Which designer SHOULD have won 'Project Runway'?

12 Comments

  • Sara - 4 years ago

    I think the judges got it right, except I would have sent Ayana home instead of Kenya. I think her looks were mostly awful except the last dress. The fashion show is supposed to be fantasy and then they can create ready to wear looks from those ideas. Kentaro and Brandon were obviously the best designers this season, they had fresh new ideas and really collaborated well. As for the twins, they usually designed what one of the twins wore the previous day, in the model challenge she actually asked for the person at mood to find the lace she was already wearing. I also thought that Ayana had a really high opinion of herself, too high. And I don't think Tim should have wasted his save on Margarita (if she wants to design only for the Caribbean or Miami, she should go there). He would have been able to save Kenya who really deserved it...

  • Donna Peterson - 6 years ago

    I love Project Runway and Tim but the last few seasons it has gone down hill I think. They came down on the twins for always helping each other and breaking the rules. Yet they refer to Brandon & Kentaro the dream team. How unfair for the Judges to pick out designers and call them The Dream Team. You know from day one who will win at the end. As far as Kontaro winning he should of never been in the final. Can't picture a full figure women wearing one of those red dresses. Kenya should of made it to the final instead of Kontaro, her designs were better fitted to the bodies of all women. She might of not won but her clothes would of sold at JC Penny's.. If I had to choose a winner it would of been Ayana, I don't like the head coverings but there are a lot of women would. Her fashions were suited for most body shapes, she did a great job. Margarita was a close second.

  • Maggie Genius - 6 years ago

    When they showed the winning collections from previous seasons, what went down the runway last night looked like Project Runway Junior. So disappointed in the judges. Wasn't there a black tulle pregnant bump earlier in the season that almost got the designer kicked off? Suddenly, at the final runway the judges couldn't get enough "love,love" out of their mouths. I've been waiting all season for someone to tell Brandon (who is too cute to insult), same song, second dance. If he had been given better direction weeks ago, he might have stepped away with the prize. The fact that he let the same basic outfits walk across the stage week after week to rave reviews was a disservice to his talent. And his "brother" should thank him for helping to tweak his outfits. No uproar over that help because everyone thought it was cute. Not like the twins who would make me gag. What joy when they left. How many times did they make outfits from trash? Using caution tape is not designing, it's repurposing. Present baskets of leftover fabric from a sewing co-operative. Designs would be representative of wearable outfits. Imagine a Red Carpet design from baskets of scraps. Project Runway, you are off the track. While I used to watch the show for ideas, I now watch it as I would a soap opera or tacky reality television. Bring back the glamour and real creativity.

  • Cindy P - 6 years ago

    Ayana's collection looked the walk, especially for JCPenney! Her wedding gown was to die for. I shop JCP's and cannot imagine Kataro's collection there! Who would wear it and where will they be going in those odd pueces??? The only one I liked was the black/white pants.

    I am usually disappointed every year with the shows winner. I do not get their decision!

  • Cindy P - 6 years ago

    Ayana's collection looked the walk, especially for JCPenney! Her wedding gown was to die for. I shop JCP's and cannot imagine Kataro's collection there! Who would wear it and where will they be going in those odd pueces??? The only one I liked was the black/white pants.

  • Susie Anne - 6 years ago

    I, too, thought Kentaro shouldn't have won. I really liked Margarita's collection, because it sparked Latino fashion. She did, along with Anya create beautiful wearable fashions. Brandon was awesome too. The judges forgot about JC Penney. I adored Anya's gown...so gorgeous. They all should have their fashion.out there.

  • Jane Roberson - 6 years ago

    I was so appalled that Kentero won! The judges definitely must have had their heads caught up in that first look he sent out not to mention some of the others... good grief! Seriously Margarita’s was way better than his. Ayana even had him beat. I realize this is in New York, and they wear some “odd” styles up there, but Lordy mercy, I realize this is in New York, and they wear some “odd“ styles up there, but Lordy mercy! I do believe the show was rigged to begin with. I did not see one thing that the winner sent out that I would have purchased at a Goodwill store much less JCPenney‘s. You know what they say, opinions are like a holes we all have one. He definitely did not deserve to win, not on the garbage he designed for the finale!

  • Marco - 6 years ago

    I, like Brandon, and shocked he did not win. Even though he didn't have the showstoppers like Kentaro and Ayana, his collection, like all season, was the most cohesive. Kentaro and Ayana had some (not many) bad pieces, and I think that's why Brandon should have won.

  • Nancy - 6 years ago

    Very disappointed in the judges. The winner was the worse collection. No body who shops at JCPENNY will by those clothes.

  • D - 6 years ago

    What? I don’t see what Hedi sees. Kentoro should of been the first out of the 4 to be let go, not the winner. This show is rigged

  • Bobbbie - 6 years ago

    Can't believe it!! Where was the judges minds, the winning look was so boring. All he knows is black and white and although he said it was based on his culture, I saw none in the look.

  • Debbie Christy - 6 years ago

    Won't be watching this show any more, they pick the worse for project 16 that collection was horrible.

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment