I would prefer to be able to connect to my own smp server again.
After the halloween update it's not working anymore.
(p.s. i have the latest server.exe , mc_server.jar and the latest client so don't tell me to update)
All i get now is java exceptions...
Peacegrove - 14 years ago
Server-side health is no fun with a _broken_ Server-side inventory.
Helpless - 14 years ago
I'd much rather have minecraft starting, freezing, then crashing fixed...
Kakashi - 14 years ago
@ Notch Do you know why Singleplayer has lower framerate than multiplayer? :P If i play on other server it is more smooth than playing sp :) Hope there will be some performance updates^^
Flibo - 14 years ago
What's the point in adding enemies if you only have to kill each of them once and then just duplicate the items? Inventory fixes are more important, but personally I think fixing both would be the best XD?
reason - 14 years ago
"and then Notch printed out the poll results and used it to roll a blunt after fucking his beezy"
mark - 14 years ago
Notch, try this: https://uservoice.com/
Melissa - 14 years ago
OMG Notch, you are a saint... I wish you all the best and thank you for this fun game!
snaipperi - 14 years ago
Thanks Notch for your efforts. Asking the community opinion is always neat. Personally I'm happy again when the lag-thing is gone.
Glad to see that, whilst there is a very vocal minority clamouring for inventory as a priority, SMP health is topping the poll. The lack of any real threat in SMP really does completely cheapen the experience and has meant that we haven't really bothered with our office server as, well, what's the point? There's no challenge if the SSSSSSSSSSSSSS behind you doesn't inspire fear.
Kolbias - 14 years ago
Obvs Health, Dupes and Glitches I can live with, I just want to be able to build a Fortress for the sake of building a Defensive Structure not JUST to make it look cool(that's a bonus). Mining is totally boring without having to make sure its properly lit and there are no creepers about to destroy you! Most of the time I play with friends, we get past the glitches but we hardly mine because of the lack of reward you get from doing it. There is just something really boring about being able to swim through lava to get to a diamond strain. I'd much rather fall in and die because then there is a risk, and its risks and danger that make going in to a cave on Single player fun. When you emerge from a cave in SP with a handful of diamonds and gold, clutching onto life with one heart because you didn't bring enough cooked meat with you but still coming out victorious... That's Awesome. We have all the main parts of the game: Building, Mining, even Mine carts now and they work pretty good, glitch fixes can be postponed we need the other big fun aspect of the game and thats the monsters and danger, after all it is SURVIVAL Multiplayer! :)
Ashley - 14 years ago
No more duplicating and making giant diamond pyramids? :'(
Tim - 14 years ago
I'd rather have server-side inventory, because being able to duplicate items (armor, food, weapons) lowers the risk involved in losing health.
Gary - 14 years ago
I'd be happy with the right-click bug getting fixed, for now. Health would be nice, though. I am resetting my server's map when either Health or Beta comes. Whichever comes first. Until then, we're basically playing advanced creative mode.
carlos - 14 years ago
No brainer
Fredrik - 14 years ago
Fix the server lag first, its unplayable! It's only gonna get worse if you add more server side features.
Seiseki - 14 years ago
If people cheat it's their own loss...
Health and monsters would benefit everyone.
If cheating is that much of a problem just play on private servers with friends until there's server-side inventory.
Taross - 14 years ago
I'd like to know if the prevalent javascript erroring can be seen to, whether it's an issue with java or with minecraft. I think I'd ask here since the forums are strangely mute on it.
Yeah I would much rather see SMP up and rolling. Also, you could keep people distracted... for a day. ;)
kerberox - 14 years ago
Both.
LordMortis - 14 years ago
SMP Health is much more important because we can activate monsters \o/
buddy kiddo - 14 years ago
I'd rather have health because I just want to play with my friends and not a bunch of random online pricks. My friends and I are obviously not going to exploit bugs so why should I give a fuck?
help - 14 years ago
Notch! Custom foliagecolor.png and grasscolor.png don't work with the new texture pack thing you added! And it overrides custom watch and compass graphics too!
Dan - 14 years ago
Fixing the lag issues would be nice.
Matt - 14 years ago
As a server admin I'd prefer you fix the duping and related bugs first as otherwise there is not a lot of point 'playing' as it is now. Fix the dupe / security and you have a solid foundation on which to build the rest of the game.
Otherwise for an immediate update the block lag that was introduced in the latest version is pretty bad :)
Awerty - 14 years ago
The health fix without the invent fix makes no sense. Everyone wiil have golden apples and infinte TNT. That sucks.
Diskmaster - 14 years ago
Whatever's easier to implement, so you can finish it and go to the harder item.
erik - 14 years ago
yeah, my server has been lagging since the new update too :S
Bhima - 14 years ago
Neither of those choices are important to me. The systematic lagging is more frustrating that either of those two particular issues. But having to chose one or the other I'd chose fixing existing bugs, rather than adding new features.
Coldshrike - 14 years ago
Health, definetly. I'm sick of animals running through my farm and not being able to do anything about it!
Brandon - 14 years ago
I'd love working health for my friends, won't really affect my since I have invinciblity >:D
Tryst - 14 years ago
I can't even consider playing SMP right now because of furnaces bugging out... I keep losing so much stuff to them randomly eating everything I put in them.
Thrandisher - 14 years ago
I got a bunch of friends to buy this after i wouldnt shut up about it for a few weeks. I want to be able to build giant shape objects and defend them with my buddy's againts hordes of mobs!
Would like to echo that the most important thing to me is the lag problems. Mining out a cave only to see it reappear is quite disheartening! :) I see you've got that coming, so that's nice. Thank you.
NeoTheOne - 14 years ago
@Markus Persson: Du måste ha så jävla kul. "Hmm vet inte vad jag ska börja med. Jag gör ett online poll! :D"
Adrian Petlevanny - 14 years ago
Inven bugs much more important in SMP in my opinion. Health is such low priority compared to duping, invis. items in furnaces etc. Plenty of time to shed blood!
Jon - 14 years ago
Indeed, something is lagging the new version, unless it was coincidence for me.
zrebf - 14 years ago
health pleeaaasseee multiplayer feels so fake without it :I
N4kame0 - 14 years ago
I hope we don't have too chose just one of them :P Rather just wich one your starting with
A wizard - 14 years ago
Which should I vote for, if I don't play multiplayer at all?
I would prefer to be able to connect to my own smp server again.
After the halloween update it's not working anymore.
(p.s. i have the latest server.exe , mc_server.jar and the latest client so don't tell me to update)
All i get now is java exceptions...
Server-side health is no fun with a _broken_ Server-side inventory.
I'd much rather have minecraft starting, freezing, then crashing fixed...
@ Notch Do you know why Singleplayer has lower framerate than multiplayer? :P If i play on other server it is more smooth than playing sp :) Hope there will be some performance updates^^
What's the point in adding enemies if you only have to kill each of them once and then just duplicate the items? Inventory fixes are more important, but personally I think fixing both would be the best XD?
"and then Notch printed out the poll results and used it to roll a blunt after fucking his beezy"
Notch, try this: https://uservoice.com/
OMG Notch, you are a saint... I wish you all the best and thank you for this fun game!
Thanks Notch for your efforts. Asking the community opinion is always neat. Personally I'm happy again when the lag-thing is gone.
I'd rather you get the SURVIVAL part of SURVIVAL multiplayer working as soon as possible.
hi i vill mean the mobs in smp
but with the leaves get it fixed
Both of these are these are things that are fun to take advantage of and add to the sandboxy-ness of the game.
Certain elements of health and attacking could potentially be made optional for the players to decide.
Lag *Twitch* -> Tree Decay (I'm sick of cleaning up half trees) -> Health -> Inventory
Server-side health (attack animals, monsters, other players, and carts, get hurt yourself)
I think inventory first, it's better to have it fully working than to have 2 different things not working well!
Glad to see that, whilst there is a very vocal minority clamouring for inventory as a priority, SMP health is topping the poll. The lack of any real threat in SMP really does completely cheapen the experience and has meant that we haven't really bothered with our office server as, well, what's the point? There's no challenge if the SSSSSSSSSSSSSS behind you doesn't inspire fear.
Obvs Health, Dupes and Glitches I can live with, I just want to be able to build a Fortress for the sake of building a Defensive Structure not JUST to make it look cool(that's a bonus). Mining is totally boring without having to make sure its properly lit and there are no creepers about to destroy you! Most of the time I play with friends, we get past the glitches but we hardly mine because of the lack of reward you get from doing it. There is just something really boring about being able to swim through lava to get to a diamond strain. I'd much rather fall in and die because then there is a risk, and its risks and danger that make going in to a cave on Single player fun. When you emerge from a cave in SP with a handful of diamonds and gold, clutching onto life with one heart because you didn't bring enough cooked meat with you but still coming out victorious... That's Awesome. We have all the main parts of the game: Building, Mining, even Mine carts now and they work pretty good, glitch fixes can be postponed we need the other big fun aspect of the game and thats the monsters and danger, after all it is SURVIVAL Multiplayer! :)
No more duplicating and making giant diamond pyramids? :'(
I'd rather have server-side inventory, because being able to duplicate items (armor, food, weapons) lowers the risk involved in losing health.
I'd be happy with the right-click bug getting fixed, for now. Health would be nice, though. I am resetting my server's map when either Health or Beta comes. Whichever comes first. Until then, we're basically playing advanced creative mode.
No brainer
Fix the server lag first, its unplayable! It's only gonna get worse if you add more server side features.
If people cheat it's their own loss...
Health and monsters would benefit everyone.
If cheating is that much of a problem just play on private servers with friends until there's server-side inventory.
I'd like to know if the prevalent javascript erroring can be seen to, whether it's an issue with java or with minecraft. I think I'd ask here since the forums are strangely mute on it.
Yeah I would much rather see SMP up and rolling. Also, you could keep people distracted... for a day. ;)
Both.
SMP Health is much more important because we can activate monsters \o/
I'd rather have health because I just want to play with my friends and not a bunch of random online pricks. My friends and I are obviously not going to exploit bugs so why should I give a fuck?
Notch! Custom foliagecolor.png and grasscolor.png don't work with the new texture pack thing you added! And it overrides custom watch and compass graphics too!
Fixing the lag issues would be nice.
As a server admin I'd prefer you fix the duping and related bugs first as otherwise there is not a lot of point 'playing' as it is now. Fix the dupe / security and you have a solid foundation on which to build the rest of the game.
Otherwise for an immediate update the block lag that was introduced in the latest version is pretty bad :)
The health fix without the invent fix makes no sense. Everyone wiil have golden apples and infinte TNT. That sucks.
Whatever's easier to implement, so you can finish it and go to the harder item.
yeah, my server has been lagging since the new update too :S
Neither of those choices are important to me. The systematic lagging is more frustrating that either of those two particular issues. But having to chose one or the other I'd chose fixing existing bugs, rather than adding new features.
Health, definetly. I'm sick of animals running through my farm and not being able to do anything about it!
I'd love working health for my friends, won't really affect my since I have invinciblity >:D
I can't even consider playing SMP right now because of furnaces bugging out... I keep losing so much stuff to them randomly eating everything I put in them.
I got a bunch of friends to buy this after i wouldnt shut up about it for a few weeks. I want to be able to build giant shape objects and defend them with my buddy's againts hordes of mobs!
Would like to echo that the most important thing to me is the lag problems. Mining out a cave only to see it reappear is quite disheartening! :) I see you've got that coming, so that's nice. Thank you.
@Markus Persson: Du måste ha så jävla kul. "Hmm vet inte vad jag ska börja med. Jag gör ett online poll! :D"
Inven bugs much more important in SMP in my opinion. Health is such low priority compared to duping, invis. items in furnaces etc. Plenty of time to shed blood!
Indeed, something is lagging the new version, unless it was coincidence for me.
health pleeaaasseee multiplayer feels so fake without it :I
I hope we don't have too chose just one of them :P Rather just wich one your starting with
Which should I vote for, if I don't play multiplayer at all?
Dear SantaNotch,
For Christmas I would like:
-SMP Health actually working
-Boats, even if laggy
-A pissed off weasel in a box
Love,
A Minecraft Multiplayer Player
Performance updates are coming regardless of which of these win.
(Oh, and BOTH of these are coming, I just don't know in which order yet)
item creation for pure co-op building in multiplayer is a must.
Obvious answer is obvious.
Notch, you're my poll daddy.
I'd much prefer this LAG fix! Why is the whole game lagging?! What the hell?!