192 Comments

  • Jenn - 16 hours ago

    One tree hill

  • Royce Khan - 20 hours ago

    Smallville all the way...

  • Jeremy Bys - 22 hours ago

    Smallville

  • Loune - 23 hours ago

    OTH all the way!!!!!

  • Carl - yesterday

    Smallville…hands down

  • Scott Hughes - yesterday

    Smallville

  • Steena Petersen - yesterday

    Smallville definitely worked in the film and television industry for 20 years I know what I'm talking about..lol

  • Junior wellington - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Britt bass - 2 days ago

    Oth ( one tree hill) all the way!

  • Kathryn - 2 days ago

    One Tree Hill.

  • Unnati - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Luke - 2 days ago

    Smallville ALWAYS. NO COMPETITION

  • Josh - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • julie c - 2 days ago

    Smallville..

  • Jamie Thomasson - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Emily - 2 days ago

    One tree hill baby!!!

  • Kaya - 2 days ago

    One tree hill - love you Naley!!!

  • Jenny - 2 days ago

    Without a doubt, One Tree Hill.

  • Miranda - 2 days ago

    One tree hill

  • Chris C - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Adam Perry - 2 days ago

    Smallville!

  • Crystal Wells - 2 days ago

    One Tree Hill???? There is no debate! Best Show! I still bing watch all the time❣????????

  • Me - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Gabe - 2 days ago

    Smallville

  • Ben - 3 days ago

    Smallville

  • Beatriz Valle - 3 days ago

    One Tree Hill for sure

  • Elvin Rivera - 3 days ago

    Smallville all the way!!!!

  • Christa Schmidt - 3 days ago

    OTH all the way!!!

  • H. Conlon - 3 days ago

    One Tree Hill

  • Samdon - 3 days ago

    Smallville

  • Nadia - 3 days ago

    “I used to be a bit of a b*tch just for the sake of being one, but now I am a b*tch for the sake of my friends and family. You do not want to test that!” — Brooke Davis

    “Happiness is not a destination. It is a mood, it is not permanent. It comes and goes and if people thought that way then maybe people would find happiness more often.” — Julian Baker

    “At this moment there are 6,470,818,671 people in the world. Some are running scared. Some are coming home. Some tell lies to make it through the day. Others are just now facing the truth. Some are evil men, at war with good. And some are good, struggling with evil. Six billion people in the world. Six billion souls. And sometimes — all you need is one.” — Peyton Sawyer

  • Hanna - 3 days ago

    “The hardest part of saying goodbye is having to do it again every single day.” — Lucas Scott

    “I’ve come to the conclusion that if having things turn out the way you wanted them to is a measure of a successful life, then some would say I’m a failure.” — Coach Whitey Durham

    I did two quotes for OTH because I wanted to

  • Siena Forde - 3 days ago

    I voted oth for B Davis, but if I’m being honest I’d rather watch smallville. It’s less painful, because the stuff I wanted to happen happens.
    Not a cw show but the o.c is better than/on the same level as most of these.
    Also I doubt oth, smallville, or supernatural will win. Not because they aren’t the best, but cause tvd’s fan base is huge and will most likely win by default.

  • Gab - 3 days ago

    Sorry can’t use Gabby but I meant to say my vote is One Tree Hill

  • Gabby - 3 days ago

    “There’s a day when you realize that you’re not just a survivor, you’re a warrior. You’re tougher than anything life throws your way.” — Brooke Davis. One Tree Hill is vote for this round and Brooke is right

  • Fiona - 3 days ago

    “The world is full of magic. You just have to believe in it. So make your wish. Do you have it? Good. Now believe in it with all your heart.” — One Tree Hill cast. One Tree Hill is gonna win!!!

  • Danielle H - 3 days ago

    OTH all the way best show ever!!!!!!

  • Kylie - 3 days ago

    “Some people believe that ravens guide travelers to their destinations. Others believe that the sight of a solitary raven is considered good luck, while more than one raven together predicts trouble ahead.” — Peyton Sawyer OTH baby!!!

  • Jenna M - 3 days ago

    If you don’t vote OTH you can Brooke yourself.

    I don't need to be anything other
    Than a prison guard's son
    I don't need to be anything other
    Than a specialist's son

  • Ar - 3 days ago

    Smallville definitely

  • Madison - 3 days ago

    It’s game over One Tree Hill wins!!!! Sorry but you gotta look at the comments so why try anymore when you know Smallville is gonna lose but ok whatever just try I guess. OTH sorry it’s the best show

  • Thomas Giguere - 3 days ago

    Smallville without a doubt.

  • Cindy - 3 days ago

    Love both shows but gotta go OTH all.the way

  • Emma - 3 days ago

    OTH 100% “I will always protect you.” -Nathan Scott. One Tree Hill teaches very good lessons that you might need in life. “Don’t get married in high school.” Nathan is right don’t do that because you should wait till you are out of high school or at least College so OTH teaches you to not pull a Naley and get married in high school so I’m going with OTH because it teaches Valuable life lessons that we all need in life

  • Robyn - 3 days ago

    ONE TREE HILL!

  • Vannie - 3 days ago

    One Tree Hill has the most comments so it’s over but let me tell you this it won’t beat Supernatural plus in order for Smallville to get the final 2 it has to beat TVD and look what happened to the flash when they were up against TVD. OTH wins according to the comments

  • Star - 3 days ago

    Smallville 100%.

  • Elissa - 3 days ago

    One Tree Hill is my vote but it won’t win against Supernatural because look at Batwoman and Dc’s legends of tomorrow they lost to Supernatural but what makes you all so sure TVD won’t beat Smallville because they TVD did beat the flash which I find a shocking so it turns out drama shows can beat superhero shows I guess and that’s because I think people watch more drama shows than superhero shows or they did the past

  • Davina - 3 days ago

    I vote OTH but Jessica is right no matter what show wins this round won’t beat Supernatural because it’s the longest running show over Arrow, TVD, and OTH even Smallville too. Yes Arrow ended a year before Supernatural did but Arrow has 8 seasons and Supernatural has 15. Smallville ain’t gonna beat Supernatural so pretty nobody stands a chance against them unless somehow Arrow fans pull something and get Arrow to win but I don’t think they will seriously if you wanna be petty and butthurt than you go Brooke yourself

  • Courtney - 3 days ago

    Some drama aren’t show as bad as they seem and One Tree Hill is one that isn’t bad. How can you say a show is bad if you haven’t seen it trust me I never watched it before now and this is because I was a kid when the show was on so I couldn’t watch it because my mom would never let me

  • Cody - 3 days ago

    “People are always gonna label you.” OTH teaches you good life lessons probably a lot more than any show ever will so my vote One Tree Hill sorry

  • Clary - 3 days ago

    Always and forever is Naleys aka Nathan and Haley’s saying. OTH fan here and it’s the best show ever sorry Smallville but you go Brooke yourselves

  • David h - 3 days ago

    Smallville is best show hands down, groundbreaking special effects. Smallville also paved the road for shows like arrow and the flash.!

  • T - 3 days ago

    somebody save meeeeeee

  • martin - 3 days ago

    somebody save me

  • Alex - 3 days ago

    I feel my wings have broken in your hands

  • smallville pakistan - 3 days ago

    No tv show can beat smallville!

  • khulaid jamal - 3 days ago

    Smallville.... the best show ever

  • khulaid jamal - 3 days ago

    Always hold on to smallville

  • Jami - 3 days ago

    SMALLVILLE!

  • Jessica - 3 days ago

    OTH fan here, but also a smallville fan. I’m voting OTH because of a connection I feel with the show, but I see a lot of petty bickering on here and just want to point out to both sides, it doesn’t really matter because eventually it’s paired with Supernatural at the end and that’s game over for any other show ????

  • T - 3 days ago

    Somebody save me!

  • J - 3 days ago

    People using 'always and forever' when voting for oth nonsense.. Can't even come up with something original? What a pathetic show oth must be. What a shame.

  • Matt - 3 days ago

    I love both shows - but ONE TREE HILL is hands down the best TV show of ALL TIME!

  • Jamie - 3 days ago

    Smallville

  • Katie - 3 days ago

    OTH is the bomb diggity baby!!!! Always & forever!! ❤❤❤

  • Tim Costello - 3 days ago

    Always Hold On to Smallville!!!

  • KL - 3 days ago

    Love Smallville

  • Abob - 3 days ago

    SMALLVILLE

  • Clarissa aka Vanessa - 3 days ago

    “Maybe cause you looked like that.” -Rachel Gatina

    I’m so sorry for that and if it sounded rude oops but Rachel truly said that if don’t believe me it’s in Season 4 Episode 9 of One Tree Hill

  • John - 3 days ago

    Isn't changing names fun. One tree hills highest viewed season garnered less views than and of the first five seasons of smallville. Smallville won numerous Emmys, Leo, Saturn, and teen choice awards while OTH only ever won three teen choice awards. Not to mention that Smallville ran for a full season longer, as well as had 30 more episodes and never had to rely on a time jump gimmick to keep the show from being canceled. The show was continued in comic form and the characters were just brought in live action due to overwhelming fan demand. Don't worry, put as many votes in as you want Carol/Carlee/Carily/Cassidy/Brie/Bree no one is going to care that OTH beat out Smallville in one online poll because you stuffed the ballot box, the legacies for both of these shows were written long ago lol

  • Claire - 3 days ago

    “This is so Naley.” -Brooke Davis sorry I just had to but I say go OTH sorry

  • Jennifer - 3 days ago

    I love both but I have to go with Smallville

  • Cheryl P - 3 days ago

    You can’t control other’s opinions but OTH is winning baby

  • Cheryl - 3 days ago

    Sorry but according to the comments OTH is winning but I voted OTH anyways. For the ones aren’t expressing their opinions but getting butthurt that your show ain’t winning. You can control other’s opinions. OTH for the win baby!!!!!

  • Cece - 3 days ago

    It’s better than Riverdale right now tbh because frankly with Riverdale idk even know wtf I’m watching. They just did the Riverdale time jump wrong at least for OTH’s time jump the main couple Naley was still together even tho things were kinda rocky for them.

  • Joey - 3 days ago

    So the options are a literal genre defining series that laid the groundwork for the creation of the marvel cinematic universe which directly lead to other cinematic unvierses and defined superhero television everywhere with a format that still is copied to this day. Or a run of the mill teen high school/early 20s drama? Somehow I feel like the drama is gonna win from someone who had a ship spamming ????‍♂️

  • Cassidy - 3 days ago

    OTH!!!! Naley’s love is stronger than you think

  • Casey - 3 days ago

    OTH baby!!!! Naley will always be the couple we all wanted to be.

  • Nick - 3 days ago

    Based on the comments oth is gonna win, but I will still try because in my opinion smallville is the best series I have watched.

  • Carol - 3 days ago

    Biggest Naley shipper here so OTH baby

  • Carliee - 3 days ago

    Rachel Gatina is played by Jensen Ackles’ wife Daanel *I think I spelled her name wrong sorry* Ackles but she has her maiden name still because they weren’t married when she did OTH. One Tree Hill all the way baby

  • Carlee - 3 days ago

    OTH has this sorry Smallville fans but I think OTH is winning so you can try all you want

  • Kyle - 3 days ago

    Smallville for the WIN!! This show made my childhood and my love for superman and superheros what it is is today!

  • Candace - 3 days ago

    Seriously go Brooke yourselves

  • Boo - 3 days ago

    Come on OTH fans we got this!!!! Sorry OTH is the best show ever.

  • Tomas candelaria Jr - 3 days ago

    Smallville hands down.

  • Bubbles - 3 days ago

    OTH!!!! I would love a Next Generation tbh and we never did get to meet Mouth and Millies children or child so deserve that at least

  • Pee jay - 3 days ago

    Smallville for me. It won't reach 10 seasons if its not worth watching... We even wanted a seasonn 11 if it was possible. ????

  • Eddie Sanchez - 3 days ago

    Smallville is my choice the beat show hands down.

  • Brie - 3 days ago

    Let’s go OTH!!!!!! “Go Brooke yourself.”

  • Julz - 3 days ago

    First of all you don’t know me. Second of all you don’t know me.
    Go OTH!!

  • Bree - 3 days ago

    OTH is the best!!!!!! I must say as a Riverdale fan it’s better than Riverdale tbh

  • Bonnie - 3 days ago

    OTH for the win baby!!!!!!!! It’s the best show ever

  • Jeffrey G Litz jr - 3 days ago

    Smallville all the way. They best Series ever. The second best is Arrow.

  • B - 3 days ago

    OTH!!!!!! It’s the best show ever and I love it that I can’t stop watching it

  • Betty - 3 days ago

    One Tree Hill is the best and it’s not a show about a tree on a hill. OTH teaches you great lessons. Don’t be Naley and get married in high school. I can’t don’t get pregnant in high school because that happens everyday to teens. OTH for the win!!!!!!

  • Beth F - 3 days ago

    “Always and forever.” -Naley

  • Lexie - 3 days ago

    ONE TREE HILL. Hands down! Best show ever.

  • Bella M - 3 days ago

    Sorry but I’ve seen Smallville when my dad watched all the time on DVD when we had them but I thought it was boring so when he watched it I wouldn’t be in the room so I say One Tree Hill is better tbh sorry

Leave a Comment

0/4000 chars


Submit Comment

Create your own.

Opinions! We all have them. Find out what people really think with polls and surveys from Crowdsignal.