The paper in the first one is beautiful, and I probably prefer it over the Ikat, but to me the first option as is is just too busy.
They both are beautiful ..either one would be wonderful but to me No. 2 is "beyond smashing!"
I totally agree with Frannie above. LOVE the Pierre Frey wallpaper, and think the chairs from number 1 would be perfect!!!
I like foyer 2. But you should swap out the chairs and put the foyer 1 chairs in it .
Sometimes I struggle with Ikat because it can appear chaotic and busy. In this case I think the soft lines of mood board 1 are much softer, smoother and welcoming than mood board 2.