no one is asking you to 'pay' for anything. What they are asking for is to be treated with respect and dignity as human beings. Our country has been a home to immigrants through every generation.
No, tax payers should not have to pay for undocumented persons in our country. Deport them. They are breaking the law!
Any politician that thinks their city should be a sanctuary to ILLEGAL ALIENS should be put in prison for treason!!!!!!!!!
Vote Trump 2020